Problem of Time: Facets and Machian Strategy
arXiv:1306.5816 · doi:10.1111/nyas.12510
Abstract
The Problem of Time is that `time' in each of ordinary quantum theory and general relativity are mutually incompatible notions. This causes difficulties in trying to put these two theories together to form a theory of Quantum Gravity. The Problem of Time has 8 facets in canonical approaches. I clarify that all but one of these facets already occur at the classical level, and reconceptualize and re-name some of these facets as follows.The Frozen Formalism Problem becomes Temporal Relationalism, the Thin Sandwich Problem becomes Configurational Relationalism, via the notion of Best Matching. The Problem of Observables becomes the Problem of Beables, and the Functional Evolution Problem becomes the Constraint Closure Problem. I also outline how each of the Global and Multiple-Choice Problems of Time have their own plurality of facets. This article additionally contains a local resolution to the Problem of Time at the conceptual level and which is actually realizable for the relational triangle and minisuperspace models. This resolution is, moreover, Machian, and has three levels: classical, semiclassical and a combined semiclassical-histories-timeless records scheme. I end by delineating the current frontiers of this program toward resolution of the Problem of Time in the cases of full GR and of slightly inhomogeneous cosmology.
arXiv commentLonger version (more introductory explanations of problem of time's terminology, more references), as Accepted by `Annals of the New York Academy of Sciences'
References in corpus (44)
- The Dynamics of General Relativity
- Decoherence, the measurement problem, and interpretations of quantum mechanics
- Problem of Time in Quantum Gravity
- Relativity without relativity
- Continuous Histories and the History Group in Generalised Quantum Theory
- `What is a Thing?': Topos Theory in the Foundations of Physics
- Quantum Gravitational Contributions to the CMB Anisotropy Spectrum
- The Problem of Time in Quantum Gravity
- The physical gravitational degrees of freedom
- The Problem of Time and Quantum Cosmology in the Relational Particle Mechanics Arena
- Revisiting observables in generally covariant theories in the light of gauge fixing methods
- On the modification of the cosmic microwave background anisotropy spectrum from canonical quantum gravity
- Probabilities in Quantum Cosmological Models: A Decoherent Histories Analysis Using a Complex Potential
- Beables/Observables in Classical and Quantum Gravity
- A First Class Constraint Generates Not a Gauge Transformation, But a Bad Physical Change: The Case of Electromagnetism
- The Quantum Measurement Problem: State of Play
- Observables in classical canonical gravity: folklore demystified
- Frequently asked questions about Shape Dynamics
- The issue of time in generally covariant theories and the Komar-Bergmann approach to observables in general relativity
- New interpretation of variational principles for gauge theories. I. Cyclic coordinate alternative to ADM split
- Classical Machian Resolution of the Spacetime Reconstruction Problem
- Can effects of quantum gravity be observed in the cosmic microwave background?
- Decoherent Histories Analysis of Minisuperspace Quantum Cosmology
- Records Theory
- Approaching the Problem of Time with a Combined Semiclassical-Records-Histories Scheme
- Machian Time Is To Be Abstracted From What Change?
- Pitfalls of Path Integrals: Amplitudes for Spacetime Regions and the Quantum Zeno Effect
- Consciousness and the Quantum
- On the Semiclassical Approach to Quantum Cosmology
- On Background Independence
- Shape dynamics and Mach's principles: Gravity from conformal geometrodynamics
- Seminar on Records Theory
- Kendall's Shape Statistics as a Classical Realization of Barbour-type Timeless Records Theory approach to Quantum Gravity
- Minisuperspace model of Machian Resolution of Problem of Time. I. Isotropic Case
- A loop quantum multiverse?
- Gravitational observables, intrinsic coordinates, and canonical maps
- Relational Motivation for Conformal Operator Ordering in Quantum Cosmology
- Machian Classical and Semiclassical Emergent Time
- Quantum Cosmological Metroland Model
- Scaled Triangleland Model of Quantum Cosmology
- Quantum Cosmology will need to become a Numerical Subject
- Shape Space Methods for Quantum Cosmological Triangleland
- Quantum Cosmological Relational Model of Shape and Scale in 1-d
- Exact Phase Space Localized Projectors from Energy Eigenstates