Compatibility of Planck and BICEP2 in the Light of Inflation

Abstract

We investigate the implications for inflation of the detection of B-modes polarization in the Cosmic Microwave Background (CMB) by BICEP2. We show that the hypothesis of primordial origin of the measurement is only favored by the first four bandpowers, while the others would prefer unreasonably large values of the tensor-to-scalar ratio. Using only those four bandpowers, we carry out a complete analysis in the cosmological and inflationary slow-roll parameter space using the BICEP2 polarization measurements alone and extract the Bayesian evidences and complexities for all the Encyclopaedia Inflationaris models. This allows us to determine the most probable and simplest BICEP2 inflationary scenarios. Although this list contains the simplest monomial potentials, it also includes many other scenarios, suggesting that focusing model building efforts on large field models only is unjustified at this stage. We demonstrate that the sets of inflationary models preferred by Planck alone and BICEP2 alone are almost disjoint, indicating a clear tension between the two data sets. We address this tension with a Bayesian measure of compatibility between BICEP2 and Planck. We find that for models favored by Planck the two data sets tend to be incompatible, whereas there is a moderate evidence of compatibility for the BICEP2 preferred models. As a result, it would be premature to draw any conclusion on the best Planck models, such as Starobinsky and/or Kahler moduli inflation. For the subset of scenarios not exhibiting data sets incompatibility, we update the evidences and complexities using both data sets together.

arXiv comment26 pages, 19 figures, uses RevTex. References added, matches published version

References in corpus (94)

• Nine-Year Wilkinson Microwave Anisotropy Probe (WMAP) Observations: Cosmological Parameter Results
• Efficient Computation of CMB anisotropies in closed FRW models
• Cosmological parameters from CMB and other data: a Monte-Carlo approach
• MultiNest: an efficient and robust Bayesian inference tool for cosmology and particle physics
• Non-Gaussian features of primordial fluctuations in single field inflationary models
• Nine-Year Wilkinson Microwave Anisotropy Probe (WMAP) Observations: Final Maps and Results
• k-Inflation
• Five-Year Wilkinson Microwave Anisotropy Probe (WMAP) Observations: Likelihoods and Parameters from the WMAP data
• Multimodal nested sampling: an efficient and robust alternative to MCMC methods for astronomical data analysis
• BICEP2 I: Detection Of B-mode Polarization at Degree Angular Scales
• Bayes in the sky: Bayesian inference and model selection in cosmology
• Perturbations in k-inflation
• Encyclopaedia Inflationaris
• Evidence for strong extragalactic magnetic fields from Fermi observations of TeV blazars
• Everything You Always Wanted To Know About The Cosmological Constant Problem (But Were Afraid To Ask)
• Equilibrium State of a Massless Self-Interacting Scalar Field in the De Sitter Background
• What would we learn by detecting a gravitational wave signal in the cosmic microwave background anisotropy?
• Beyond LISA: Exploring Future Gravitational Wave Missions
• Cosmological Signature of New Parity-Violating Interactions
• A more accurate analytic calculation of the spectrum of cosmological perturbations produced during inflation
• Cosmological perturbations
• N-flation
• G-inflation: inflation driven by the Galileon field
• Assisted inflation
• The intergalactic magnetic field constrained by Fermi/LAT observations of the TeV blazar 1ES 0229+200
• Applications of Bayesian model selection to cosmological parameters
• First CMB Constraints on the Inflationary Reheating Temperature
• Lower limit on the strength and filling factor of extragalactic magnetic fields
• The Best Inflationary Models After Planck
• Generation of Large-Scale Magnetic Fields in Single-Field Inflation
• Magnetic fields from inflation?
• Likelihood Analysis of CMB Temperature and Polarization Power Spectra
• Inflation after WMAP3: Confronting the Slow-Roll and Exact Power Spectra with CMB Data
• Higher order corrections to primordial spectra from cosmological inflation
• Cosmological parameter estimation and the inflationary cosmology
• The Density Perturbation Power Spectrum to Second-Order Corrections in the Slow-Roll Expansion
• Measurement of Cosmic Microwave Background Polarization Power Spectra from Two Years of BICEP Data
• Probing reheating temperature of the universe with gravitational wave background
• Problems with Tachyon Inflation
• Quantum-to-classical Transition of Cosmological Perturbations for Non-vacuum Initial States
• Determination of intergalactic magnetic fields from gamma ray data
• Birefringent Gravitational Waves and the Consistency Check of Inflation
• Measuring the effective complexity of cosmological models
• Bayesian Analysis of Inflation II: Model Selection and Constraints on Reheating
• Shortcomings in the Understanding of Why Cosmological Perturbations Look Classical
• Cosmological Inflation and the Quantum Measurement Problem
• Inflationary Magnetogenesis without the Strong Coupling Problem
• Combining cosmological datasets: hyperparameters and Bayesian evidence
• WKB approximation for inflationary cosmological perturbations
• On the Decoherence of Primordial Fluctuations During Inflation
• Anomalous CMB polarization and gravitational chirality
• Bayesian evidence as a tool for comparing datasets
• Bayesian Selection of sign(mu) within mSUGRA in Global Fits Including WMAP5 Results
• Inflationary Magnetogenesis without the Strong Coupling Problem II: Constraints from CMB anisotropies and B-modes
• Primordial non-Gaussianity from G-inflation
• Using Cosmology to Establish the Quantization of Gravity
• The tensor-to-scalar ratio in punctuated inflation
• Nflation: multi-field inflationary dynamics and perturbations
• Hunting Down the Best Model of Inflation with Bayesian Evidence
• Fingerprints of Galactic Loop I on the Cosmic Microwave Background
• The Inflationary Perturbation Spectrum
• Challenges of Profile Likelihood Evaluation in Multi-Dimensional SUSY Scans
• Whipped inflation
• Primordial fluctuations and cosmological inflation after WMAP 1.0
• Cosmic strings and their induced non-Gaussianities in the cosmic microwave background
• Resurrecting Quadratic Inflation in No-Scale Supergravity in Light of BICEP2
• Simple predictions from multifield inflationary models
• K-inflationary Power Spectra in the Uniform Approximation
• Quantum-to-classical transition of primordial cosmological perturbations in de Broglie--Bohm quantum theory
• Did BICEP2 see vector modes? First B-mode constraints on cosmic defects
• Can topological defects mimic the BICEP2 B-mode signal?
• Can primordial magnetic fields be the origin of the BICEP2 data?
• Quantum to Classical Transition of Inflationary Perturbations - Continuous Spontaneous Localization as a Possible Mechanism -
• BICEP2 implications for single-field slow-roll inflation revisited
• K-inflationary Power Spectra at Second Order
• Improved WKB analysis of cosmological perturbations
• Polynomial inflation models after BICEP2
• Exact Mapping between Tensor and Most General Scalar Power Spectra
• Suppressing the impact of a high tensor-to-scalar ratio on the temperature anisotropies
• On Perturbation Spectra of N-flation
• Ruling out the power-law form of the scalar primordial spectrum
• Solving Stochastic Inflation for Arbitrary Potentials
• Higher Order Slow-Roll Predictions for Inflation
• Complementarity of direct and indirect Dark Matter detection experiments
• Improved WKB analysis of Slow-Roll Inflation
• Reheating constraints in inflationary magnetogenesis
• Early Universe Tomography with CMB and Gravitational Waves
• Magneto-reheating constraints from curvature perturbations
• Fast Bayesian inference for slow-roll inflation
• Inflationary Tensor Perturbations After BICEP
• Chasing a consistent picture for dark matter direct searches
• Generic inference of inflation models by non-Gaussianity and primordial power spectrum reconstruction
• Does the BICEP2 Observation of Cosmological Tensor Modes Imply an Era of Nearly Planckian Energy Densities?
• Quantifying the tension between the Higgs mass and (g-2)_mu in the CMSSM

