Type Ia Single Degenerate Survivors Must Be Overluminous
arXiv:1205.5028 · doi:10.1088/0004-637X/765/2/150
Abstract
In the single-degenerate (SD) channel of a Type Ia supernovae (SN Ia) explosion, a main-sequence (MS) donor star survives the explosion but it is stripped of mass and shock heated. An essentially unavoidable consequence of mass loss during the explosion is that the companion must have an overextended envelope after the explosion. While this has been noted previously, it has not been strongly emphasized as an inevitable consequence. We calculate the future evolution of the companion by injecting 2-6 10^47 ergs into the stellar evolution model of a 1 Msun donor star based on the post-explosion progenitors seen in simulations. We find that, due to the Kelvin-Helmholtz collapse of the envelope, the companion must become significantly more luminous (10 - 10^3 Lsun) for a long period of time (10^3 - 10^4 years). The lack of such a luminous "leftover" star in the LMC supernova remnant SNR 0609-67.5 provides another piece of evidence against the SD scenario. We also show that none of the stars proposed as the survivors of the Tycho supernova, including Tycho G, could plausibly be the donor star. Additionally, luminous donors closer than ~10 Mpc should be observable with the Hubble Space Telescope starting ~2 years post-peak. Such systems include SN 1937C, SN 1972E, SN 1986G, and SN 2011fe. Thus, the SD channel is already ruled out for at least two nearby SNe Ia and can be easily tested for a number of additional ones. We also discuss similar implications for the companions of core-collapse SNe.
arXiv comment22 pages, 5 figures. Accepted to ApJ. For a brief video explaining this paper, see http://youtu.be/MycQn5BPKmI
References in corpus (66)
- Observational Evidence from Supernovae for an Accelerating Universe and a Cosmological Constant
- Measurements of Omega and Lambda from 42 High-Redshift Supernovae
- Modules for Experiments in Stellar Astrophysics (MESA)
- Evolution of asymptotic giant branch stars II. Optical to far-infrared isochrones with improved TP-AGB models
- The Palomar Transient Factory: System Overview, Performance and First Results
- Observational Constraints on the Nature of the Dark Energy: First Cosmological Results from the ESSENCE Supernova Survey
- Supernova Constraints and Systematic Uncertainties from the First 3 Years of the Supernova Legacy Survey
- First-year Sloan Digital Sky Survey-II (SDSS-II) Supernova Results: Hubble Diagram and Cosmological Parameters
- The Supernova Legacy Survey 3-year sample: Type Ia Supernovae photometric distances and cosmological constraints
- Supernova 2011fe from an Exploding Carbon-Oxygen White Dwarf Star
- Type Ib/c supernovae in binary systems I. Evolution and properties of the progenitor stars
- Seeing the Collision of a Supernova with its Companion Star
- Progenitors of type Ia supernovae
- Type Ia Supernova Explosions in Binary Systems: The Impact on the Secondary Star and its Consequences
- Using SN Ia Light Curve Shapes to Measure The Hubble Constant
- Constraints on the Progenitor System of the Type Ia Supernova SN 2011fe/PTF11kly
- The Cassiopeia A Supernova was of Type IIB
- A Compact Degenerate Primary-Star Progenitor of SN 2011fe
- The binary progenitor of Tycho Brahe's 1572 supernova
- Constraints on the Physics of Type Ia Supernovae from the X-Ray Spectrum of the Tycho Supernova Remnant
- Constraining Type Ia supernova models: SN 2011fe as a test case
- On the evolution of rapidly rotating massive white dwarfs towards supernovae or collapses
- Constraining the Type Ia Supernova Progenitor: The Search for Hydrogen in Nebular Spectra
- Cepheid Distances to SNe Ia Host Galaxies based on a Revised Photometric Zero-Point of the HST-WFPC2 and New P-L Relations and Metallicity Corrections
- A New Cepheid Distance to the Giant Spiral M101 Based On Image Subtraction of HST/ACS Observations
- EVLA Observations Constrain the Environment and Progenitor System of Type Ia Supernova 2011fe
- Are the Models for Type Ia Supernova Progenitors Consistent with the Properties of Supernova Remnants?
