Challenging times: a re-analysis of NGC 5408 X-1
arXiv:1009.2686 · doi:10.1111/j.1365-2966.2010.17712.x
Abstract
The ultraluminous X-ray source (ULX), NGC 5408 X-1, is one of only 3 such objects to show a quasi-periodic oscillation (QPO) in its power spectrum. Previous analysis of this signal identified it with the well-studied type C low-frequency QPO (LFQPO) seen in black hole binaries (BHBs), implying an intermediate mass black hole (IMBH). However, in BHBs this QPO has a centroid frequency which scales tightly with the position of the low-frequency break in the broad band power spectrum. We use this relation to predict the frequency of the power spectral break in NGC 5408 X-1, and show that this is inconsistent with the break frequencies in both available, archival XMM-Newton observations. Thus the broad band power spectral shape does not support this identification of the QPO. The energy spectra also do not support an IMBH interpretation. They can be fit by a two-component model, best described by soft thermal emission at low energies, together with low-temperature, optically thick Comptonisation producing a tail which dominates above 2 keV. The parameters of the tail are unlike those seen in any of the sub-Eddington BHB spectral states. The energy dependent variability supports this deconvolution, as it is consistent with the soft thermal component below 2 keV diluting extreme variability of the high energy tail. The only objects with similar spectra which have similar amounts of variability are the BHB, GRS 1915+105, and some extreme NLS1s. This suggests that NGC 5408 X-1 is in a similar super-Eddington state, placing a natural limit on the mass of < 100 solar masses. Its QPO could then be similar to the ultra-LFQPO seen occasionally in GRS 1915+105, consistent with a large stellar mass black hole. We suggest a model geometry which may explain the spectra and variability of highly super-Eddington sources.
arXiv comment10 pages, 8 figures, accepted by MNRAS
References in corpus (68)
- X-ray Properties of Black-Hole Binaries
- Modelling the behaviour of accretion flows in X-ray binaries
- On characterising the variability properties of X-ray light curves from active galaxies
- Ultraluminous X-Ray Sources in External Galaxies
- The Nature of Accreting Black Holes in Nearby Galaxy Nuclei
- On The Maximum Mass of Stellar Black Holes
- Super-critically accreting stellar-mass black holes as ultraluminous X-ray sources
- The Ultraluminous State
- Intermediate-Mass Black Holes
- X-ray Spectral Variability and Rapid Variability of the Soft X-ray Spectrum Seyfert 1 Galaxies Ark 564 and Ton S180
- Black Hole Winds
- A Comprehensive Spectral and Variability Study of Narrow-Line Seyfert 1 Galaxies Observed by ASCA: II. Spectral Analysis and Correlations
- The flux-dependent amplitude of broadband noise variability in X-ray binaries and active galaxies
- Soft state of Cygnus X-1: stable disk and unstable corona
- X-ray Spectroscopic Evidence for Intermediate Mass Black Holes: Cool Accretion Disks in Two Ultra--Luminous X-ray Sources
- The broad-band power spectra of X-ray binaries
- XMM-Newton observations of the brightest Ultraluminous X-ray sources
- An unstable central disk in the superluminal black-hole X-ray binary GRS 1915+105
- The Nature of SS433 and the Ultraluminous X-ray Sources
- The effect of radiation pressure on virial black hole mass estimates and the case of Narrow Line Seyfert 1 galaxies
- Global Radiation-Magnetohydrodynamic Simulations of Black Hole Accretion Flow and Outflow: Unified Model of Three States
- Discovery of X-ray QPOs from an Ultra-luminous X-ray Source in M82: Evidence Against Beaming
- M-BH - sigma relation for a Complete Sample of Soft X-ray Selected AGNs
- Slim Disk Model for Ultra-Luminous X-Ray Sources
- Radio Emission from an Ultraluminous X-Ray Source
- X-ray observations of ultraluminous X-ray sources
- HST STIS Ultraviolet Spectral Evidence of Outflow in Extreme Narrow-line Seyfert 1 Galaxies: II. Modeling and Interpretation
- OSSE and RXTE Observations of GRS 1915+105: Evidence for Non-thermal Comptonization
- GRS 1915+105: The brightest Galactic black hole
- ROSAT monitoring of persistent giant and rapid variability in the narrow-line Seyfert 1 galaxy IRAS 13224-3809
- Spectral variability of ultraluminous X-ray sources
- Long-Term X-ray Spectral Variability in Seyfert 1 Galaxies
- Super-Eddington accretion disc around a Kerr black hole
- GRS 1915+105 in "Soft State": Nature of Accretion Disk Wind and Origin of X-Ray Emission
- Quasi-Periodic Variability in NGC 5408 X-1
- The relationship between X-ray variability amplitude and black hole mass in active galactic nuclei
- Revealing a Cool Accretion Disk in the Ultraluminous X-ray Source M81 X-9 (Holmberg IX X-1): Evidence for an Intermediate Mass Black Hole
