Gamma-ray bursts as cosmological probes: LambdaCDM vs. conformal gravity

Abstract

LambdaCDM, for the currently preferred cosmological density Omega_0 and cosmological constant Omega_Lambda, predicts that the Universe expansion decelerates from early times to redshift z~0.9 and accelerates at later times. On the contrary, the cosmological model based on conformal gravity predicts that the cosmic expansion has always been accelerating. To distinguish between these two very different cosmologies, we resort to gamma-ray bursts (GRBs), which have been suggested to probe the Universe expansion history at z>1, where identified type Ia supernovae (SNe) are rare. We use the full Bayesian approach to infer the cosmological parameters and the additional parameters required to describe the GRB data available in the literature. For the first time, we use GRBs as cosmological probes without any prior information from other data. In addition, when we combine the GRB samples with SNe, our approach neatly avoids all the inconsistencies of most numerous previous methods that are plagued by the so-called circularity problem. In fact, when analyzed properly, current data are consistent with distance moduli of GRBs and SNe that can respectively be, in a variant of conformal gravity, ~15 and ~3 magnitudes fainter than in LambdaCDM. Our results indicate that the currently available SN and GRB samples are accommodated equally well by both LambdaCDM and conformal gravity and do not exclude a continuous accelerated expansion. We conclude that GRBs are currently far from being effective cosmological probes, as they are unable to distinguish between these two very different expansion histories.

31 pages, 12 figures, 4 tables. In the discussion section, we comment on the sensitivity of the Bayes factor on the choice of the priors. This discussion weakens the previous claim that GRBs and SNe decisively favour LambdaCDM over conformal gravity

References in corpus (16)

• Unified cosmic history in modified gravity: from F(R) theory to Lorentz non-invariant models
• Five-Year Wilkinson Microwave Anisotropy Probe (WMAP) Observations: Likelihoods and Parameters from the WMAP data
• Improved Cosmological Constraints from New, Old and Combined Supernova Datasets
• Bayes in the sky: Bayesian inference and model selection in cosmology
• Improved Dark Energy Constraints from ~100 New CfA Supernova Type Ia Light Curves
• The Hubble Diagram to Redshift >6 from 69 Gamma-Ray Bursts
• No-ghost theorem for the fourth-order derivative Pais-Uhlenbeck oscillator model
• A Cosmology-Independent Calibration of Gamma-Ray Burst Luminosity Relations and the Hubble Diagram
• Fitting galactic rotation curves with conformal gravity and a global quadratic potential
• Spectroscopic confirmation of a galaxy at redshift z=8.6
• Improved constraints on cosmological parameters from SNIa data
• Support for temporally varying behavior of the Pioneer anomaly from the extended Pioneer 10 and 11 Doppler data sets
• SNLS data are consistent with acceleration at z=3
• Conformal Gravity Challenges String Theory
• Are Gamma-Ray Bursts a Standard Energy Reservoir?
• GRB Probes of the Early Universe with EXIST

Cited by in corpus (33)

• Beyond $\Lambda$CDM: Problems, solutions, and the road ahead
• Testing General Relativity in Cosmology
• The 2M++ galaxy redshift catalogue
• Cosmology with gamma-ray bursts: I. The Hubble diagram through the calibrated $E_{\mathrm{p},\mathrm{i}}$ - $E_{\mathrm{iso}}$ correlation
• Fitting galactic rotation curves with conformal gravity and a global quadratic potential
• The Konus-Wind catalog of gamma-ray bursts with known redshifts. I. Bursts detected in the triggered mode
• Setting the Stage for Cosmic Chronometers. I. Assessing the Impact of Young Stellar Populations on Hubble Parameter Measurements
• Slope evolution of GRB correlations and cosmology
• The Konus-Wind catalog of gamma-ray bursts with known redshifts. II. Waiting mode bursts simultaneously detected by Swift/BAT
• The abundance of galaxy clusters in MOND: Cosmological simulations with massive neutrinos
• Early massive clusters and the bouncing coupled dark energy
• High redshift cosmography: new results and implication for dark energy
• Cosmological Perturbations in Conformal Gravity
• High Redshift Standard Candles: Predicted Cosmological Constraints
• Standardizing the GRBs with the Amati Ep,i - Eiso relation: the updated Hubble diagram and implications for cosmography
• The generalized Chaplygin-Jacobi gas
• On the Null Trajectories in Conformal Weyl Gravity
• Ergosphere, photon region structure, and the shadow of a rotating charged Weyl black hole
• Astrophysical Gravitational Waves in Conformal Gravity
• Classical tests on a charged Weyl black hole: bending of light, Shapiro delay and Sagnac effect
• Motion of massive particles around a charged Weyl black hole and the geodetic precession of orbiting gyroscopes
• Test of conformal gravity with astrophysical observations
• Conformal gravity does not predict flat galaxy rotation curves
• An updated analysis of two classes of f(R) theories of gravity
• High Redshift Investigation On The Dark Energy Equation of State
• Probing alternative cosmologies through the inverse distance ladder
• Conformal gravity: light deflection revisited and the galactic rotation curve failure
• Gravitational waves in conformal gravity
• Covariant formulation of refracted gravity
• Astrophysical Tests of Kinematical Conformal Cosmology in Fourth-Order Conformal Weyl Gravity
• Measurement errors and scaling relations in astrophysics: a review
• Spinor field solutions in $F\left(B^2\right)$ modified Weyl gravity
• Gamma-Ray Bursts are precise distance indicators similar to Type Ia Supernovae?