- Single-degenerate type Ia supernovae without hydrogen contamination
- Scattered-Light Echoes from the Historical Galactic Supernovae Cassiopeia A and Tycho (SN 1572)
- Early and late time VLT spectroscopy of SN 2001el - progenitor constraints for a type Ia supernova
- Echoes from Ancient Supernovae in the Large Magellanic Cloud
- Spin-Up/Spin-Down models for Type Ia Supernovae
- Impact of type ia supernova ejecta on binary companions in the single-degenerate scenario
- Subaru high-resolution spectroscopy of Star G in the Tycho supernova remnant
- Early radio and X-ray observations of the youngest nearby type Ia supernova PTF11kly (SN 2011fe)
- A Swift Look at SN 2011fe: The Earliest Ultraviolet Observations of a Type Ia Supernova
- Thermal Timescale Mass Transfer and the Evolution of White Dwarf Binaries
- The Merger Rate of Binary White Dwarfs in the Galactic Disk
- Binaries Like to be Twins: Implications for Doubly Degenerate Binaries, the Supernova Ia Rate and Other Interacting Binaries
- The Chemical Abundances of Tycho G in Supernova Remnant 1572
- No Stripped Hydrogen in the Nebular Spectra of Nearby Type Ia Supernova 2011fe
- BVRI lightcurves of supernovae SN 2011fe in M101, SN 2012aw in M95, and SN 2012cg in NGC 4424
- The impact of type Ia supernovae on main sequence binary companions
- Spectral Identification of an Ancient Supernova using Light Echoes in the LMC
- RCW 86: A Type Ia Supernova in a Wind-Blown Bubble
- The Discovery of Cepheids and a Distance to NGC 5128
- Single or Double Degenerate Progenitors? Searching for Shock Emission in the SDSS-II Type Ia Supernovae
- The Stellar Ancestry of Supernovae in the Magellanic Clouds - I. the Most Recent Supernovae in the Large Magellanic Cloud
- The Persistence of Memory, or How the X-Ray Spectrum of SNR 0509-67.5 Reveals the Brightness of its Parent Type Ia Supernova
- Late-time supernova light curves: The effect of internal conversion and Auger electrons
- Constraining Type Ia Supernovae progenitors from three years of SNLS data
- Searching for a Companion Star of Tycho's Type Ia Supernova with Optical Spectroscopic Observations
- Progenitors of Type Ia Supernovae: Binary Stars with White Dwarf Companions
- Tycho Brahe's supernova: light from centuries past
- Companion Stars of Type Ia Supernovae
- Constraints on Type Ia Supernova Progenitor Companions from Early Ultraviolet Observations with Swift
- Multi-epoch high-resolution spectroscopy of SN2011fe - Linking the progenitor to its environment
- Impact of Type Ia Supernova Ejecta on a Helium-star Binary Companion
- The Progenitor of the Type Ia Supernova that created SNR 0519-69.0 in the Large Magellanic Cloud
- X-ray and optical observations of the unique binary system HD49798/RXJ0648.0-4418
- The Absence of Ex-Companions in Type Ia Supernova Remnants
- A Type Ia Supernova at Redshift 1.55 in Hubble Space Telescope Infrared Observations from CANDELS
- Identification of the companion stars of Type Ia supernovae
- Stellar Binary Companions to Supernova Progenitors
- The Distance to the Massive Eclipsing Binary LMC-SC1-105 in the Large Magellanic Cloud
- Companion stars of Type Ia supernovae and single low-mass white dwarfs
Cited by in corpus (69)
- Observational clues to the progenitors of Type-Ia supernovae
- The Evolution of Compact Binary Star Systems
- The search for failed supernovae with the Large Binocular Telescope: confirmation of a disappearing star
- Three Hypervelocity White Dwarfs in Gaia DR2: Evidence for Dynamically Driven Double-Degenerate Double-Detonation Type Ia Supernovae
- Spectrophotometric time series of SN 2011fe from the Nearby Supernova Factory
- Type Ia Supernova Explosions in Binary Systems: A Review
- Constraints on the progenitor system and the environs of SN 2014J from deep radio observations
- Seeing Double: ASASSN-18bt Exhibits a Two-Component Rise in the Early-Time K2 Light Curve
- A reconnaissance of the possible donor stars to the Kepler supernova
- Hydrogen and helium in the spectra of Type Ia supernovae
- Type Iax Supernovae
- The Young and Bright Type Ia Supernova ASASSN-14lp: Discovery, Early-Time Observations, First-Light Time, Distance to NGC 4666, and Progenitor Constraints
- Strong Evidence Against A Non-Degenerate Companion in SN 2012cg
- Almost Gone: SN~2008S and NGC~300 2008OT-1 are Fainter than their Progenitors
- Evolution Of Post-Impact Remnant Helium Stars In Type Ia Supernova Remnants Within The Single-Degenerate Scenario
- Nebular Spectra of 111 Type Ia Supernovae Disfavor Single Degenerate Progenitors