- An optically thick inner corona geometry for the Very High State Galactic Black Hole XTE J1550-564
- The distribution of kHz QPO frequencies in bright LMXBs
- A Systematic Study of Variability in a Sample of Ultraluminous X-ray Sources
- RE J1034+396: The origin of the soft X-ray excess and QPO
- Broad-band spectra of Cyg X-1 and correlations between spectral characteristics
- X-ray reverberation in 1H0707-495 revisited
- Evidence for an Intermediate Mass Black Hole in NGC 5408 X-1
- Probable intermediate mass black holes in NGC4559: XMM-Newton spectral and timing constraints
- Spectral States and Evolution of Ultraluminous X-ray Sources
- Patterns of energy-dependent variability from Comptonization
- Relativistic disc reflection in the extreme NLS1 IRAS13224-3809
- A transition to a low/soft state in the ultra-luminous compact X-ray source Holmberg II X-1
- XMM-Newton EPIC observations of the ultraluminous X-ray source NGC 5204 X-1
- GRS 1915+105: the distance, radiative processes and energy-dependent variability
- Angular Momentum Transport in Accretion Disks and its Implications for Spin Estimates in Black Hole Binaries
- Suzaku Observation of GRS 1915+105: Evolution of Accretion Disc Structure during Limit-Cycle Oscillation
- The linear rms-flux relation in an Ultraluminous X-ray Source
- Feedback from supercritical disk accretion flows; Two-dimensional radiation-hydrodynamic simulations of stable and unstable disks with radiatively driven outflows
- X-ray spectral variability in the ultraluminous X-ray source Holmberg IX X-1
- Discovery of mHz X-ray Oscillations in a Transient Ultraluminous X-ray Source in M82
- Weighing the black holes in ultraluminous X-ray sources through timing
- Compton scattering as the explanation of the peculiar X-ray properties of Cyg X-3
- The X-ray variability of the Narrow-Line Seyfert 1 galaxy IRAS 13224-3809 from an XMM-Newton observation
- X-ray reflection in a sample of X-ray bright Ultraluminous X-ray sources
- A review of rapid X-ray variability in X-ray binaries
- Suzaku Observations of M82 X-1 : Detection of a Curved Hard X-ray Spectrum
- Detection of Strong Short-Term Variability in NGC 6946 X-1
- The nature of the intranight variability of radio-quiet quasars
- Optically Thick Outflows of Supercritical Accretion Discs: Radiative Diffusion Approach
- On the artificial nature of aperiodic variability in XMM-Newton observations of M31 X-ray sources and the ultraluminous X-ray source NGC 4559 ULX-7
- An XMM-Newton view of M101 - III. Diffuse X-ray emission
Cited by in corpus (83)
- Ultraluminous X-Ray Sources
- Ultraluminous X-ray Sources in the Chandra and XMM-Newton Era
- Observational evidence for intermediate-mass black holes
- The ultraluminous state revisited: fractional variability and spectral shape as diagnostics of super-Eddington accretion
- A 400 solar mass black hole in the Ultraluminous X-ray source M82 X-1 accreting close to its Eddington limit
- A spectral-timing model for ULXs in the super-critical regime
- The ultraluminous X-ray sources NGC 1313 X-1 and X-2: a broadband study with NuSTAR and XMM-Newton
- Ultraluminous X-ray sources
- 2XMM Ultraluminous X-Ray Source Candidates in Nearby Galaxies
- Clumpy Outflow from Supercritical Accretion Flows
- The most extreme ultraluminous X-ray sources: evidence for intermediate-mass black holes?
- From ultraluminous X-ray sources to ultraluminous supersoft sources: NGC 55 ULX, the missing link
- Diagnosing the accretion flow in ultraluminous X-ray sources using soft X-ray atomic features
- Broad absorption features in wind-dominated ULXs?
- Broadband X-ray Spectra of the Ultraluminous X-ray Source Holmberg IX X-1 observed with NuSTAR, XMM-Newton and Suzaku
- Optically thick outflows in ultraluminous supersoft sources
- Optical counterparts of the nearest ultraluminous X-ray sources
- The Broadband XMM-Newton and NuSTAR X-ray Spectra of Two Ultraluminous X-ray Sources in the Galaxy IC 342
- Optical emission of the ultraluminous X-ray source NGC 5408 X-1: donor star or irradiated accretion disk?
- Searching for Outflows in Ultraluminous X-ray Sources Through High-Resolution X-ray Spectroscopy
- The missing link: a low mass X-ray binary in M31 seen as an ultraluminous X-ray source
- XMM-Newton campaign on the ultraluminous X-ray source NGC 247 ULX-1: outflows
- X-ray spectral evolution in M33 X-8
- Three-dimensional structure of clumpy outflow from supercritical accretion flow onto black holes
- X-ray spectral states and metallicity in the ultraluminous X-ray sources NGC 1313 X-1 and X-2
- NuSTAR, XMM-Newton and Suzaku Observations of the Ultraluminous X-ray Source Holmberg II X-1
- NuSTAR reveals the hidden nature of SS433
- Radio observations of extreme ULXs: revealing the most powerful ULX radio nebula ever or the jet of an intermediate-mass black hole?
