Limits of sensing temporal concentration changes by single cells

Abstract

Berg and Purcell [Biophys. J. 20, 193 (1977)] calculated how the accuracy of concentration sensing by single-celled organisms is limited by noise from the small number of counted molecules. Here we generalize their results to the sensing of concentration ramps, which is often the biologically relevant situation (e.g. during bacterial chemotaxis). We calculate lower bounds on the uncertainty of ramp sensing by three measurement devices: a single receptor, an absorbing sphere, and a monitoring sphere. We contrast two strategies, simple linear regression of the input signal versus maximum likelihood estimation, and show that the latter can be twice as accurate as the former. Finally, we consider biological implementations of these two strategies, and identify possible signatures that maximum likelihood estimation is implemented by real biological systems.

11 pages, 2 figures

References in corpus (2)

• Accuracy of direct gradient sensing by single cells
• Maximum likelihood and the single receptor

Cited by in corpus (50)

• The Energetic Costs of Cellular Computation
• Cost and Precision of Brownian Clocks
• E. coli chemotaxis is information-limited
• Thermodynamics of statistical inference by cells
• Information-theoretic vs. thermodynamic entropy production in autonomous sensory networks
• Bacteria push the limits of chemotactic precision to navigate dynamic chemical gradients
• Physical limit to concentration sensing amid spurious ligands
• The thermodynamics of computational copying in biochemical systems
• Perspectives on theory at the interface of physics and biology
• Physical limit to concentration sensing in a changing environment
• Fundamental Limits on Sensing Chemical Concentrations with Linear Biochemical Networks
• Spectral theory of fluctuations in time-average statistical mechanics of reversible and driven systems
• Receptor crosstalk improves concentration sensing of multiple ligands
• Physical Limits on Bacterial Navigation in Dynamic Environments
• Know the single-receptor sensing limit? Think again
• Memory improves precision of cell sensing in fluctuating environments
• Unraveling Adaptation in Eukaryotic Pathways: Lessons from Protocells
• Accurate encoding and decoding by single cells: amplitude versus frequency modulation
• Immune cells use active tugging forces to distinguish affinity and accelerate evolution
• A connection between bacterial chemotactic network and optimal filtering
• Optimal sensing and control of run-and-tumble chemotaxis
• Universal energy-accuracy tradeoffs in nonequilibrium cellular sensing
• Optimal time estimation and the clock uncertainty relation for stochastic processes
• Physical limits on cellular directional mechanosensing
• The accuracy of telling time via oscillatory signals
• Dispersion for Two Classes of Random Variables: General Theory and Application to Inference of an External Ligand Concentration by a Cell
• Extending the dynamic range of transcription factor action by translational regulation
• Bayesian gradient sensing in the presence of rotational diffusion
• Precision of flow sensing by self-communicating cells
• Optimal inference strategies and their implications for the linear noise approximation
• Multi-dimensional biochemical information processing of dynamical patterns
• Biological implications of dynamical phases in non-equilibrium networks
• Pleiotropy enables specific and accurate signaling in the presence of ligand cross talk
• A thermodynamic paradigm for solution demixing inspired by nuclear transport in living cells
• Unified Linear Fluctuation-Response Theory Arbitrarily Far from Equilibrium
• Tradeoffs in concentration sensing in dynamic environments
• Slower swimming promotes chemotactic encounters between bacteria and small phytoplankton
• Dispersion of the time spent in a state: General expression for unicyclic model and dissipation-less precision
• Precision of protein thermometry
• Optimal temporal patterns for dynamical cellular signaling
• Limits on the accuracy of contact inhibition of locomotion
• Nonequilibrium fluctuation-response relations for state observables
• Ambitions for theory in the physics of life
• Accuracy in readout of glutamate concentrations by neuronal cells
• Nonlinear Response Relations and Fluctuation-Response Inequalities for Nonequilibrium Stochastic Systems
• Counting observables in stochastic excursions
• Chemotaxing E. coli do not count single molecules
• Framework for fluctuating times and counting observables in stochastic excursions
• Detecting concentration changes with cooperative receptors
• Hunchback promoters can readout morphogenetic positional information in less than a minute