Conformal gravity does not predict flat galaxy rotation curves

Abstract

We reconsider the widely held view that the Mannheim--Kazanas (MK) vacuum solution for a static, spherically-symmetric system in conformal gravity (CG) predicts flat rotation curves, such as those observed in galaxies, without the need for dark matter. This prediction assumes that test particles have fixed rest mass and follow timelike geodesics in the MK metric in the vacuum region exterior to a spherically-symmetric representation of the galactic mass distribution. Such geodesics are not conformally invariant, however, which leads to an apparent discrepancy with the analogous calculation performed in the conformally-equivalent Schwarzschild-de-Sitter (SdS) metric, where the latter does not predict flat rotation curves. This difference arises since the mass of particles in CG must instead be generated dynamically through interaction with a scalar field. The energy-momentum of this required scalar field means that, in a general conformal frame from the equivalence class of CG solutions outside a static, spherically-symmetric matter distribution, the spacetime is not given by the MK vacuum solution. A unique frame does exist, however, for which the metric retains the MK form, since the scalar field energy-momentum vanishes despite the field being non-zero and radially dependent. Nonetheless, we show that in both this MK frame and the Einstein frame, in which the scalar field is constant, massive particles follow timelike geodesics of the SdS metric, thereby resolving the apparent frame dependence of physical predictions and unambiguously yielding rotation curves with no flat region. We also comment on how our analysis resolves the long-standing uncertainty regarding gravitational lensing in the MK metric. (Abridged)

arXiv comment13 pages, no figures

References in corpus (49)

• Alternatives to Dark Matter and Dark Energy
• No-ghost theorem for the fourth-order derivative Pais-Uhlenbeck oscillator model
• The distribution of dark matter in galaxies
• Making the Case for Conformal Gravity
• The Contribution of the Cosmological Constant to the Relativistic Bending of Light Revisited
• Exactly solvable PT-symmetric Hamiltonian having no Hermitian counterpart
• Fitting galactic rotation curves with conformal gravity and a global quadratic potential
• Impact of a global quadratic potential on galactic rotation curves
• Are galactic rotation curves really flat?
• Comprehensive Solution to the Cosmological Constant, Zero-Point Energy, and Quantum Gravity Problems
• Classical tests for Weyl gravity: deflection of light and time delay
• Linear Potentials and Galactic Rotation Curves
• Fourth order Weyl gravity
• The Relevance of the Cosmological Constant for Lensing
• Mass Generation, the Cosmological Constant Problem, Conformal Symmetry, and the Higgs Boson
• Conformal Weyl gravity and perihelion precession
• Correct light deflection in Weyl conformal gravity
• Schwarzschild limit of conformal gravity in the presence of macroscopic scalar fields
• Light deflection in Weyl gravity: constraints on the linear parameter
• Light deflection in Weyl gravity: critical distances for photon paths
• Gamma-ray bursts as cosmological probes: LambdaCDM vs. conformal gravity
• Nucleosynthesis in Power-Law Cosmologies
• Analytical formulas for gravitational lensing: higher order calculation
• Gauge choice and geodetic deflection in conformal gravity
• Cosmic acceleration as the solution to the cosmological constant problem
• Weyl gauge theories of gravity do not predict a second clock effect
• Exact gravitational lensing in conformal gravity and Schwarzschild-de Sitter spacetime
• Spontaneous breaking of conformal invariance in theories of conformally coupled matter and Weyl gravity
• Exact Static Cylindrical Solution to Conformal Weyl Gravity
• Can Conformal Weyl Gravity be Considered a Viable Cosmological Theory?
• Spherical Structures in Conformal Gravity and its Scalar-Tensor Extension
• Scale-invariant gauge theories of gravity: theoretical foundations
• Gravitational Lensing in Weyl Gravity
• How Recent is Cosmic Acceleration?
• Lambda does not Lens: Deflection of Light in the Schwarzschild-de Sitter Spacetime
• On the Null Trajectories in Conformal Weyl Gravity
• Conformal Gravity Rotation Curves with a Conformal Higgs Halo
• Test of conformal gravity with astrophysical observations
• Cosmological implications of conformal field theory
• Charged Cylindrical Black Holes in Conformal Gravity
• Not Conformally-Einstein Metrics in Conformal Gravity
• Probing alternative cosmologies through the inverse distance ladder
• Conformal gravity: light deflection revisited and the galactic rotation curve failure
• Cosmological perturbations in conformal gravity II
• Alternative gravity rotation curves for the Little Things Survey
• Exact solution to perturbative conformal cosmology in the recombination era
• Tests of $\Lambda$CDM and Conformal Gravity using GRB and Quasars as Standard Candles out to $z\sim 8$
• Gauge Choice in Conformal Gravity
• Schwarzschild and linear potentials in Mannheim's model of conformal gravity

Cited by in corpus (9)

• Emergence of the Cotton tensor for describing gravity
• On the Ghost Problem of Conformal Gravity
• Note on the absence of the second clock effect in Weyl gauge theories of gravity
• The covariant approach to static spacetimes in Einstein and extended gravity theories
• Conformally-rescaled Schwarzschild metrics do not predict flat galaxy rotation curves
• Unfolding Conformal Geometry
• Critique of the use of geodesics in astrophysics and cosmology
• Structure of conformal gravity in the presence of a scale breaking scalar field
• The $\kappa$-model, a minimal model alternative to dark matter. Application to the galactic rotation problem