Numerical sunspot models: Robustness of photospheric velocity and magnetic field structure

Abstract

MHD simulations of sunspots have successfully reproduced many aspects of sunspot fine structure as consequence of magneto convection in inclined magnetic field. We study how global sunspot properties and penumbral fine structure depend on the magnetic top boundary condition as well as on grid spacing. The overall radial extent of the penumbra is subject to the magnetic top boundary condition. All other aspects of sunspot structure and penumbral fine structure are resolved at an acceptable level starting from a grid resolution of 48 [24] km (horizontal [vertical]). We find that the amount of inverse polarity flux and the overall amount of overturning convective motions in the penumbra are robust with regard to both, resolution and boundary conditions. At photospheric levels Evershed flow channels are strongly magnetized. We discuss in detail the relation between velocity and magnetic field structure in the photosphere and point out observational consequences.

23 pages, 22 figures, 2 movies, accepted for publication in ApJ

References in corpus (22)

• Magneto-convection in a sunspot umbra
• Penumbral structure and outflows in simulated sunspots
• Magnetic Structure of Sunspots
• MHD simulations of penumbra fine structure
• Penumbral fine structure and driving mechanisms of large-scale flows in simulated sunspots
• Magnetostatic penumbra models with field-free gaps
• Subsurface magnetic field and flow structure of simulated sunspots
• Detection of vortex tubes in solar granulation from observations with Sunrise
• Convection and the origin of Evershed flows in sunspot penumbrae
• Evidence of convective rolls in a sunspot penumbra
• Two-dimensional spectroscopy of a sunspot. III Thermal and kinematic structure of the penumbra at 0.5"
• Convective Nature of Sunspot Penumbral Filaments: Discovery of Downflows in the Deep Photosphere
• Precursor of Sunspot Penumbral Formation discovered with Hinode SOT Observations
• Evidence of magnetic field wrapping around penumbral filaments
• Traveling Waves of Magnetoconvection and the Origin of the Evershed Effect in Sunspots
• Are there field-free gaps near tau=1 in sunspot penumbrae?
• The Fine-Structure of the Net-Circular Polarization in a Sunspot Penumbra
• Striation and convection in penumbral filaments
• Models and Observations of Sunspot Penumbrae
• Evidence for convection in Sunspot penumbrae
• Searching for overturning convection in penumbral filaments: slit spectroscopy at 0.2 arcsec resolution
• Can overturning motions in penumbral filaments be detected?

Cited by in corpus (86)

