Problem of Time in Quantum Gravity

Abstract

The Problem of Time occurs because the `time' of GR and of ordinary Quantum Theory are mutually incompatible notions. This is problematic in trying to replace these two branches of physics with a single framework in situations in which the conditions of both apply, e.g. in black holes or in the very early universe. Emphasis in this Review is on the Problem of Time being multi-faceted and on the nature of each of the eight principal facets. Namely, the Frozen Formalism Problem, Configurational Relationalism Problem (formerly Sandwich Problem), Foliation Dependence Problem, Constraint Closure Problem (formerly Functional Evolution Problem), Multiple Choice Problem, Global Problem of Time, Problem of Beables (alias Problem of Observables) and Spacetime Reconstruction/Replacement Problem. Strategizing in this Review is not just centred about the Frozen Formalism Problem facet, but rather about each of the eight facets. Particular emphasis is placed upon A) relationalism as an underpinning of the facets and as a selector of particular strategies (especially a modification of Barbour relationalism, though also with some consideration of Rovelli relationalism). B) Classifying approaches by the full ordering in which they embrace constrain, quantize, find time/history and find observables, rather than only by partial orderings such as "Dirac-quantize". C) Foliation (in)dependence and Spacetime Reconstruction for a wide range of physical theories, strategizing centred about the Problem of Beables, the Patching Approach to the Global Problem of Time, and the role of the question-types considered in physics. D) The Halliwell- and Gambini-Porto-Pullin-type combined Strategies in the context of semiclassical quantum cosmology.

Invited Review: 26 pages including 2 Figures. This v2 has a number of minor improvements and corrections

References in corpus (89)

