Scaling: Lost in the smog

Abstract

In this commentary we discuss the validity of scaling laws and their relevance for understanding urban systems and helping policy makers. We show how the recent controversy about the scaling of CO2 transport-related emissions with population size, where different authors reach contradictory conclusions, is symptomatic of the lack of understanding of the underlying mechanisms. In particular, we highlight different sources of errors, ranging from incorrect estimate of CO2 to problems related with the definition of cities. We argue here that while data are necessary to build of a new science of cities, they are not enough: they have to go hand in hand with a theoretical understanding of the main processes. This effort of building models whose predictions agree with data is the prerequisite for a science of cities. In the meantime, policy advice are, at best, a shot in the dark.

arXiv comment2 pages, 1 figure

References in corpus (4)

• Economics need a scientific revolution
• How congestion shapes cities: from mobility patterns to scaling
• Large cities are less green
• Modeling the polycentric transition of cities

Cited by in corpus (21)

• The statistical physics of Cities
• From global scaling to the dynamics of individual cities
• Is this scaling nonlinear?
• Comparing and modeling land use organization in cities
• Statistical laws in linguistics
• Evolution of urban scaling: evidence from Brazil
• Scale-adjusted metrics for predicting the evolution of urban indicators and quantifying the performance of cities
• Fractal Modeling and Fractal Dimension Description of Urban Morphology
• Understanding the mesoscopic scaling patterns within cities
• Modeling Growth Curve of Fractal Dimension of Urban Form of Beijing
• Fractal Dimensions Derived from Spatial Allometric Scaling of Urban Form
• More crime in cities? On the scaling laws of crime and the inadequacy of per capita rankings -- a cross-country study
• Multi-Scaling Allometric Analysis for Urban and Regional Development
• Cities as nuclei of sustainability?
• Spatial interactions in urban scaling laws
• The solutions to uncertainty problem of urban fractal dimension calculation
• Exploring the Level of Urbanization Based on Zipf's Scaling Exponent
• Hierarchical Scaling in Systems of Natural Cities
• Two Sets of Simple Formulae to Estimating Fractal Dimension of Irregular Boundaries
• Spatial Dynamics of Urban Growth Based on Entropy and Fractal Dimension
• Characteristic Scales, Scaling, and Geospatial Analysis