The solutions to uncertainty problem of urban fractal dimension calculation
arXiv:1711.06409 · doi:10.3390/e21050453
Abstract
Fractal geometry provides a powerful tool for scale-free spatial analysis of cities, but the fractal dimension calculation results always depend on methods and scopes of study area. This phenomenon has been puzzling many researchers. This paper is devoted to discussing the problem of uncertainty of fractal dimension estimation and the potential solutions to it. Using regular fractals as archetypes, we can reveal the causes and effects of the diversity of fractal dimension estimation results by analogy. The main factors influencing fractal dimension values of cities include prefractal structure, multi-scaling fractal patterns, and self-affine fractal growth. The solution to the problem is to substitute the real fractal dimension values with comparable fractal dimensions. The main measures are as follows: First, select a proper method for a special fractal study. Second, define a proper study area for a city according to a study aim, or define comparable study areas for different cities. These suggestions may be helpful for the students who takes interest in or even have already participated in the studies of fractal cities.
arXiv comment27 pages, 3 figures, 8 tables
References in corpus (13)
- Constructing cities, deconstructing scaling laws
- How congestion shapes cities: from mobility patterns to scaling
- Multifractal methodology
- Multifractal to monofractal evolution of the London's street network
- Scaling of Geographic Space from the Perspective of City and Field Blocks and Using Volunteered Geographic Information
- Scaling: Lost in the smog
- Understanding Fractal Dimension of Urban Form through Spatial Entropy
- Fractal dimension evolution and spatial replacement dynamics of urban growth
- Fractal Analytical Approach of Urban Form Based on Spatial Correlation Function
- Defining urban and rural regions by multifractal spectrums of urbanization
- Multi-Scaling Allometric Analysis for Urban and Regional Development
- Spatial Measures of Urban Systems: from Entropy to Fractal Dimension
- The spatial meaning of Pareto's scaling exponent of city-size distribution