- A Hard X-Ray Study of Ultraluminous X-ray Source NGC 5204 X-1 with NuSTAR and XMM-Newton
- Ultra Luminous X-ray Sources: a deeper insight into their spectral evolution
- The X-ray spectral evolution of the ultraluminous X-ray source Holmberg IX X-1
- Lense-Thirring precession in ULXs as a possible means to constrain the neutron star equation-of-state
- (No) dynamical constraints on the mass of the black hole in two ULXs
- An optically-thick disk wind in GRO J1655-40?
- Radiation Hydrodynamic Instability in Plane-Parallel, Super-Eddington Atmosphere: A Mechanism for Clump Formation
- Time lags in the ultraluminous X-ray source NGC 5408 X-1: implications for the black hole mass
- Can nebular HeII emission be explained by ultra-luminous X-ray sources?
- A long-term X-ray monitoring of the ultraluminous X-ray source NGC 5408 X-1 with Swift reveals the presence of dips but no orbital period
- The Lense-Thirring timing-accretion plane for ULXs
- Revisiting the ultraluminous supersoft source in M101: an optically thick outflow model
- Thermal stability of winds driven by radiation pressure in super-Eddington accretion disks
- A bright ultraluminous X-ray source in NGC 5907
- A variable ULX and possible IMBH candidate in M51a
- Evidence for High-Frequency QPOs with a 3:2 Frequency Ratio from a 5000 Solar Mass Black Hole
- A Multi-epoch Timing and Spectral Study of the Ultraluminous X-Ray Source NGC 5408 X-1 with XMM-Newton
- Irradiated, colour-temperature-corrected accretion discs in ultraluminous X-ray sources
- Searching for Massive Outflows in Holmberg IX X-1 and NGC 1313 X-1: The Iron K Band
- The Broadband Spectral Variability of Holmberg IX X-1
- X-ray time lags and nonlinear variability in the ultraluminous X-ray sources NGC 5408 X-1 and NGC 6946 X-1
- Discovery of a recurrent spectral evolutionary cycle in the ultra-luminous X-ray sources Holmberg II X-1 and NGC 5204 X-1
- Exploring the Long-Term Evolution of GRS 1915+105
- Searching for intermediate-mass black holes in globular clusters with gravitational microlensing
- MUSE spectroscopy of the ULX NGC 1313 X-1: a shock-ionised bubble, an X-ray photoionised nebula, and two supernova remnants
- A deficit of ultraluminous X-ray sources in luminous infrared galaxies
- No Strong Geometric Beaming in the Ultraluminous Neutron Star Binary NGC 300 ULX-1 (SN 2010da) from Swift and Gemini
- Evidence for Quasi-periodic X-Ray Dips from an Ultraluminous X-Ray Source: Implications for the Binary Motion
- Ultraluminous X-ray sources with flat-topped noise and QPO
- Discovery of a soft X-ray lag in the Ultraluminous X-ray Source NGC 1313 X-1
- Discovery of a Quasi-Periodic Oscillation in the Ultraluminous X-ray Source IC 342 X-1: XMM-Newton Results
- A variable ultraluminous X-ray source in a globular cluster in NGC 4649
- Searching for coherent pulsations in ultraluminous X-ray sources
- Spectral variability in Swift and Chandra observations of the Ultraluminous source NGC 55 ULX1
- Temporal evolution of long-timescale periodicities in ULX NGC 5408 X-1
- Geometrical beaming of stellar mass ULXs
- ULX behaviour: the ultraluminous state, winds & interesting anomalies
- X-ray variability and energy spectra from NGC5408 X-1 with XMM-Newton
- Constraining the mass of accreting black holes in ultraluminous X-ray sources with ultrafast outflows
- Suzaku Observations of Spectral Variations of the Ultra Luminous X-ray Source Holmberg IX X-1
- The ultraluminous X-ray source M81 X-6: a weakly magnetised neutron star with a precessing accretion disc?
- The largest bright ULX population in a galaxy: X-ray variability and Luminosity Function in the Cartwheel ring Galaxy
- A transient ultraluminous X-ray source in NGC 55
- Confirming the 115.5-day periodicity in the X-ray light curve of ULX NGC 5408 X-1
- General Relativistic Radiation Magnetohydrodynamics Simulations of Precessing Tilted Super-Eddington Disks
- X-ray reverberation models of the disc wind in ultraluminous X-ray source NGC 5408 X-1
- Deep observations of the NGC 4472 globular cluster black hole XMMU 122939.7+075333: Short term variability from the first globular cluster black hole binary
- A Long-term Study of Ultraluminous X-ray Sources in NGC 891
- A NuSTAR study of quasi-periodic oscillations from the ultraluminous X-ray sources in M82
- The kilo-second variability of X-ray sources in nearby galaxies
- First Search for an X-ray -- Optical Reverberation Signal in an Ultraluminous X-ray Source
- Probing extreme black-hole outflows on short timescales via high spectral-resolution X-ray imagers
- A comparative study of occurrence rates and nature of Ultraluminous X-ray sources in spiral and elliptical galaxies
- Spectral and Temporal Properties of Ultra-luminous X-ray Source NGC 55 ULX1
- The aperiodic variability of the Ultraluminous X-ray source in NGC 5408