• Quantum Gravity at a Lifshitz Point
• Classical Equations for Quantum Systems
• Spectral Dimension of the Universe in Quantum Gravity at a Lifshitz Point
• Real Ashtekar Variables for Lorentzian Signature Space-times
• The Spin Foam Approach to Quantum Gravity
• A healthy extension of Horava gravity
• Loop Quantum Cosmology
• Dust as a Standard of Space and Time in Canonical Quantum Gravity
• Quantum Gravity: a Progress Report
• Geometrodynamics of Schwarzschild Black Holes
• Conformal ``thin sandwich'' data for the initial-value problem of general relativity
• Partial and Complete Observables for Hamiltonian Constrained Systems
• Partial and Complete Observables for Canonical General Relativity
• Problem of Time in Quantum Gravity
• Lorentzian spin foam amplitudes: graphical calculus and asymptotics
• Quantum Logic and the Histories Approach to Quantum Theory
• Extended Horava gravity and Einstein-aether theory
• Quantum temporal logic and decoherence functionals in the histories approach to generalised quantum theory
• Relativity without relativity
• A Topos Foundation for Theories of Physics: I. Formal Languages for Physics
• Reduced Phase Space Quantization and Dirac Observables
• Conditional probabilities with Dirac observables and the problem of time in quantum gravity
• Spectral geometry as a probe of quantum spacetime
• Continuous Histories and the History Group in Generalised Quantum Theory
• `What is a Thing?': Topos Theory in the Foundations of Physics
• Cuscuton and low energy limit of Horava-Lifshitz gravity
• An effective approach to the problem of time
• Effective approach to the problem of time: general features and examples
• CDT meets Horava-Lifshitz gravity
• GPS observables in general relativity
• Fundamental decoherence from quantum gravity: a pedagogical review
• The physical gravitational degrees of freedom
• Physical evolution in Loop Quantum Cosmology: The example of vacuum Bianchi I
• Somewhere in the Universe: Where is the Information Stored When Histories Decohere?
• The Problem of Time and Quantum Cosmology in the Relational Particle Mechanics Arena
• U(N) Coherent States for Loop Quantum Gravity
• General Covariance in Gravity at a Lifshitz Point
• The Semiclassical Limit of Causal Dynamical Triangulations
• Proof of the Thin Sandwich Conjecture
• Quantizing Horava-Lifshitz Gravity via Causal Dynamical Triangulations
• On the consistency of the constraint algebra in spin network quantum gravity
• Loop constraints: A habitat and their algebra
• Probabilities in Quantum Cosmological Models: A Decoherent Histories Analysis Using a Complex Potential
• Constraints and gauge transformations: Dirac's theorem is not always valid
• Effective relational dynamics of a nonintegrable cosmological model
• Foundations of Relational Particle Dynamics
• Is General Relativity an 'Already Parametrized' Field Theory?
• Life in an Energy Eigenstate: Decoherent Histories Analysis of a Model Timeless Universe
• Causal Dynamical Triangulations and the Quest for Quantum Gravity
• Gravitational Constraints which Generate a Lie Algebra
• Directions in Causal Set Quantum Gravity
• Einstein-aether gravity: a status report
• Covariant gauge fixing and Kuchar decomposition
• On Relativistic Material Reference Systems
• Sensible Quantum Mechanics: Are Probabilities only in the Mind?
• Stable Homology as an Indicator of Manifoldlikeness in Causal Set Theory
• Emergent Semiclassical Time in Quantum Gravity. I. Mechanical Models
• The role of time in relational quantum theories
• On the Groenewold-Van Hove problem for R^{2n}
• Group quantization of parametrized systems I. Time levels
• Time and Time Functions in Parametrized Non-Relativistic Quantum Mechanics
• Emergence of spatial structure from causal sets
• Elements of Loop Quantum Cosmology
• Invariant Class Operators in the Decoherent Histories Analysis of Timeless Quantum Theories
• Decoherent Histories Analysis of Minisuperspace Quantum Cosmology
• Records Theory
• Topos theory and `neo-realist' quantum theory
• General relativity histories theory II: Invariance groups
• Does relationalism alone control geometrodynamics with sources?
• Minisuperspace Models in Histories Theory
• Poincare' invariance for continuous-time histories
• Approaching the Problem of Time with a Combined Semiclassical-Records-Histories Scheme
• Jacobi's Principle and the Disappearance of Time
• Seminar on Records Theory
• On the Semiclassical Approach to Quantum Cosmology
• Shape dynamics and Mach's principles: Gravity from conformal geometrodynamics
• Unitary and non-unitary evolution in quantum cosmology
• Covariance and Time Regained in Canonical General Relativity
• Diffeomorphisms as Symplectomorphisms in History Phase Space: Bosonic String Model
• Perennials and the Group-Theoretical Quantization of a Parametrized Scalar Field on a Curved Background
• Quantum Machian Time in Toy Models of Gravity
• Continuous Time in Consistent Histories
• Challenges for Emergent Gravity
• Cosmological Time in Quantum Supergravity
• Relational Quadrilateralland. Analogues of Isospin and Hypercharge
• A Topos Formulation of Consistent Histories
• Quantum gravity as a group field theory: a sketch
• Shape Dynamics
• General Relativity without paradigm of space-time covariance, and resolution of the problem of time

Cited by in corpus (144)

