Challenges of Profile Likelihood Evaluation in Multi-Dimensional SUSY Scans

Abstract

Statistical inference of the fundamental parameters of supersymmetric theories is a challenging and active endeavor. Several sophisticated algorithms have been employed to this end. While Markov-Chain Monte Carlo (MCMC) and nested sampling techniques are geared towards Bayesian inference, they have also been used to estimate frequentist confidence intervals based on the profile likelihood ratio. We investigate the performance and appropriate configuration of MultiNest, a nested sampling based algorithm, when used for profile likelihood-based analyses both on toy models and on the parameter space of the Constrained MSSM. We find that while the standard configuration is appropriate for an accurate reconstruction of the Bayesian posterior, the profile likelihood is poorly approximated. We identify a more appropriate MultiNest configuration for profile likelihood analyses, which gives an excellent exploration of the profile likelihood (albeit at a larger computational cost), including the identification of the global maximum likelihood value. We conclude that with the appropriate configuration MultiNest is a suitable tool for profile likelihood studies, indicating previous claims to the contrary are not well founded.

21 pages, 9 figures, 1 table; minor changes following referee report. Matches version accepted by JHEP

References in corpus (14)

• Bayes in the sky: Bayesian inference and model selection in cosmology
• Dark Matter Results from 100 Live Days of XENON100 Data
• Hadronic Uncertainties in the Elastic Scattering of Supersymmetric Dark Matter
• Search for Supersymmetry in pp Collisions at 7 TeV in Events with Jets and Missing Transverse Energy
• The Astrophysical Uncertainties Of Dark Matter Direct Detection Experiments
• Likelihood Functions for Supersymmetric Observables in Frequentist Analyses of the CMSSM and NUHM1
• Implications for the Constrained MSSM from a new prediction for b to s gamma
• Systematic uncertainties in the determination of the local dark matter density
• Bayesian Selection of sign(mu) within mSUGRA in Global Fits Including WMAP5 Results
• Natural Priors, CMSSM Fits and LHC Weather Forecasts
• Dependence of direct detection signals on the WIMP velocity distribution
• A Coverage Study of the CMSSM Based on ATLAS Sensitivity Using Fast Neural Networks Techniques
• Global fits of the Minimal Universal Extra Dimensions scenario
• Are BR(b->s gamma) and (g-2)_muon consistent within the Constrained MSSM?

Cited by in corpus (58)

• The Best Inflationary Models After Planck
• Nested sampling for physical scientists
• The Case for Dark Radiation
• GAMBIT: The Global and Modular Beyond-the-Standard-Model Inference Tool
• Global fits of GUT-scale SUSY models with GAMBIT
• Joining Forces of Bayesian and Frequentist Methodology: A Study for Inference in the Presence of Non-Identifiability
• Global Fits of the cMSSM and NUHM including the LHC Higgs discovery and new XENON100 constraints
• Naturalness and Fine Tuning in the NMSSM: Implications of Early LHC Results
• The CMSSM and NUHM1 after LHC Run 1
• A Global Analysis of Dark Matter Signals from 27 Dwarf Spheroidal Galaxies using 11 Years of Fermi-LAT Observations
• Implications of the Higgs Boson Discovery for mSUGRA
• Improved constraints on cosmological parameters from SNIa data
• Updated global fits of the cMSSM including the latest LHC SUSY and Higgs searches and XENON100 data
• FlavBit: A GAMBIT module for computing flavour observables and likelihoods
• Gluino-driven Radiative Breaking, Higgs Boson Mass, Muon $\mathbf{g}-2$, and the Higgs Diphoton Decay in SUGRA Unification
• Global fits of the dark matter-nucleon effective interactions
• Global fits of the cMSSM including the first LHC and XENON100 data
• Comparison of statistical sampling methods with ScannerBit, the GAMBIT scanning module
• Impact of CMS Multi-jets and Missing Energy Search on CMSSM Fits
• Profile likelihood maps of a 15-dimensional MSSM
• Compatibility of Planck and BICEP2 in the Light of Inflation
• Fundamental statistical limitations of future dark matter direct detection experiments
• Here be Dragons: The Unexplored Continents of the CMSSM
• Prospects for direct detection of dark matter in an effective theory approach
• Should we still believe in constrained supersymmetry?
• Bayesian Analysis of Inflation III: Slow Roll Reconstruction Using Model Selection
• A self-consistent phase-space distribution function for the anisotropic Dark Matter halo of the Milky Way
• How well will ton-scale dark matter direct detection experiments constrain minimal supersymmetry?
• Use of event-level neutrino telescope data in global fits for theories of new physics
• Statistical Issues in Astrophysical Searches for Particle Dark Matter
• The health of SUSY after the Higgs discovery and the XENON100 data
• Eccentric Companions to Kepler-448b and Kepler-693b: Clues to the Formation of Warm Jupiters
• Effective Field Theory of Dark Matter: a Global Analysis
• Complementarity of direct and indirect Dark Matter detection experiments
• Nuclear uncertainties in the spin-dependent structure functions for direct dark matter detection
• Global limits and interference patterns in dark matter direct detection
• Complementarity of dark matter direct detection: the role of bolometric targets
• The DNNLikelihood: enhancing likelihood distribution with Deep Learning
• Dark matter interpretations of ATLAS searches for the electroweak production of supersymmetric particles in $\sqrt{s}=8$ TeV proton-proton collisions
• A comparison of optimisation algorithms for high-dimensional particle and astrophysics applications
• Naturalness of the relaxion mechanism
• Statistical coverage for supersymmetric parameter estimation: a case study with direct detection of dark matter
• Determining Dark Matter properties with a XENONnT/LZ signal and LHC-Run3 mono-jet searches
• Implications for constrained supersymmetry of combined H.E.S.S. observations of dwarf galaxies, the Galactic halo and the Galactic Centre
• Perspectives of direct Detection of supersymmetric Dark Matter in the NMSSM
• Astrophysical interpretation of the anisotropies in the unresolved gamma-ray background
• Is the CNMSSM more credible than the CMSSM?
• Bayesian analysis and naturalness of (Next-to-)Minimal Supersymmetric Models
• Surrogate Models for Direct Dark Matter Detection
• Impact of nucleon matrix element uncertainties on the interpretation of direct and indirect dark matter search results
• Supersymmetric Fits after the Higgs Discovery and Implications for Model Building
• Where is SUSY?
• EasyScan_HEP: a tool for connecting programs to scan the parameter space of physics models
• Supersymmetry With Prejudice: Fitting the Wrong Model to LHC Data
• Entanglement masquerading in the CMB
• LHC and dark matter phenomenology of the NUGHM
• Search for Dark Matter in the Sun with the ANTARES Neutrino Telescope in the CMSSM and mUED frameworks
• Genetic algorithm demystified for cosmological parameter estimation