Critical evaluation of magnetic field detections reported for pulsating B-type stars in the light of ESPaDOnS, Narval and reanalyzed FORS1/2 observations

Abstract

Recent spectropolarimetric studies of 7 SPB and $\beta$ Cep stars have suggested that photospheric magnetic fields are more common in B-type pulsators than in the general population of B stars, suggesting a significant connection between magnetic and pulsational phenomena. We present an analysis of new and previously published spectropolarimetric observations of these stars. New Stokes $V$ observations obtained with the high-resolution ESPaDOnS and Narval instruments confirm the presence of a magnetic field in one of the stars ($\epsilon$ Lup), but find no evidence of magnetism in 5 others. A re-analysis of the published longitudinal field measurements obtained with the low-resolution FORS1/2 spectropolarimeters finds that the measurements of all stars show more scatter from zero than can be attributed to Gaussian noise, suggesting the presence of a signal and/or systematic under-estimation of error bars. Re-reduction and re-measurement of the FORS1/2 spectra from the ESO archive demonstrates that small changes in reduction procedure lead to substantial changes in the inferred longitudinal field, and substantially reduces the number of field detections at the 3$\sigma$ level. Furthermore, we find that the published periods are not unique solutions to the time series of either the original or the revised FORS1/2 data. We conclude that the reported field detections, proposed periods and field geometry models for $\alpha$ Pyx, 15 CMa, 33 Eri and V1449 Aql are artefacts of the data analysis and reduction procedures, and that magnetic fields at the reported strength are no more common in SPB/$\beta$ Cep stars than in the general population of B stars.

10 pages, 5 figures, accepted for publication in ApJ, 2012, typo corrected

References in corpus (9)

• Magnetic field measurements and their uncertainties: the FORS1 legacy
• Abundance analysis of prime B-type targets for asteroseismology I. Nitrogen excess in slowly-rotating beta Cephei stars
• Discovery of magnetic fields in the beta Cephei star xi^1 CMa and in several Slowly Pulsating B stars
• Nitrogen enrichment, boron depletion and magnetic fields in slowly-rotating B-type dwarfs
• Discovery of two magnetic massive stars in the Orion Nebula Cluster: a clue to the origin of neutron star magnetic fields?
• New magnetic field measurements of beta Cephei stars and Slowly Pulsating B stars
• First magnetic field models for recently discovered magnetic beta Cephei and slowly pulsating B stars
• Photometric studies of three multiperiodic Beta Cephei stars: Beta CMa, 15 CMa and KZ Mus
• Attempts to measure the magnetic field of the pulsating B star $\nu$ Eridani

Cited by in corpus (23)

• A Magnetic Confinement vs. Rotation Classification of Massive-Star Magnetospheres
• The MiMeS Survey of Magnetism in Massive Stars: Introduction and overview
• Magnetic White Dwarf Stars in the Sloan Digital Sky Survey
• B fields in OB stars (BOB): low-resolution FORS2 spectropolarimetry of the first sample of 50 massive stars
• The Magnetic Early B-type Stars I: Magnetometry and Rotation
• Forward seismic modelling of the pulsating magnetic B-type star HD 43317
• Fundamental properties of nearby single early B-type stars
• Multisite spectroscopic seismic study of the beta Cep star V2052 Oph: inhibition of mixing by its magnetic field
• The eccentric massive binary V380 Cyg: revised orbital elements and interpretation of the intrinsic variability of the primary component
• X-ray emission from supernovae in dense circumstellar matter environments: A search for collisionless shocks
• The surface nitrogen abundance of a massive star in relation to its oscillations, rotation, and magnetic field
• Detection of magnetic fields in both B-type components of the $\epsilon$ Lupi system: a new constraint on the origin of fossil fields?
• On the consistency of magnetic field measurements of Ap stars: lessons learned from the FORS1 archive
• Are there tangled magnetic fields on HgMn stars?
• Discovery of a magnetic field in the CoRoT hybrid B-type pulsator HD 43317
• The magnetic characteristics of Galactic OB stars from the MiMeS survey of magnetism in massive stars
• Detectability of small-scale magnetic fields in early-type stars
• $\epsilon$ Lupi: measuring the heartbeat of a doubly-magnetic massive binary with BRITE-Constellation
• BD-19 5044L: discovery of a short-period SB2 system with a magnetic Bp primary in the open cluster IC 4725
• An Observational Evaluation of Magnetic Confinement in the Winds of BA Supergiants
• Discovery of extraordinary X-ray emission from magnetospheric interaction in the unique binary stellar system $\epsilon$ Lupi
• ${\xi }^1$ CMa: An Extremely Slowly Rotating Magnetic B0.7 IV Star
• Modeling surface magnetic fields in stars with radiative envelopes