• Problem of Time in Quantum Gravity
• Quantum cosmology: a review
• Time from quantum entanglement: an experimental illustration
• Conceptual Problems in Quantum Gravity and Quantum Cosmology
• Avoiding singularities in Lorentzian-Euclidean black holes: the role of atemporality
• Critical evaluation of common claims in loop quantum cosmology
• Singularity resolution depends on the clock
• Beables/Observables in Classical and Quantum Gravity
• Time Remains
• Unitarity, clock dependence and quantum recollapse in quantum cosmology
• Can chaos be observed in quantum gravity?
• Change in Hamiltonian General Relativity from the Lack of a Time-like Killing Vector Field
• Gravity with more or less gauging
• Higher-order theories of gravity: diagnosis, extraction and reformulation via non-metric extra degrees of freedom
• Problem of Time and Background Independence: the Individual Facets
• History state formalism for scalar particles
• Bouncing Unitary Cosmology I: Mini-Superspace General Solution
• The role of time in relational quantum theories
• Superpositions of the cosmological constant allow for singularity resolution and unitary evolution in quantum cosmology
• Symmetry and Evolution in Quantum Gravity
• Schrodinger Evolution for the Universe: Reparametrization
• Classical Machian Resolution of the Spacetime Reconstruction Problem
• The equivalent emergence of time dependence in classical and quantum mechanics
• Scalar field quantum cosmology: a Schrödinger picture
• Quantum empty Bianchi I spacetime with internal time
• Quantum fluctuations in the effective relational GFT cosmology
• Quantum Time: experimental multi-time correlations
• Quantization of systems with temporally varying discretization II: Local evolution moves
• Approaching the Problem of Time with a Combined Semiclassical-Records-Histories Scheme
• Quantum Null Geometry and Gravity
• Quantization of systems with temporally varying discretization I: Evolving Hilbert spaces
• A Local Resolution of the Problem of Time
• Machian Time Is To Be Abstracted From What Change?
• Explicit partial and functional differential equations for beables or observables
• The Solution to the Problem of Time in Shape Dynamics
• The Smallest Shape Spaces. I. Shape Theory Posed, with Example of 3 Points on the Line
• Hamiltonian group field theory with multiple scalar matter fields
• On Types of Observables in Constrained Theories
• The Smallest Shape Spaces. III. Triangles in 2- and 3-d
• Quantum to classical transition in the Hořava-Lifshitz quantum cosmology
• The Smallest Shape Spaces. II. 4 Points in 1-d Suffices to have a Complex Background-Independent Theory of Inhomogeneity
• Configuration Spaces in Fundamental Physics
• On Background Independence
• TRiPoD (Temporal Relationalism incorporating Principles of Dynamics)
• Geometric relational framework for general-relativistic gauge field theories
• Timelessness strictly inside the Quantum Realm
• Relational time in anyonic systems
• Loop quantum cosmology and singularities
• Scale Anomaly as the Origin of Time
• Tunneling in attosecond optical ionization and a dynamical time operator
• Quantum cosmological intertwining: Factor ordering and boundary conditions from hidden symmetries
• Shape Theory. III. Comparative Theory of Backgound Independence
• Quantum Motion on Shape Space and the Gauge Dependent Emergence of Dynamics and Probability in Absolute Space and Time
• A Local Resolution of the Problem of Time. III. The other classical facets piecemeal
• Dirac observables and boundary proposals in quantum cosmology
• Relating dust reference models to conventional systems in manifestly gauge invariant perturbation theory
• Specific PDEs for Preserved Quantities in Geometry. I. Similarities and Subgroups
• Kendall's Shape Statistics as a Classical Realization of Barbour-type Timeless Records Theory approach to Quantum Gravity
• Big Bang Singularity Resolution In Quantum Cosmology
• From path integrals to the Wheeler-DeWitt equation: Time evolution in spacetimes with a spatial boundary
• A Local Resolution of the Problem of Time. I. Introduction and Temporal Relationalism
• A Local Resolution of the Problem of Time. IV. Quantum outline and piecemeal Conclusion
• Origin of Structure in the Universe: Quantum Cosmology Reconsidered
• A Local Resolution of the Problem of Time. V. Combining Temporal and Configurational Relationalism for Finite Theories
• Multi-Dimensional Cosmology and GUP
• A Local Resolution of the Problem of Time. IX. Spacetime Constructability
• Spaces of Observables from Solving PDEs. I. Translation-Invariant Theory
• Is it time to rethink quantum gravity?
• Relativistic free motion time of arrival operator for massive spin-0 particles with positive energy
• The problem of time in quantum mechanics
• Chaos, Dirac observables and constraint quantization
• A Local Resolution of the Problem of Time. VII. Constraint Closure
