Deep probing of the photospheric sunspot penumbra: no evidence for magnetic field-free gaps

Abstract

Some models for the topology of the magnetic field in sunspot penumbrae predict the existence of field-free or dynamically weak-field regions in the deep Photosphere. To confirm or rule out the existence of weak-field regions in the deepest photospheric layers of the penumbra. The magnetic field at $\log {\tau }_5=0$ is investigated by means of inversions of spectropolarimetric data of two different sunspots located very close to disk center with a spatial resolution of approximately 0.4-0.45 arcsec. The data have been recorded using the GRIS instrument attached to the 1.5-meters GREGOR solar telescope at El Teide observatory. It includes three Fe I lines around 1565 nm, whose sensitivity to the magnetic field peaks at half a pressure-scale-height deeper than the sensitivity of the widely used Fe I spectral line pair at 630 nm. Prior to the inversion, the data is corrected for the effects of scattered light using a deconvolution method with several point spread functions. At $\log {\tau }_5=0$ we find no evidence for the existence of regions with dynamically weak ($B<500$ Gauss) magnetic fields in sunspot penumbrae. This result is much more reliable than previous investigations done with Fe I lines at 630 nm. Moreover, the result is independent of the number of nodes employed in the inversion, and also independent of the point spread function used to deconvolve the data, and does not depend on the amount of straylight (i.e. wide-angle scattered light) considered.

arXiv commentAccepted for publication in Astronomy & Astrophysics

References in corpus (48)

• CRISP Spectropolarimetric Imaging of Penumbral Fine Structure
• The Imaging Magnetograph eXperiment (IMaX) for the Sunrise balloon-borne solar observatory
• Penumbral structure and outflows in simulated sunspots
• An Open Source, Massively Parallel Code for Non-LTE Synthesis and Inversion of Spectral Lines and Zeeman-induced Stokes Profiles
• Numerical sunspot models: Robustness of photospheric velocity and magnetic field structure
• Fine structure, magnetic field and heating of sunspot penumbrae
• The intensity contrast of solar granulation: comparing Hinode SP results with MHD simulations
• Spatially coupled inversion of spectro-polarimetric image data I: Method and first results
• Penumbral fine structure and driving mechanisms of large-scale flows in simulated sunspots
• Peripheral downflows in sunspot penumbrae
• Center-to-Limb Variation of Solar Line Profiles as a Test of NLTE Line Formation Calculations
• Magnetostatic penumbra models with field-free gaps
• Structure of sunspot penumbral filaments: a remarkable uniformity of properties
• Point spread functions for the Solar Optical Telescope onboard Hinode
• On the fine structure of the sunspot penumbrae. II. The nature of the Evershed flow
• Vigorous convection in a sunspot granular light bridge
• Returning magnetic flux in sunspot penumbrae
• Opposite polarity field with convective downflow and its relation to magnetic spines in a sunspot penumbra
• Evidence of convective rolls in a sunspot penumbra
• Stray light correction and contrast analysis of Hinode broad band images
• Comparison of inversion codes for polarized line formation in MHD simulations. I. Milne-Eddington codes
• A geometrical height scale for sunspot penumbrae
• On the velocity field of sunspot penumbrae - I. A global view
• Convective Nature of Sunspot Penumbral Filaments: Discovery of Downflows in the Deep Photosphere
• Depth-dependent global properties of a sunspot observed by Hinode using the Solar Optical Telescope/Spectropolarimeter
• Point spread function of SDO/HMI and the effects of stray light correction on the apparent properties of solar surface phenomena
• Evidence of magnetic field wrapping around penumbral filaments
• The SHARDDS survey: first resolved image of the HD114082 debris disk in Lower Centaurus Crux with SPHERE
• On the fine structure of the sunspot penumbrae. III The vertical extension of penumbral filaments
• Stray-light contamination and spatial deconvolution of slit-spectrograph observations
• Temporal evolution of the Evershed flow in sunspots. I. Observational characterization of Evershed clouds
• The velocity field of sunspot penumbrae II. Return flow and magnetic fields of opposite polarity
• Spatial deconvolution of spectropolarimetric data: an application to quiet Sun magnetic elements
• Vertical flows and mass flux balance of sunspot umbral dots
• Are there field-free gaps near tau=1 in sunspot penumbrae?
• Striation and convection in penumbral filaments
• Lateral downflows in sunspot penumbral filaments and their temporal evolution
• SST/CRISP Observations of Convective Flows in a Sunspot Penumbra
• Temporal evolution of the Evershed flow in sunspots. II. Physical properties and nature of Evershed clouds
• Convective motions and net circular polarization in sunspot penumbrae
• Sources of straylight in the post-focus imaging instrumentation of the Swedish 1-m Solar Telescope
• Modified p-modes in penumbral filaments?
• Waves as the source of apparent twisting motions in sunspot penumbrae
• The Evershed Effect with SOT/Hinode
• Convection and the Origin of Evershed Flows
• Improved search of PCA databases for spectro-polarimetric inversion
• Recent Evidence for Convection in Sunspot Penumbrae
• Image Reconstruction with Analytical Point Spread Functions

Cited by in corpus (26)

• Probing deep photospheric layers of the quiet Sun with high magnetic sensitivity
• Magnetic fields of opposite polarity in sunspot penumbrae
• Inference of magnetic fields in the very quiet Sun
• Upper Chromospheric Magnetic Field of a Sunspot Penumbra: Observations of Fine Structure
• Height variation of magnetic field and plasma flows in isolated bright points
• Properties of the Umbral Filament Observed in Active Region NOAA 12529
• Temporal evolution of small-scale internetwork magnetic fields in the solar photosphere
• Using the infrared iron lines to probe solar subsurface convection
• Characterization of the umbra-penumbra boundary by the vertical component of the magnetic field -- Analysis of ground-based data from the GREGOR Infrared Spectrograph
• Signatures of the impact of flare ejected plasma on the photosphere of a sunspot light-bridge
• The role of the chromospheric magnetic canopy in the formation of a sunspot penumbra
• Penumbral thermal structure below the visible surface
• Constraining the magnetic vector in the quiet solar photosphere and the impact of instrumental degradation
• Three-lobed near-infrared Stokes V profiles in the quiet Sun
• Evolution of Stokes V area asymmetry related to a quiet Sun cancelation observed with GRIS/IFU
• Combining magneto-hydrostatic constraints with Stokes profiles inversions. III. Uncertainty in the inference of electric currents
• Detection of emission in the Si i 1082.7 nm line core in sunspot umbrae
• The Temperature - Magnetic Field Relation in Observed and Simulated Sunspots
• Does H$\alpha$ Stokes~$V$ profiles probe the chromospheric magnetic field? An observational perspective
• Simultaneous spectropolarimetric observations in the H$\alpha$ and Ca II 8662 Å lines of an active region
• Spectral resolution effects on the information content in solar spectra
• Correction of atmospheric stray-light in restored slit-spectra
• The role of the Lorentz force in sunspot equilibrium
• On the center-to-limb variations of the He I 10830 Å triplet
• Decay of a photospheric transient filament at the boundary of a pore and the chromospheric response
• Episodic Plasma Flows and Coronal Brightenings in an Arch Filament System Observed with SUNRISE III