Magnetic field measurements and their uncertainties: the FORS1 legacy

Abstract

During the last decade, the FORS1 instrument of the ESO VLT has been extensively used to study stellar magnetism. A number of interesting discoveries of magnetic fields in several classes of stars have been announced, many of which obtained at a ~3 sigma level; some of the discoveries are confirmed by measurements obtained with other instruments, some are not. Here we investigate the reasons for the discrepancies between the results obtained with FORS1 and those obtained with other instruments. Using the ESO FORS pipeline, we have developed a semi-automatic procedure for magnetic field determination. We have applied this procedure to the full content of circular spectropolarimetric measurements of the FORS1 archive. We have devised and applied a number of consistency checks to our field determinations, and we have compared our results to those previously published in the literature. We find that for high signal-to-noise ratio measurements, photon noise does not account for the full error bars. We discuss how field measurements depend on the specific algorithm adopted for data reduction, and we show that very small instrument flexures, negligible in most of the instrument applications, may be responsible for some spurious field detections in the null profiles. Finally, we find that we are unable to reproduce some results previously published in the literature. Consequently, we do not confirm some important discoveries of magnetic fields obtained with FORS1 and reported in previous publications. Our revised field measurements show that there is no contradiction between the results obtained with the low-resolution spectropolarimeter FORS1 and those obtained with high-resolution spectropolarimeters. FORS1 is an instrument capable of performing reliable magnetic field measurements, provided that the various source of uncertainties are properly taken into account.

Accepted for publication in A&A

References in corpus (21)

• The surprising magnetic topology of tauSco: fossil remnant or dynamo output?
• Weak magnetic fields in Ap/Bp stars: Evidence for a dipole field lower limit and a tentative interpretation of the magnetic dichotomy
• Evolutionary state of magnetic chemically peculiar stars
• Magnetic field measurements and their uncertainties: the FORS1 legacy
• Searching for links between magnetic fields and stellar evolution. I. A survey of magnetic fields in open cluster A- and B-type stars with FORS1
• A search for strong, ordered magnetic fields in Herbig Ae/Be stars
• Discovery of magnetic fields in the beta Cephei star xi^1 CMa and in several Slowly Pulsating B stars
• Nitrogen enrichment, boron depletion and magnetic fields in slowly-rotating B-type dwarfs
• Characterisation of the magnetic field of the Herbig Be star HD 200775
• Magnetic field measurements of O stars with FORS1 at the VLT
• Discovery of two magnetic massive stars in the Orion Nebula Cluster: a clue to the origin of neutron star magnetic fields?
• The weak magnetic field of the O9.7 supergiant zeta Orionis A
• The fraction of DA white dwarfs with kilo-Gauss magnetic fields
• A search for magnetic fields in the variable HgMn star $\alpha$ Andromedae
• A study of the magnetic field in the photospheric and circumstellar components of Herbig Ae stars
• Magnetic fields and chemical peculiarities of the very young intermediate-mass binary system HD 72106
• A search for kilogauss magnetic fields in white dwarfs and hot subdwarf stars
• The pecular magnetic field morphology of the white dwarf WD 1953-011: evidence for a large-scale magnetic flux tube?
• New insights into the nature of the peculiar star theta Carinae
• Detection of Magnetic Massive Stars in the Open Cluster NGC 3766
• Magnetic Field Measurement in Black Hole X-Ray Binary Cygnus X-1

Cited by in corpus (93)

