Tradeoffs in concentration sensing in dynamic environments

Abstract

When cells measure concentrations of chemical signals, they may average multiple measurements over time in order to reduce noise in their measurements. However, when cells are in a environment that changes over time, past measurements may not reflect current conditions - creating a new source of error that trades off against noise in chemical sensing. What statistics in the cell's environment control this tradeoff? What properties of the environment make it variable enough that this tradeoff is relevant? We model a single eukaryotic cell sensing a chemical secreted from bacteria (e.g. folic acid). In this case, the environment changes because the bacteria swim - leading to changes in the true concentration at the cell. We develop analytical calculations and stochastic simulations of sensing in this environment. We find that cells can have a huge variety of optimal sensing strategies, ranging from not time averaging at all, to averaging over an arbitrarily long time, or having a finite optimal averaging time. The factors that primarily control the ideal averaging are the ratio of sensing noise to environmental variation, and the ratio of timescales of sensing to the timescale of environmental variation. Sensing noise depends on the receptor-ligand kinetics, while the environmental variation depends on the density of bacteria and the degradation and diffusion properties of the secreted chemoattractant. Our results suggest that fluctuating environmental concentrations may be a relevant source of noise even in a relatively static environment.

References in corpus (18)

• Active Brownian Particles. From Individual to Collective Stochastic Dynamics
• Bacterial hopping and trapping in porous media
• Running and tumbling with E. coli in polymeric solutions
• The Energetic Costs of Cellular Computation
• Enhanced diffusion due to active swimmers at a solid surface
• Dynamics of Self-Propelled Particles Under Strong Confinement
• Dynamics of a self-propelled particle in a harmonic trap
• Fluctuations and Rheology in Active Bacterial Suspensions
• Maximum likelihood and the single receptor
• Bacteria display optimal transport near surfaces -- bacteria as intermittent active chiral particles: trapped by hydrodynamics, escaping by adhesion
• Thermodynamics of statistical inference by cells
• Limits of sensing temporal concentration changes by single cells
• Steady State of an Active Brownian Particle in Two-Dimensional Harmonic Trap
• Collective signal processing in cluster chemotaxis: roles of adaptation, amplification, and co-attraction in collective guidance
• Physical limit to concentration sensing in a changing environment
• Universal properties of concentration sensing in large ligand-receptor networks
• Bayesian gradient sensing in the presence of rotational diffusion
• Chemotaxis in uncertain environments: hedging bets with multiple receptor types

Cited by in corpus (2)

• Limits on the accuracy of contact inhibition of locomotion
• Perfect adaptation in eukaryotic gradient sensing using cooperative allosteric binding