Cited by in corpus (45)

• Concordance and Discordance in Cosmology
• Inflationary universe from perfect fluid and $F(R)$ gravity and its comparison with observational data
• Exploring Cosmic Origins with CORE: Inflation
• The Observational Status of Cosmic Inflation after Planck
• Inflation after Planck: Judgment Day
• Assessing tension metrics with Dark Energy Survey and Planck data
• Is there concordance within the concordance $\Lambda$CDM model?
• Consistency relation for $R^p$ inflation
• Non-Gaussian estimates of tensions in cosmological parameters
• B-modes and the Nature of Inflation
• Quantifying concordance of correlated cosmological data sets
• Information Gain on Reheating: the One Bit Milestone
• Renormalization-group inflationary scalar electrodynamics and SU(5) scenarios confronted with Planck2013 and BICEP2 results
• On the scalar consistency relation away from slow roll
• Quantifying Tensions between CMB and Distance Datasets in Models with Free Curvature or Lensing Amplitude
• Inflation, the Hubble Tension and Early Dark Energy: an alternative overview
• Quantifying Concordance in Cosmology
• Cosmic Inflation at the Crossroads
• Shortcomings of New Parametrizations of Inflation
• Inflation with an extra light scalar field after Planck
• Inflationary Potential as seen from Different Angles: Model Compatibility from Multiple CMB Missions
• COSMOS-$e^{\prime }$-GTachyon from String Theory
• Gravity Waves From Non-Minimal Quadratic Inflation
• A new measure of tension between experiments
• Naturalness of the relaxion mechanism
• Generation of large-scale magnetic fields, non-Gaussianity, and primordial gravitational waves in inflationary cosmology
• Pre-inflationary genesis with CMB B-mode polarization
• Tracking the Multifield Dynamics with Cosmological Data: A Monte Carlo approach
• Small field models with gravitational wave signature supported by CMB data
• Revised cosmological parameters after BICEP 2 and BOSS
• Tensors, BICEP2, prior dependence, and dust
• Estimation of Inflation parameters for Perturbed Power Law model using recent CMB measurements
• Constraints on the Combined Models with $R^{2-q}$ Inflation and Viable $f(R)$ Dark Energy
• Constraining brane inflationary magnetic field from cosmoparticle physics after Planck
• BICEP's acceleration
• Updated Constraints on Large Field Hybrid Inflation
• B-modes and the sound speed of primordial fluctuations
• Primordial Magnetic Field Generated in Natural Infation
• Power law $\alpha$-Starobinsky inflation
• An introduction to inflation after Planck: from theory to observations
• The scalar-scalar-tensor inflationary three-point function in the axion monodromy model
• Numerical evaluation of the tensor bispectrum in two field inflation
• Numerical Analysis of the Primordial Power Spectrum for (Small Field) Inflationary Potentials
• The Primordial Magnetic Field (PMF) Generated in Large Field Inflation (LFI), Natural Inflation (NI) and $R^2$-Inflation by $f^{2}FF$ Model
• Primordial magnetic fields in the $f^{2}FF$ model in large field inflation under de Sitter and power law expansion