• Classical Be Stars: Rapidly Rotating B Stars with Viscous Keplerian Decretion Disks
• The rotation rates of massive stars: the role of binary interaction through tides, mass transfer and mergers
• A Magnetic Confinement vs. Rotation Classification of Massive-Star Magnetospheres
• The MiMeS Survey of Magnetism in Massive Stars: Introduction and overview
• The MiMeS survey of magnetism in massive stars: Magnetic analysis of the O-type stars
• A Bcool magnetic snapshot survey of solar-type stars
• Magnetic field measurements and their uncertainties: the FORS1 legacy
• B fields in OB stars (BOB): low-resolution FORS2 spectropolarimetry of the first sample of 50 massive stars
• Chemical abundances of magnetic and non-magnetic Herbig Ae/Be stars
• Fundamental properties of nearby single early B-type stars
• The eccentric massive binary V380 Cyg: revised orbital elements and interpretation of the intrinsic variability of the primary component
• B fields in OB stars (BOB): Concluding the FORS2 observing campaign
• On the incidence of weak magnetic fields in DA white dwarfs
• The FORS1 catalogue of stellar magnetic field measurements
• On the use of the Fourier Transform to determine the projected rotational velocity of line-profile variable B stars
• Investigating the spectroscopic, magnetic and circumstellar variability of the O9 subgiant star HD 57682
• Magnetic OB[A] Stars with TESS: probing their Evolutionary and Rotational properties (MOBSTER) - I. First-light observations of known magnetic B and A stars
• TESS survey of rotational and pulsational variability of mercury-manganese stars
• The Chandra Planetary Nebula Survey (ChanPlaNS). II. X-ray Emission from Compact Planetary Nebulae
• Resolving structure of the disk around HD100546 at 7 mm with ATCA
• Exploring the origin of magnetic fields in massive stars: II. New magnetic field measurements in cluster and field stars
• The importance of non-photon noise in stellar spectropolarimetry. The spurious detection of a non-existing magnetic field in the A0 supergiant HD 92207
• On the consistency of magnetic field measurements of Ap stars: lessons learned from the FORS1 archive
• On the first $\delta$ Sct--roAp hybrid pulsator and the stability of p and g modes in chemically peculiar A/F stars
• Discovery of six new strongly magnetic white dwarfs in the 20 pc local population
• Large Interstellar Polarisation Survey. LIPS I: FORS2 spectropolarimetry in the Southern Hemisphere
• First discovery of a magnetic field in a main sequence delta Scuti star: the Kepler star HD188774
• Magnetism, X-rays, and Accretion Rates in WD 1145+017 and other Polluted White Dwarf Systems
• Searching for the weakest detectable magnetic fields in white dwarfs. Highly-sensitive measurements from first VLT and WHT surveys
• Are there tangled magnetic fields on HgMn stars?
• Spectroscopic and physical parameters of Galactic O-type stars. II. Observational constraints on projected rotational and extra broadening velocities as a function of fundamental parameters and stellar evolution
• Critical evaluation of magnetic field detections reported for pulsating B-type stars in the light of ESPaDOnS, Narval and reanalyzed FORS1/2 observations
• B fields in OB stars (BOB): Detection of a magnetic field in the He-strong star CPD-57° 3509
• B fields in OB stars (BOB): on the detection of weak magnetic fields in the two early B-type stars beta CMa and epsilon CMa
• Short time scale spectral variability in the A0 supergiant HD92207 and the importance of line profile variations for the interpretation of FORS2 spectropolarimetric observations
• Evidence of a discontinuous disk structure around the Herbig Ae star HD 139 614
• The enigmatic He-sdB pulsator LS IV$-$14${}^{\circ }$116: new insights from the VLT
• HD66051: the first eclipsing binary hosting an early-type magnetic star
• Chemical surface inhomogeneities in late B-type stars with Hg and Mn peculiarity I Spot evolution in HD 11753 on short and long time scales
• Evidence for radio and X-ray auroral emissions from the magnetic B-type star rho Oph A
• The prevalence of weak magnetic fields in Herbig Ae stars: The case of PDS2
• Design of a Full-Stokes Polarimeter for VLT/X-shooter
• The magnetic fields of hot subdwarf stars
• The Emergence of Negative Superhumps in Cataclysmic Variables: Smoothed Particle Hydrodynamics Simulations
