The Age of Ellipticals and the Color-Magnitude Relation

Abstract

Using new narrowband color observations of early-type galaxies in clusters, we reconstruct the color-magnitude relation (CMR) with a higher degree of accuracy than previous work. We then use the spectroscopically determined ages and metallicities from three samples (Trager et al 2008, Thomas et al 2005, Gallazzi et al 2006), combined with multi-metallicity SED models, to compare predicted colors for galaxies with young ages (less than 8 Gyr) with the known CMR. We find that the CMR cannot by reproduced by the spectroscopically determined ages and metallicities in any of the samples despite the high internal accuracies to the spectroscopic indices. In contrast, using only the $<$Fe$>$ index to determine [Fe/H], and assuming a mean age of 12 Gyr for a galaxy's stellar population, we derive colors that exactly match not only the color zeropoint of the CMR but also its slope. We consider the source of young age estimates, the H$\beta$ index, and examine the conflict between red continuum colors and large H$\beta$ values in galaxy spectra. We conclude that our current understanding of stellar populations is insufficient to correctly interpret H$\beta$ values and that the sum of our galaxy observations supports an old and monolithic scenario of galaxy formation. This result has a devastating impact on every study that has used the H$\beta$ index to calculate galaxy age, as the use of the H$\beta$ versus MgFe diagram will result in incorrectly deduced young ages.

29 pages, 9 figures. This version deviates from the version accepted by ApJ

References in corpus (18)

• Ages and metallicities of early-type galaxies in the SDSS: new insight into the physical origin of the colour-magnitude and the Mg2-sigmaV relations
• Population Synthesis in the Blue IV: Accurate Model Predictions for Lick Indices and UBV Colors in Single Stellar Populations
• The DEEP2 Galaxy Redshift Survey: The Role of Galaxy Environment in the Cosmic Star-Formation History
• Evolution of the Color-Magnitude Relation in Galaxy Clusters at z ~1 from the ACS Intermediate Redshift Cluster Survey
• A Large Stellar Evolution Database for Population Synthesis Studies. III. Inclusion of the full Asymptotic Giant Branch phase and Web tools for stellar population analyses
• Measuring Ages and Elemental Abundances from Unresolved Stellar Populations: Fe, Mg, C, N, and Ca
• Dissecting the Red Sequence--I. Star Formation Histories of Quiescent Galaxies: The Color-Magnitude vs. the Color-Sigma Relation
• The stellar population histories of early-type galaxies. III. The Coma Cluster
• A large stellar evolution database for population synthesis studies. IV. Integrated properties and spectra
• An optimized H_βindex for disentangling stellar population ages
• Galaxy evolution in the high redshift, colour-selected cluster RzCS 052 at z=1.02
• The Evolutionary History of Galactic Bulges: Photometric and Spectroscopic Studies of Distant Spheroids in the GOODS Fields
• The nature of the SDSS galaxies in various classes based on morphology, colour and spectral features -- I. Optical properties
• Color-magnitude relations of late-type galaxies
• Stellar age versus mass of early-type galaxies in the Virgo Cluster
• The Age of Cluster Galaxies from Continuum Colors
• The star formation histories of early-type galaxies: insights from the rest-frame ultra-violet
• Ages of Elliptical Galaxies: Single versus Multi Population Interpretation

Cited by in corpus (11)

• Fitting the integrated Spectral Energy Distributions of Galaxies
• Stellar Populations and the Star Formation Histories of LSB Galaxies: III. Stellar Population Models
• Stellar Populations and the Star Formation Histories of LSB Galaxies: I. Optical and H-alpha Imaging
• Mapping the galaxy NGC 4486 (M87) through its Globular Cluster System
• Colors of Ellipticals from GALEX to Spitzer
• Stellar Populations and the Star Formation Histories of LSB Galaxies: IV Spitzer Surface Photometry of LSB Galaxies
• Colors of Dwarf Ellipticals from GALEX to WISE
• Spitzer's View of the Candidate Cluster and Protocluster Catalog (CCPC)
• The Galaxy Population of Abell 1367: The Stellar Mass-Metallicity Relation
• Three candidate clusters around high redshift radio-loud sources: MG1 J04426+0202, 3C 068.2, MS 1426.9+1052
• Comparative studies of Population Synthesis Models in the frame work of modified Strömgren filters