- ASASSN-18tb: A Most Unusual Type Ia Supernova Observed by TESS and SALT
- New approaches to SNe Ia progenitors
- Whimper of a Bang: Documenting the Final Days of the Nearby Type Ia Supernova 2011fe
- A common-envelope wind model for Type Ia supernovae (I): binary evolution and birth rate
- Constraining the Progenitor Companion of the Nearby Type Ia SN 2011fe with a Nebular Spectrum at +981 Days
- Comprehensive study of ejecta-companion interaction for core-collapse supernovae in massive binaries
- Delayed Circumstellar Interaction for Type Ia SN 2015cp Revealed by an HST Ultraviolet Imaging Survey
- Single-Degenerate Type Ia Supernovae Are Preferentially Overluminous
- Observational constraints on the origin of the elements. III. Evidence for the dominant role of sub-Chandrasekhar SN Ia in the chemical evolution of Mn and Fe in the Galaxy
- Evidence for Sub-Chandrasekhar Mass Type Ia Supernovae from an Extensive Survey of Radiative Transfer Models
- A Search for a Surviving White Dwarf Companion in SN 1006
- Cas A and the Crab Were Not Stellar Binaries At Death
- Improved Hubble Space Telescope Proper Motions for Tycho-G and Other Stars in the Remnant of Tycho's Supernova 1572
- Surviving companions of Type Ia supernovae: theory and observations
- LOSS's First Supernova? New Limits on the "Impostor" SN 1997bs
- Reconciling 56Ni Production in Type Ia Supernovae with Double Degenerate Scenarios
- Search for surviving companions in type Ia supernova remnants
- No surviving companion in Kepler's supernova
- Observability of inflated companion stars after supernovae in massive binaries
- Still Brighter than Pre-Explosion, SN 2012Z Did Not Disappear: Comparing Hubble Space Telescope Observations a Decade Apart
- Early ultraviolet signatures from the interaction of Type Ia supernova ejecta with a stellar companion
- Search for Surviving Companions of Progenitors of Young LMC Type Ia Supernova Remnants
- Confirmation of Hostless Type Ia Supernovae Using Hubble Space Telescope Imaging
- The Evolution of Helium Star Plus Carbon-Oxygen White Dwarf Binary Systems and Implications for Diverse Stellar Transients and Hypervelocity Stars
- Tycho-B: an unlikely companion for SN 1572
- Constraining the spin-down timescale of the white-dwarf progenitors of Type Ia supernovae
- Blue Large-Amplitude Pulsators: the Possible Surviving Companions of Type Ia Supernovae
- The interaction of Type Iax supernova ejecta with a helium companion star
- From Out of the Blue: Swift Links 2002es-like, 2003fg-like, and Early-Time Bump Type Ia Supernovae
- The nature of the companion star in Circinus X-1
- Possible Signatures of Ejecta-Companion Interaction in iPTF 13bvn
- SN 2011fe: A Laboratory for Testing Models of Type Ia Supernovae
- Observations of Type Ia Supernova 2014J for Nearly 900 Days and Constraints on Its Progenitor System
- The Whisper of a Whimper of a Bang: 2400 Days of the Type Ia SN 2011fe Reveals the Decay of Fe
- Investigation of the Progenitors of the Type Ia Supernovae Associated With the LMC Supernova Remnants 0505-67.9 and 0509-68.7
- Tycho's supernova: the view from {\it Gaia}
- Long-term evolution of surviving companion stars of Type Iax supernovae
- No Surviving SN Ia Companion In SNR 0509-67.5: Stellar Population Characterization and Comparison To Models
- Late-Onset Circumstellar Medium Interactions are Rare: An Unbiased GALEX View of Type Ia Supernovae
- Searching for a Hypervelocity White Dwarf Companion: A Proper Motion Survey of SN 1006
- White dwarf deflagrations for Type Iax supernovae: Polarisation signatures from the explosion and companion interaction
- Signatures of a surviving helium-star companion in Type Ia supernovae and constraints on the progenitor companion of SN 2011fe
- Constraining the Progenitor of the Type Ia Supernova SN 2012cg
- The Search for Failed Supernovae with the Large Binocular Telescope: N6946-BH1, Still No Star
- Dust Formation and the Binary Companions of Supernovae
- Blast From the Past: Constraining Progenitor Models of SN 1972E
- Effects of the core-collapse supernova ejecta impact on a rapidly rotating massive companion star
- A possible surviving companion of the SN Ia in the Galactic SNR G272.2-3.2
- A Runaway Giant in the Galactic Halo
- Type Ia supernova ejecta-donor interaction: explosion model comparison
- The HST Non-Detection of SN Ia 2011fe 11.5yr After Explosion Further Restricts Single-Degenerate Progenitor Systems
- Long-term evolution of post-explosion Helium-star Companions of Type Iax Supernovae
- On the rotation properties of a post-explosion helium-star companion in Type Iax supernovae