• On the Mass Accretion Rates of Herbig Ae/Be Stars. Magnetospheric Accretion or Boundary Layer?
• B fields in OB stars (BOB): The discovery of a magnetic field in a multiple system in the Trifid Nebula, one of the youngest star forming regions
• A novel and sensitive method for measuring very weak magnetic fields of DA white dwarfs: A search for a magnetic field at the 250 G level in 40 Eri B
• Magnetic field topology and chemical spot distributions in the extreme Ap star HD 75049
• Discovery of a magnetic field in $\rho$ Pup
• A solar-type star polluted by calcium-rich supernova ejecta inside the supernova remnant RCW 86
• Detectability of small-scale magnetic fields in early-type stars
• Searching for a magnetic field in Wolf-Rayet stars using FORS2 spectropolarimetry
• A search for magnetic fields on central stars in planetary nebulae
• The pulsating magnetosphere of the extremely slowly rotating magnetic $\beta$ Cep star ${\xi }^1$ CMa
• B fields in OB stars (BOB): FORS2 spectropolarimetric follow-up of the two rare rigidly rotating magnetosphere stars HD23478 and HD345439
• Magnetic fields in central stars of planetary nebulae?
• Discovery of weak magnetic fields in four DZ white dwarfs in the local 20pc volume. Implications for the frequency of magnetic fields with cooling age
• $\gamma$ Columbae: the recently stripped, pulsating core of a massive star
• Weak magnetic fields in central stars of planetary nebulae?
• Discovery of an extremely weak magnetic field in the white dwarf LTT 16093 = WD2047+372
• Magnetometry of a sample of massive stars in Carina
• HD 41641: A classical $\delta$ Sct-type pulsator with chemical signatures of an Ap star
• Linking Signatures of Accretion with Magnetic Field Measurements - Line Profiles are not Significantly Different in Magnetic and Non-Magnetic Herbig Ae/Be Stars
• The Circumstellar Disk of the Be Star $o$~Aquarii
• A search for strong magnetic fields in massive and very massive stars in the Magellanic Clouds
• Upper limits to the magnetic field in central stars of planetary nebulae
• First detection of a magnetic field in low-luminosity B[e] stars: New scenarios for the nature and evolutionary stages of FS CMa stars
• An Observational Evaluation of Magnetic Confinement in the Winds of BA Supergiants
• Boron depletion in Galactic early B-type stars reveals two different main sequence star populations
• First constraints on the magnetic field strength in extra-Galactic stars: FORS2 observations of Of?p stars in the Magellanic Clouds
• NGC 6611 601: A hot pre-main sequence spectroscopic binary containing a centrifugal magnetosphere host star
• The multi-line slope method for the measure of the effective magnetic field of the cool stars: an application to the solar like cycle of ε Eri
• The complex fossil magnetic field of the $\delta$ Scuti star HD\,41641
• HD144941: The most extreme helium-strong star
• A probable pre-main sequence chemically peculiar star in the open cluster Stock 16
• Discovery of magnetically guided metal accretion onto a polluted white dwarf
• Calibrating and Stabilizing Spectropolarimeters with Charge Shuffling and Daytime Sky Measurements
• Extensive study of HD 25558, a long-period double-lined binary with two SPB components
• The Autonomous Data Reduction Pipeline for the CUTE Mission
• Abundance analysis, spectral variability, and search for the presence of a magnetic field in the typical PGa star HD19400
• Detection of magnetic field in the B2 star $\rho$ Oph A with ESO FORS2
• V772 Cas: an ellipsoidal HgMn star in an eclipsing binary
• The first spectropolarimetric monitoring of the peculiar O4Ief supergiant zeta Puppis
• A revisit to the enigmatic variable star 21 Comae
• No evidence of a sudden change of spectral appearance or magnetic field strength of the O9.7V star HD 54879
• Chemical abundances of the high-latitude Herbig Ae Star PDS2
• CUTE Data Simulator and Reduction Pipeline
• The puzzling properties of the magnetic O star Tr16-22
• Measuring the continuum polarization with ESPaDOnS
• Discovery and analysis of three magnetic hot subdwarf stars: evidence for merger-induced magnetic fields
• Chemical fingerprints of binary mass transfer in massive stars
• Detection of a weak magnetic field in the Balmer emission line white dwarf WDJ1653-1001
• A magnetic field detection in the massive O-type bright giant 63 Oph