Paradoxical Interpretations of Urban Scaling Laws

Abstract

Scaling laws are powerful summaries of the variations of urban attributes with city size. However, the validity of their universal meaning for cities is hampered by the observation that different scaling regimes can be encountered for the same territory, time and attribute, depending on the criteria used to delineate cities. The aim of this paper is to present new insights concerning this variation, coupled with a sensitivity analysis of urban scaling in France, for several socio-economic and infrastructural attributes from data collected exhaustively at the local level. The sensitivity analysis considers different aggregations of local units for which data are given by the Population Census. We produce a large variety of definitions of cities (approximatively 5000) by aggregating local Census units corresponding to the systematic combination of three definitional criteria: density, commuting flows and population cutoffs. We then measure the magnitude of scaling estimations and their sensitivity to city definitions for several urban indicators, showing for example that simple population cutoffs impact dramatically on the results obtained for a given system and attribute. Variations are interpreted with respect to the meaning of the attributes (socio-economic descriptors as well as infrastructure) and the urban definitions used (understood as the combination of the three criteria). Because of the Modifiable Areal Unit Problem and of the heterogeneous morphologies and social landscapes in the cities internal space, scaling estimations are subject to large variations, distorting many of the conclusions on which generative models are based. We conclude that examining scaling variations might be an opportunity to understand better the inner composition of cities with regard to their size, i.e. to link the scales of the city-system with the system of cities.

References in corpus (2)

• Scaling and universality in the micro-structure of urban space
• Scaling and allometry in the building geometries of Greater London

Cited by in corpus (21)

• From global scaling to the dynamics of individual cities
• Defining urban agglomerations to detect agglomeration economies
• Evolution of urban scaling: evidence from Brazil
• Rural to urban population density scaling of crime and property transactions in English and Welsh Parliamentary Constituencies
• More crime in cities? On the scaling laws of crime and the inadequacy of per capita rankings -- a cross-country study
• Constructing multi-level urban clusters based on population distributions and interactions
• On the relation between Transversal and Longitudinal Scaling in Cities
• Mobile phone indicators and their relation to the socioeconomic organisation of cities
• Unveiling Relationships Between Crime and Property in England and Wales Via Density Scale-Adjusted Metrics and Network Tools
• City limits in the age of smartphones and urban scaling
• Spatial regionalization based on optimal information compression
• Scaling Behavior of Public Procurement Activity
• Cross-sectional Urban Scaling Fails in Predicting Temporal Growth of Cities
• On the parametric description of log-growth rates of cities' sizes of four European countries and the USA
• Perspectives on urban theories
• Individual-level evolutions manifest population-level scaling in complex supply networks
• Cities as they could be: Artificial Life and Urban Systems
• Multi-dimensional Urban Network Percolation
• Observing cities as a complex system
• Change of impervious space in German cities: A scaling law analysis
• Prediction of 'artificial' urban archetypes at the pedestrian-scale through a synthesis of domain expertise with machine learning methods