Are there tangled magnetic fields on HgMn stars?
arXiv:1304.6717 · doi:10.1051/0004-6361/201321467
Abstract
Several recent spectrophotometric studies failed to detect significant global magnetic fields in late-B HgMn chemically peculiar stars, but some investigations have suggested the presence of strong unstructured or tangled fields in these objects. We used detailed spectrum synthesis analysis to search for evidence of tangled magnetic fields in high-quality observed spectra of 8 slowly rotating HgMn stars and one normal late-B star. We also evaluated recent sporadic detections of weak longitudinal magnetic fields in HgMn stars based on the moment technique. Our analysis of the Zeeman broadening of magnetically sensitive spectral lines reveals no evidence of tangled magnetic fields in any of the studied HgMn or normal stars. We infer upper limits of 200-700 G for the mean magnetic field modulus -- much smaller than the field strengths implied by studies based on differential magnetic line intensification and quadratic field diagnostics. The new HARPSpol longitudinal field measurements for the extreme HgMn star HD 65949 and the normal late-B star 21 Peg are consistent with zero at a precision of 3-6 G. Re-analysis of our Stokes V spectra of the spotted HgMn star HD 11753 shows that the recent moment technique measurements retrieved from the same data are incompatible with the lack of circular polarization signatures in the spectrum of this star. We conclude that there is no evidence for substantial tangled magnetic fields on the surfaces of studied HgMn stars. We cannot independently confirm the presence of very strong quadratic or marginal longitudinal fields for these stars, so results from the moment technique are likely to be spurious.
arXiv comment12 pages, 11 figures; accepted for publication in A&A
References in corpus (33)
- The Magnetic Fields of Classical T Tauri Stars
- Least squares deconvolution of the stellar intensity and polarization spectra
- Weak magnetic fields in Ap/Bp stars: Evidence for a dipole field lower limit and a tentative interpretation of the magnetic dichotomy
- Evolutionary state of magnetic chemically peculiar stars
- Searching for links between magnetic fields and stellar evolution. II. The evolution of magnetic fields as revealed by observations of Ap stars in open clusters and associations
- Magnetic field measurements and their uncertainties: the FORS1 legacy
- Detection of a weak surface magnetic field on Sirius A: are all tepid stars magnetic ?
- The rapid rotation and complex magnetic field geometry of Vega
- Atmospheric velocity fields in tepid main sequence stars
- The chemical abundance analysis of normal early A- and late B-type stars
- Weather in stellar atmosphere: the dynamics of mercury clouds in alpha Andromedae
- The search for magnetic fields in mercury-manganese stars
- On the incidence of magnetic fields in slowly-pulsating B, Beta Cephei and B-type emission line stars
- Chemical stratification in the atmosphere of Ap star HD 133792. Regularized solution of the vertical inversion problem
- No detection of large-scale magnetic fields at the surfaces of Am and HgMn stars
- Inhomogeneous surface distribution of chemical elements in the eclipsing binary AR Aur: A new challenge for our understanding of HgMn stars
- A search for magnetic fields in the variable HgMn star Andromedae
- Evolution of magnetic fields in stars across the upper main sequence: I. Catalogue of magnetic field measurements with FORS1 at the VLT
- Magnetic field, chemical composition and line profile variability of the peculiar eclipsing binary star AR Aur
- Magnetic fields of HgMn stars
- Dynamical evolution of titanium, strontium, and yttrium spots on the surface of the HgMn star HD 11753
- Stellar magnetic field parameters from a Bayesian analysis of high-resolution spectropolarimetric observations
- Inhomogeneous distribution of mercury on the surfaces of rapidly rotating HgMn stars
- Critical evaluation of magnetic field detections reported for pulsating B-type stars in the light of ESPaDOnS, Narval and reanalyzed FORS1/2 observations
- First detection of linear polarization in the line profiles of active cool stars
- Chemical spots in the absence of magnetic field in the binary HgMn star 66 Eridani
- Magnetism, chemical spots, and stratification in the HgMn star phi Phoenicis
- On detectability of Zeeman broadening in optical spectra of F- and G-dwarfs
- Wavelengths and oscillator strengths of Xe II from the UVES spectra of four HgMn stars
- No magnetic field in the spotted HgMn star mu Leporis
- New identified (3H)4d - (3H)4f transitions of Fe II from UVES spectra of HR 6000 and 46 Aql
- Magnetic survey of emission line B-type stars with FORS1 at the VLT
- Modelling the incomplete Paschen-Back effect in the spectra of magnetic Ap stars
Cited by in corpus (23)
- Hidden magnetic fields of young suns
- MOBSTER - II. Identification of rotationally variable A stars observed with \emph{TESS} in Sectors 1 to 4
- TESS survey of rotational and pulsational variability of mercury-manganese stars
- Discovery of new magnetic early-B stars within the MiMeS HARPSpol survey
- Doppler imaging of chemical spots on magnetic Ap/Bp stars. Numerical tests and assessment of systematic errors
- New Photometrically Variable Magnetic Chemically Peculiar Stars in the ASAS-3 Archive
- Discovery of starspots on Vega - First spectroscopic detection of surface structures on a normal A-type star
- HD66051: the first eclipsing binary hosting an early-type magnetic star
- Magnetic fields of intermediate mass T Tauri stars
- Chemical diversity among A-B stars with low rotational velocities: non-LTE abundance analysis
- A search for pulsations in the HgMn star HD 45975 with CoRoT photometry and ground-based spectroscopy
- New mercury-manganese stars and candidates from LAMOST DR4
- Photometric variability of the LAMOST sample of magnetic chemically peculiar stars as seen by TESS
- A Spectroscopic and Photometric Investigation of the Mercury-Manganese Star KIC 6128830
- Rotational modulation in A and F stars: Magnetic stellar spots or convective core rotation?
- The nature of the photometric variability of HgMn stars: A test of simulated light curves of ϕ Phe against the TESS data
- MOBSTER -- IV. Detection of a new magnetic B-type star from follow-up spectropolarimetric observations of photometrically selected candidates
- Search for stellar spots in field blue horizontal-branch stars
- V772 Cas: an ellipsoidal HgMn star in an eclipsing binary
- V680 Mon -- a young mercury-manganese star in an eclipsing heartbeat system
- BD+30549: young helium-weak silicon star in NGC 1333 star-forming region
- A conclusive non-detection of magnetic field in the Am star o Peg with high-precision near-infrared spectroscopy
- Horizontal flows in the atmospheres of chemically peculiar stars