Cross-sectional Urban Scaling Fails in Predicting Temporal Growth of Cities

Abstract

Numerous urban indicators scale with population in a power law across cities, but whether the cross-sectional scaling law is applicable to the temporal growth of individual cities is unclear. Here we first find two paradoxical scaling relationships that urban built-up area sub-linearly scales with population across cities, but super-linearly scales with population over time in most individual cities because urban land expands faster than population grows. Different cities have diverse temporal scaling exponents and one city even has opposite temporal scaling regimes during two periods, strongly supporting the absence of single temporal scaling and further illustrating the failure of cross-sectional urban scaling in predicting temporal growth of cities. We propose a conceptual model that can clarify the essential difference and also connections between the cross-sectional scaling law and temporal trajectories of cities. Our model shows that cities have an extra growth of built-up area over time besides the supposed growth predicted by the cross-sectional scaling law. Disparities of extra growth among different-sized cities change the cross-sectional scaling exponent. Further analyses of GDP and other indicators confirm the contradiction between cross-sectional and temporal scaling relationships and the validity of the conceptual model. Our findings may open a new avenue towards the science of cities.

References in corpus (12)

• Constructing cities, deconstructing scaling laws
• Scaling laws of human interaction activity
• Paradoxical Interpretations of Urban Scaling Laws
• Distance to the scaling law: a useful approach for unveiling relationships between crime and urban metrics
• The statistical physics of Cities
• From global scaling to the dynamics of individual cities
• Urban Geography and Scaling of Contemporary Indian Cities
• Evolution of urban scaling: evidence from Brazil
• Rich and Poor Cities in Europe. Urban Scaling to Mapping European Economic Convergence
• Scale-adjusted metrics for predicting the evolution of urban indicators and quantifying the performance of cities
• Urban Scaling of Cities in the Netherlands
• Superlinear and sublinear urban scaling in geographical network model of the city