Chaos, Dirac observables and constraint quantization
arXiv:1508.01947
Abstract
There is good evidence that full general relativity is non-integrable or even chaotic. We point out the severe repercussions: differentiable Dirac observables and a reduced phase space do not exist in non-integrable constrained systems and are thus unlikely to occur in a generic general relativistic context. Instead, gauge invariant quantities generally become discontinuous, thus not admitting Poisson-algebraic structures and posing serious challenges to a quantization. Non-integrability also renders the paradigm of relational dynamics cumbersome, thereby straining common interpretations of the dynamics. We illustrate these conceptual and technical challenges with simple toy models. In particular, we exhibit reparametrization invariant models which fail to be integrable and, as a consequence, can either not be quantized with standard methods or lead to sick quantum theories without a semiclassical limit. These troubles are qualitatively distinct from semiclassical subtleties in unconstrained quantum chaos and can be directly traced back to the scarcity of Dirac observables. As a possible resolution, we propose to change the method of quantization by refining the configuration space topology until the generalized observables become continuous in the new topology and can acquire a quantum representation. This leads to the polymer quantization method underlying loop quantum cosmology and gravity. Remarkably, the polymer quantum theory circumvents the problems of the quantization with smooth topology, indicating that non-integrability and chaos, while a challenge, may not be a fundamental obstruction for quantum gravity.
arXiv comment48 pages, 9 figures, lots of discussion
References in corpus (50)
- Quantum Gravity at a Lifshitz Point
- A bound on chaos
- The Dynamics of General Relativity
- Loop Quantum Cosmology: A Status Report
- Dust as a Standard of Space and Time in Canonical Quantum Gravity
- Partial observables
- Partial and Complete Observables for Hamiltonian Constrained Systems
- Problem of Time in Quantum Gravity
- Observables in effective gravity
- Time and a physical Hamiltonian for quantum gravity
- Polymer Quantum Mechanics and its Continuum Limit
- The mixmaster universe is chaotic
- The mixmaster universe: A chaotic Farey tale
- Gravitational Observables and Local Symmetries
- An effective approach to the problem of time
- Effective approach to the problem of time: general features and examples
- Canonical Quantum Gravity
- Relational Observables in Gravity: a Review
- Complementarity of representations in quantum mechanics
- Testing the Master Constraint Programme for Loop Quantum Gravity I. General Framework
- Physical evolution in Loop Quantum Cosmology: The example of vacuum Bianchi I
- The projector on physical states in loop quantum gravity
- Asymptotic conservation laws in field theory
- Classification of Generalized Symmetries for the Vacuum Einstein Equations
- A perturbative approach to Dirac observables and their space-time algebra
- A new vacuum for Loop Quantum Gravity
- Canonical quantization of general relativity in discrete space-times
- Hamiltonian structure of Horava gravity
- From covariant to canonical formulations of discrete gravity
- Beables/Observables in Classical and Quantum Gravity
- Effective relational dynamics of a nonintegrable cosmological model
- Chaos in Quantum Cosmology
- Mixmaster chaos
- Is General Relativity an 'Already Parametrized' Field Theory?
- Symmetries of the Einstein Equations
- Uniform discretizations: a new approach for the quantization of totally constrained systems
- Refined Algebraic Quantization: Systems with a single constraint
- Simplest cosmological model with the scalar field
- A Shape Dynamics Tutorial
- Polymer quantization of the free scalar field and its classical limit
- The present moment in quantum cosmology: challenges to the arguments for the elimination of time
- Group Averaging and Refined Algebraic Quantization: Where are we now?
- Dirac-like approach for consistent discretizations of classical constrained theories
- Refined Algebraic Quantization in the oscillator representation of SL(2,R)
- Discretisations, Constraints and Diffeomorphisms in Quantum Gravity
- Diffeomorphism symmetry in quantum gravity models
- Time evolution of observable properties of parametrized systems
- Solving the Problem of Time in Mini-superspace: Measurement of Dirac Observables
- Pentahedral volume, chaos, and quantum gravity
- Evolving Constants of Motion
Cited by in corpus (9)
- The Trinity of Relational Quantum Dynamics
- Switching quantum reference frames in the N-body problem and the absence of global relational perspectives
- Can chaos be observed in quantum gravity?
- Stochastic Emergent Quantum Gravity
- Quantization of dynamical symplectic reduction
- Perspective-neutral approach to quantum frame covariance for general symmetry groups
- Regarding the `Hole Argument' and the `Problem of Time'
- Observable currents in lattice field theories
- A Local Resolution of the Problem of Time. VIII. Assignment of Observables