• Inversion of the radiative transfer equation for polarized light
• Numerical simulations of active region scale flux emergence: From spot formation to decay
• Grand Minima and Equatorward Propagation in a Cycling Stellar Convective Dynamo
• Critical Science Plan for the Daniel K. Inouye Solar Telescope (DKIST)
• Peripheral downflows in sunspot penumbrae
• The European Solar Telescope
• Structure of sunspot penumbral filaments: a remarkable uniformity of properties
• Emergence of magnetic flux generated in a solar convective dynamo. I: Formation of Sunspots and Active regions, and Origin of Their Asymmetries
• Returning magnetic flux in sunspot penumbrae
• Waves in the lower solar atmosphere: the dawn of next-generation solar telescopes
• Opposite polarity field with convective downflow and its relation to magnetic spines in a sunspot penumbra
• Stokes Inversion based on Convolutional Neural Networks
• A method for global inversion of multi-resolution solar data
• Numerical simulations of sunspot decay: On the penumbra -- Evershed flow -- moat flow connection
• Light Bridge in a Developing Active Region. II. Numerical Simulation of Flux Emergence and Light Bridge Formation
• Flare differentially rotates sunspot on Sun's surface
• Comparison of inversion codes for polarized line formation in MHD simulations. I. Milne-Eddington codes
• Properties of sunspot umbrae observed in Cycle 24
• Depth-dependent global properties of a sunspot observed by Hinode using the Solar Optical Telescope/Spectropolarimeter
• Deep probing of the photospheric sunspot penumbra: no evidence for magnetic field-free gaps
• On rising magnetic flux tube and formation of sunspots in a deep domain
• 3D Radiative MHD simulations of starspots
• Transition-Region/Coronal Signatures and Magnetic Setting of Sunspot Penumbral Jets: {\it Hinode} (SOT/FG), Hi-C and {\it SDO}/AIA Observations
• The velocity field of sunspot penumbrae II. Return flow and magnetic fields of opposite polarity
• FIRTEZ-dz: A Forward and Inverse solver of the polarized Radiative Transfer Equation under Zeeman regime in geometrical scale
• Combining magneto-hydrostatic constraints with Stokes profiles inversions
• Plasma Beta Stratification in the Solar Atmosphere: A Possible Explanation for the Penumbra Formation
• The influence of NLTE effects in Fe I lines on an inverted atmosphere I. 6301 A and 6302 A lines formed in 1D NLTE
• Active region fine structure observed at 0.08 arcsec resolution
• Hi-C Observations of Sunspot Penumbral Bright Dots
• Sunrise III: Overview of Observatory and Instruments
• Magnetic fields of opposite polarity in sunspot penumbrae
• Measuring the Wilson depression of sunspots using the divergence-free condition of the magnetic field vector
• Lateral downflows in sunspot penumbral filaments and their temporal evolution
• The problem of the height dependence of magnetic fields in sunspots
• Vertical magnetic field gradient in the photospheric layers of sunspots
• Evidence of Twisting and Mixed-polarity Solar Photospheric Magnetic Field in Large Penumbral Jets: IRIS and Hinode Observations
• Legolas: a modern tool for magnetohydrodynamic spectroscopy
• Solar Dynamics, Rotation, Convection and Overshoot
• Evershed and counter-Evershed flows in sunspot MHD simulations
• Combining magneto-hydrostatic constraints with Stokes profile inversions. II. Application to Hinode/SP observations
• The non-LTE formation of the Fe I 6173 A line in the solar atmosphere
• On the relationship between sunspot structure and magnetic field changes associated with solar flares
• Time-Distance Helioseismology of Two Realistic Sunspot Simulations
• Properties of the Umbral Filament Observed in Active Region NOAA 12529
• Sunspot simulations: penumbra formation and the fluting instability
• Characterization of magneto-convection in sunspots -- The Gough & Tayler stability criterion in MURaM sunspot simulations
• Restoring process of sunspot penumbra
• A distinct magnetic property of the inner penumbral boundary III. Analysis of simulated sunspots
• Magnetic Properties and Flow Angle of the Inverse Evershed Flow at Its Downflow Points
• Temporal Evolution of the Inverse Evershed Flow
• Inference of electric currents in the solar photosphere
• Formation of super-strong horizontal magnetic field in delta-type sunspot in radiation magnetohydrodynamic simulations
• Observations of Umbral Dots and their Physical Models
• No universal connection between the vertical magnetic field and the umbra-penumbra boundary in sunspots
• Properties of Supersonic Evershed Downflows
• The role of the chromospheric magnetic canopy in the formation of a sunspot penumbra
• The pre-penumbral magnetic canopy in the solar atmosphere
• Driving solar coronal MHD simulations on high-performance computers
• Penumbral thermal structure below the visible surface
• Spectropolarimetric Inversion in Four Dimensions with Deep Learning (SPIn4D): I. Overview, Magnetohydrodynamic Modeling, and Stokes Profile Synthesis
• Structures in compressible magnetoconvection and the nature of umbral dots
• Combining magneto-hydrostatic constraints with Stokes profiles inversions. III. Uncertainty in the inference of electric currents
• On the (in)stability of sunspots
• A study of the capabilities for inferring atmospheric information from high-spatial-resolution simulations
• Solar magneto-convection
• Continuum enhancements, line profiles and magnetic field evolution during consecutive flares
• Onset of penumbra formation
• The formation and decay of sunspot penumbra in Active Region NOAA 12673
• $\text{globin}$: A spectropolarimetric inversion code for the coupled inference of atomic line parameters
• Morphological study of penumbral formation
• The Temperature - Magnetic Field Relation in Observed and Simulated Sunspots
• The Current State-Of-The-Art In Active Region Seismology
• Fan-shaped jet close to a light bridge
• The role of the Lorentz force in sunspot equilibrium
• Recipe for inferring sub-surface solar magnetism via local mode-coupling using Slepian basis functions
• 3D Radiative MHD Simulations of Starspots II: Large-scale Structure
• Ti I lines at 2.2 $\mu$m as probes of the cool parts of sunspots
• Magnetic properties of orphan penumbrae
• Detection of Travel Time Anisotropy from Subsurface Horizontal Magnetic Fields
• Chromospheric and photospheric properties of sunspots as inferred from Stokes inversions under magneto-hydrostatic and non-local-thermodynamic equilibrium
• Opposite polarity magnetic field and convective downflows in a simulated sunspot penumbra
• Decay of a photospheric transient filament at the boundary of a pore and the chromospheric response
• Apparent motion of penumbral grains in a sunspot simulation
• Sunspot simulations with MURaM -- I. Parameter study using potential field initial conditions
• Multi-height Identification of Sausage and Fluting Eigenmodes in a Solar Pore