Sub-Heisenberg estimation strategies are ineffective
arXiv:1201.1878 · doi:10.1103/PhysRevLett.108.210404
Abstract
In interferometry, sub-Heisenberg strategies claim to achieve a phase estimation error smaller than the inverse of the mean number of photons employed (Heisenberg bound). Here we show that one can achieve a comparable precision without performing any measurement, just using the large prior information that sub-Heisenberg strategies require. For uniform prior (i.e. no prior information), we prove that these strategies cannot achieve more than a fixed gain of about 1.73 over Heisenberg-limited interferometry. Analogous results hold for arbitrary single-mode prior distributions. These results extend also beyond interferometry: the effective error in estimating any parameter is lower bounded by a quantity proportional to the inverse expectation value (above a ground state) of the generator of translations of the parameter.
4 pages, 2 figures, revised version that was published
References in corpus (3)
Cited by in corpus (66)
- Quantum limits in optical interferometry
- Efficient tools for quantum metrology with uncorrelated noise
- Quantum Plasmonic Sensors
- True precision limits in quantum metrology
- Adaptive quantum metrology under general Markovian noise
- Fundamental quantum interferometry bound for the squeezed-light-enhanced gravitational-wave detector GEO600
- Photon number correlation for quantum enhanced imaging and sensing
- Quantum imaging with sub-Poissonian light: challenges and perspectives in optical metrology
- Fast-forwarding of Hamiltonians and Exponentially Precise Measurements
- Optimal Quantum-Enhanced Interferometry
- Local versus Global Strategies in Multi-parameter Estimation
- The quantum Bell-Ziv-Zakai bounds and Heisenberg limits for waveform estimation
- Bayesian multi-parameter quantum metrology with limited data
- Nonclassical Light and Metrological Power: An Introductory Review
- Quantum measurement bounds beyond the uncertainty relations
- Quantum correlations in optical metrology: Heisenberg-limited phase estimation without mode entanglement
- Quantum multiparameter metrology with generalized entangled coherent state
- Phase sensitivity of a Mach-Zehnder interferometer with single-intensity and difference-intensity detection
- Quantum transition-edge detectors
- The Parity Operator: applications in quantum metrology
- Phase sensitivity bounds for two-mode interferometers
- Frequentist and Bayesian Quantum Phase Estimation
- A search algorithm for quantum state engineering and metrology
- Quantum Metrological Bounds for Vector Parameter
- Optimal Heisenberg-style bounds for the average performance of arbitrary phase estimates
- Practical quantum metrology with large precision gains in the low photon number regime
- Matrix product states for quantum metrology
- Non-asymptotic analysis of quantum metrology protocols beyond the Cramér-Rao bound
- Single- versus two-parameter Fisher information in quantum interferometry
- Quantum metrology: why entanglement?
- Demonstration of Entanglement-Enhanced Phase Estimation in Solid
- Optimal Mach-Zehnder phase sensitivity with Gaussian states
- Cryptographic quantum metrology
- Symmetric M-ary phase discrimination using quantum-optical probe states
- Quantum Weiss-Weinstein bounds for quantum metrology
- Quantum metrology in the noisy intermediate-scale quantum era
- Digital Quantum Estimation
- Experimental Quantum Enhanced Optical Interferometry
- Alternative measures of uncertainty in quantum metrology: Contradictions and limits
- Breaking the weak Heisenberg limit
- Phase sensitivity for an unbalanced interferometer without input phase-matching restrictions
- Quantum-enhanced Phase Estimation with an Amplified Bell State
- Quantum metrology with a continuous-variable system
- Noisy quantum gyroscope
- Using states with a large photon number variance to increase quantum Fisher information in single-mode phase estimation
- Adaptive estimation of a time-varying phase with a power-law spectrum via continuous squeezed states
- Interplay between time and energy in bosonic noisy quantum metrology
- Adaptive estimation of a time-varying phase with coherent states: smoothing can give an unbounded improvement over filtering
- Generalized Limits for Parameter Sensitivity via Quantum Ziv-Zakai Bound
- Quantum metrology with precision reaching beyond- scaling through -probe entanglement generating interactions
- Evaluating the quantum Ziv-Zakai bound in noisy environments
- Fundamental noisy multiparameter quantum bounds
- Probabilistic metrology or how some measurement outcomes render ultra-precise estimates
- Fundamental quantum limits in optical metrology from rate-distortion theory
- Signal detection without finite-energy limits to quantum resolution
- Quantum Metrology with Coherent Superposition of Two Different Coded Channels
- Multicritical quantum sensors driven by symmetry-breaking
- Probabilistic metrology defeats ultimate deterministic bound
- Extreme expected values and their applications in quantum information processing
- Average number is an insufficient metric for interferometry
- Non-asymptotic quantum metrology
- Excessive precision compromises accuracy even with unlimited resources due to the trade-off in quantum metrology
- Quantum Metrology via Repeated Quantum Nondemolition Measurements in "Photon Box"
- Quantum Phase Sensitivity with Generalized Coherent States Based on Deformed su(1,1) and Heisenberg Algebras
- Interferometric binary phase estimations
- The temporal resolution limit in quantum sensing