• Geometry from Brackets Consistency
• Quantum supersymmetric FRW cosmology with a scalar field
• $N$-Body Problem: Minimal $N$'s for Qualitative Nontrivialities
• Relational evolution with oscillating clocks
• Monopoles of Twelve Types in 3-Body Problems
• Unitarity and quantum resolution of gravitational singularities
• Quantum resolution of the cosmological singularity without new physics
• Machian Classical and Semiclassical Emergent Time
• Problem of Time: Facets and Machian Strategy
• A Local Resolution of the Problem of Time. XIV. Grounding on Lie's Mathematics
• Problem of Time and Background Independence: classical version's higher Lie Theory
• Clock Time in Quantum Cosmology
• Quantum Cosmology will need to become a Numerical Subject
• Specific PDEs for Preserved Quantities in Geometry. III. 1-d Projective Transformations and Subgroups
• Specific PDEs for Preserved Quantities in Geometry. II. Affine Transformations and Subgroups
• A one-particle time of arrival operator for a free relativistic spin-0 charged particle in (1+1) dimensions
• Classical and statistical limits of the quantum singular oscillator
• Self-Adjoint Time Operator of a Quantum Field
• Basic issues of conservative approaches to quantum theory of gravity
• Finite Mathematics, Finite Quantum Theory And A Conjecture On The Nature Of Time
• "Time"-covariant Schrödinger equation and the canonical quantization of the Reissner-Nordström black hole
• Space-time-symmetric extension of quantum mechanics: Interpretation and arrival-time predictions
• Regarding the `Hole Argument' and the `Problem of Time'
• Where to Apply Relationalism
• Problem of Time: Temporal Relationalism Compatibility of Other Local Classical Facets Completed
• Quantum Cosmology with many fluids and the choice of cosmological time
• Evidence of time evolution in quantum gravity
• Nijenhuis-type variants of Local Theory of Background Independence
• Background Independence: ${\mathbb{S}}^1$ and $\mathbb{R}$ absolute spaces differ greatly in Shape-and-Scale Theory
• Topological Shape Theory
• Low-curvature quantum corrections from unitary evolution of de Sitter space
• $\Psi$-Epistemic Quantum Cosmology?
• Quantum Schwarzschild-(A)dS Black Holes: Unitarity and Singularity Resolution
• Spontaneous collapse models lead to the emergence of classicality of the Universe
• Decoherent Histories of Spin Networks
• A Relativistic One-Particle Time of Arrival Operator for a Free Spin-1/2 Particle in (1 + 1) Dimensions
• The time as an emergent property of quantum mechanics, a synthetic description of a first experimental approach
• Nambu variant of Local Resolution of Problem of Time and Background Independence
• Quantum Time and the Time-Dilation induced Interaction Transfer mechanism
• Analyzing quantum gravity spillover in the semiclassical regime
• Rubber Relationalism: Smallest Graph-Theoretically Nontrivial Leibniz Spaces
• Towards a Probabilistic Foundation of Relativistic Quantum Theory: The One-Body Born Rule in Curved Spacetime
• Spacetime boundaries do not break diffeomorphism and gauge symmetries
• Bouncing and Cyclic Quantum Primordial Universes and the Ordering Problem
• Phenomenological inflationary model in Supersymmetric Quantum Cosmology
• Finite Mathematics, Finite Quantum Theory and Applications to Gravity and Particle Theory
• We have time because we shall never know
• Covariant Space Time Line Elements in the Friedmann Lemaitre Robertson Walker Geometry
• Emergent Lorentzian dispersion relations from a Euclidean scalar-tensor theory
• Geometry and proper time of a relativistic quantum clock
• Moments and saturation properties of eigenstates
• Clock-dependent spacetime
• 'Shape Dynamics': Foundations Reassessed
• Quadrilaterals in Shape Theory. II. Alternative Derivations of Shape Space: Successes and Limitations
• Spacetime Quanta? : The Discrete Spectrum of a Quantum Spacetime Four-Volume Operator in Unimodular Loop Quantum Cosmology
• Lie Theory suffices to understand, and Locally Resolve, the Problem of Time
• Wheeler-DeWitt Universe Wave Function in the presence of stiff matter
• Relational Time as a Stochastic Variable in ADM Gravity
• Relational Quadrilateralland. II. The Quantum Theory
• Quantum cosmology in teleparallel gravity with a boundary term
• Cosmic time and the initial state of the universe
• Introdução à Cosmologia Quântica
• A Quantum Informational Approach to the Problem of Time
• Aspects of Quantum Cosmology
• Comparative Theory of Background Independence
• Problem of Time in Slightly Inhomogeneous Cosmology
• A Local Resolution of the Problem of Time. VIII. Assignment of Observables
• Isotropy Groups and Kinematic Orbits for 1 and 2-$d$ $N$-Body Problems
• Singularity avoidance from path integral
• A theory of time based on wavefunction collapse
• A quantum theory of gravity
• Operator Ordering in the Relativistic Quantization: Specific Heat in the Rindler Frame