Regarding the `Hole Argument' and the `Problem of Time'

Abstract

The canonical formalism of general relativity affords a particularly interesting characterisation of the infamous hole argument. It also provides a natural formalism in which to relate the hole argument to the problem of time in classical and quantum gravity. In this paper, we examine the connection between these two much discussed problems in the foundations of spacetime theory along two interrelated lines. First, from a formal perspective, we consider the extent to which the two problems can and cannot be precisely and distinctly characterised. Second, from a philosophical perspective, we consider the implications of various responses to the problems, with a particular focus upon the viability of a `deflationary' attitude to the relationalist/substantivalist debate regarding the ontology of spacetime. Conceptual and formal inadequacies within the representative language of canonical gravity will be shown to be at the heart of both the canonical hole argument and the problem of time. Interesting and fruitful work at the interface of physics and philosophy relates to the challenge of resolving such inadequacies.

arXiv comment20 pages (+ references)

References in corpus (24)

• The Spin Foam Approach to Quantum Gravity
• Spin Foam Models
• Dynamically Triangulating Lorentzian Quantum Gravity
• Partial and Complete Observables for Hamiltonian Constrained Systems
• Partial and Complete Observables for Canonical General Relativity
• Problem of Time in Quantum Gravity
• The Phoenix Project: Master Constraint Programme for Loop Quantum Gravity
• Einstein gravity as a 3D conformally invariant theory
• On the Generality of Refined Algebraic Quantization
• Why Gauge?
• The physical gravitational degrees of freedom
• Scale-Invariant Gravity: Particle Dynamics
• Discrete Lorentzian Quantum Gravity
• Scale-Invariant Gravity: Geometrodynamics
• Change in Hamiltonian General Relativity from the Lack of a Time-like Killing Vector Field
• A First Class Constraint Generates Not a Gauge Transformation, But a Bad Physical Change: The Case of Electromagnetism
• The Generalized Thin-Sandwich Problem and its Local Solvability
• The role of time in relational quantum theories
• Symmetry and Evolution in Quantum Gravity
• Schrodinger Evolution for the Universe: Reparametrization
• On the geometry of quantum constrained systems
• The Solution to the Problem of Time in Shape Dynamics
• Rosenfeld, Bergmann, Dirac and the Invention of Constrained Hamiltonian Dynamics
• Chaos, Dirac observables and constraint quantization