Comparison of inversion codes for polarized line formation in MHD simulations. I. Milne-Eddington codes

Abstract

Milne-Eddington (M-E) inversion codes for the radiative transfer equation are the most widely used tools to infer the magnetic field from observations of the polarization signals in photospheric and chromospheric spectral lines. Unfortunately, a comprehensive comparison between the different M-E codes available to the solar physics community is still missing, and so is a physical interpretation of their inferences. In this contribution we offer a comparison between three of those codes (VFISV, ASP/HAO, and HeLIx${}^{+}$). These codes are used to invert synthetic Stokes profiles that were previously obtained from realistic non-grey three-dimensional magnetohydrodynamical (3D MHD) simulations. The results of the inversion are compared with each other and with those from the MHD simulations. In the first case, the M-E codes retrieve values for the magnetic field strength, inclination and line-of-sight velocity that agree with each other within ${\sigma }_B\le 35$ (Gauss), ${\sigma }_{\gamma }\le 1.2°$, and ${\sigma }_{\mathrm{v}}\le 10$ ms${}^{-1}$, respectively. Additionally, M-E inversion codes agree with the numerical simulations, when compared at a fixed optical depth, within ${\sigma }_B\le 130$ (Gauss), ${\sigma }_{\gamma }\le 5°$, and ${\sigma }_{\mathrm{v}}\le 320$ ms${}^{-1}$. Finally, we show that employing generalized response functions to determine the height at which M-E codes measure physical parameters is more meaningful than comparing at a fixed geometrical height or optical depth. In this case the differences between M-E inferences and the 3D MHD simulations decrease to ${\sigma }_B\le 90$ (Gauss), ${\sigma }_{\gamma }\le 3°$, and ${\sigma }_{\mathrm{v}}\le 90$ ms${}^{-1}$.

arXiv commentAccepted for publication in Astronomy & Astrophysics (14 pages; 7 figures)

References in corpus (15)

• VFISV: Very Fast Inversion of the Stokes Vector for the Helioseismic and Magnetic Imager
• Advanced Forward Modeling and Inversion of Stokes Profiles Resulting from the Joint Action of the Hanle and Zeeman Effects
• Numerical sunspot models: Robustness of photospheric velocity and magnetic field structure
• The Helioseismic and Magnetic Imager (HMI) Vector Magnetic Field Pipeline: Optimization of the Spectral Line Inversion Code
• DELO-Bezier formal solutions of the polarized radiative transfer equation
• On the Formation Height of the SDO/HMI Fe 6173 Doppler Signal
• On the validity of the 630 nm Fe I nm lines for the magnetometry of the internetwork quiet Sun
• Magnetic fields of an active region filament from full Stokes analysis of Si I 1082.7 nm and He I 1083.0 nm
• Multicomponent He I 10830 Å profiles in an active filament
• The velocity field of sunspot penumbrae II. Return flow and magnetic fields of opposite polarity
• Applicability of Milne-Eddington inversions to high spatial resolution observations of the quiet Sun
• Magnetic field vector retrieval with the Helioseismic and Magnetic Imager
• Milne-Eddington inversions of the He I 10830 Å Stokes profiles: Influence of the Paschen-Back effect
• Milne-Eddington inversion of the Fe I line pair at 630~nm
• Retrieval of solar magnetic fields from high-spatial resolution filtergraph data: the Imaging Magnetograph eXperiment (IMaX)

Cited by in corpus (30)

• Inversion of the radiative transfer equation for polarized light
• Radiative diagnostics in the solar photosphere and chromosphere
• Light Bridge in a Developing Active Region. II. Numerical Simulation of Flux Emergence and Light Bridge Formation
• Deep probing of the photospheric sunspot penumbra: no evidence for magnetic field-free gaps
• FIRTEZ-dz: A Forward and Inverse solver of the polarized Radiative Transfer Equation under Zeeman regime in geometrical scale
• The influence of NLTE effects in Fe I lines on an inverted atmosphere I. 6301 A and 6302 A lines formed in 1D NLTE
• Photospheric response to EB-like event
• A new MHD-assisted Stokes inversion technique
• Fast inversion of solar Ca II spectra
• Magnetic fields of opposite polarity in sunspot penumbrae
• Mimicking spectropolarimetric inversions using convolutional neural networks
• Bihelical spectrum of solar magnetic helicity and its evolution
• A Statistical Comparison between Photospheric Vector Magnetograms Obtained by SDO/HMI and Hinode/SP
• Combining magneto-hydrostatic constraints with Stokes profile inversions. II. Application to Hinode/SP observations
• SynthIA: A Synthetic Inversion Approximation for the Stokes Vector Fusing SDO and Hinode into a Virtual Observatory
• Probing photospheric magnetic fields with new spectral line pairs
• Disambiguation of Vector Magnetograms by Stereoscopic Observations from the Solar Orbiter/Polarimetric and Helioseismic Imager (PHI) and the Solar Dynamic Observatory (SDO)/Helioseismic and Magnetic Imager (HMI)
• Magnetic filed dynamics and varying plasma emission in large coronal loops
• Inference of electric currents in the solar photosphere
• Interaction of magnetic fields with a vortex tube at solar subgranular scale
• Magnetograms underestimate even unipolar magnetic flux nearly everywhere on the solar disk
• Combining magneto-hydrostatic constraints with Stokes profiles inversions. III. Uncertainty in the inference of electric currents
• Inferring Line-of-Sight Velocities and Doppler Widths from Stokes Profiles of GST/NIRIS Using Stacked Deep Neural Networks
• Onset of penumbra formation
• The Temperature - Magnetic Field Relation in Observed and Simulated Sunspots
• Magnetic field inference from the spectral region around the Mg I $b_2$ line using the weak-field approximation
• Neural translation for Stokes inversion and synthesis
• Multi-height probing of horizontal flows in the solar photosphere
• A High-resolution, Inversion-Based Synoptic Study of Solar Granulation
• A stray light analysis for SO/PHI-HRT and an updated comparison of the inferred magnetic field with SDO/HMI