Assessing the Performance of Recent Density Functionals for Bulk Solids

Abstract

We assess the performance of recent density functionals for the exchange-correlation energy of a nonmolecular solid, by applying accurate calculations with the GAUSSIAN, BAND, and VASP codes to a test set of 24 solid metals and non-metals. The functionals tested are the modified Perdew-Burke-Ernzerhof generalized gradient approximation (PBEsol GGA), the second-order GGA (SOGGA), and the Armiento-Mattsson 2005 (AM05) GGA. For completeness, we also test more-standard functionals: the local density approximation, the original PBE GGA, and the Tao-Perdew-Staroverov-Scuseria (TPSS) meta-GGA. We find that the recent density functionals for solids reach a high accuracy for bulk properties (lattice constant and bulk modulus). For the cohesive energy, PBE is better than PBEsol overall, as expected, but PBEsol is actually better for the alkali metals and alkali halides. For fair comparison of calculated and experimental results, we consider the zero-point phonon and finite-temperature effects ignored by many workers. We show how Gaussian basis sets and inaccurate experimental reference data may affect the rating of the quality of the functionals. The results show that PBEsol and AM05 perform somewhat differently from each other for alkali metal, alkaline earth metal and alkali halide crystals (where the maximum value of the reduced density gradient is about 2), but perform very similarly for most of the other solids (where it is often about 1). Our explanation for this is consistent with the importance of exchange-correlation nonlocality in regions of core-valence overlap.

32 pages, single pdf file

References in corpus (6)

• Restoring the density-gradient expansion for exchange in solids and surfaces
• Generalized gradient approximation for solids and their surfaces
• The shortcomings of semi-local and hybrid functionals: what we can learn from surface science studies
• Proving the Perdew-Burke-Ernzerhof density functional designed for metallic bulk and surface systems
• Relevance of the slowly-varying electron gas to atoms, molecules, and solids
• Collapse of the Electron Gas to Two Dimensions in Density Functional Theory

Cited by in corpus (141)

• Van der Waals density functionals applied to solids
• A Performance and Cost Assessment of Machine Learning Interatomic Potentials
• The Origin of Ferroelectricity in Hf${}_x$ Zr${}_{1-x}$ O${}_2$: A Computational Investigation and a Surface Energy Model
• An exchange functional that tests the robustness of the plasmon description of the van der Waals density functional
• Error estimates for solid-state density-functional theory predictions: an overview by means of the ground-state elemental crystals
• Surface energies, work functions, and surface relaxations of low index metallic surfaces from first-principles
• PyProcar: A Python library for electronic structure pre/post-processing
• Rungs 1 to 4 of DFT Jacob's ladder: extensive test on the lattice constant, bulk modulus, and cohesive energy of solids
• Vibrational and optical properties of MoS${}_2$: from monolayer to bulk
• Solute-Vacancy Clustering in Aluminum
• Accelerating first-principles estimation of thermal conductivity by machine-learning interatomic potentials: A MTP/ShengBTE solution
• Dynamical Multiferroicity
• Are we van der Waals ready?
• Orbital magnetic moments of phonons
• Epitaxial strain effects in the spinel ferrites CoFe2O4 and NiFe2O4 from first principles
• Accurate semilocal density functional for condensed matter physics and quantum chemistry
• Active learning of reactive Bayesian force fields: Application to heterogeneous hydrogen-platinum catalysis dynamics
• Next-generation non-local van der Waals density functional
• Elastic properties of bulk and low-dimensional materials using Van der Waals density functional
• Ultrafast Structure Switching through Nonlinear Phononics
• Giant effective magnetic fields from optically driven chiral phonons in 4$f$ paramagnets
• A brief compendium of time-dependent density-functional theory
• Stacking Domain Wall Magnons in Twisted van der Waals Magnets
• Stabilization of competing ferroelectric phases of HfO${}_2$ under epitaxial strain
• Sum-frequency ionic Raman scattering
• Phono-magnetic analogs to opto-magnetic effects
• Materials design of dynamically stable $d^9$ layered nickelates
• Exciton g-factors in monolayer and bilayer WSe${}_2$ from experiment and theory
• On the accuracy of commonly used density functional approximations in determining the elastic constants of insulators and semiconductors
• The magnetic structure of bixbyite a-Mn2O3: a combined density functional theory DFT+U and neutron diffraction study
• Modeling the iron oxides and oxyhydroxides for the prediction of environmentally sensitive phase transformations
• Van der Waals density-functional theory study for bulk solids with BCC, FCC, and diamond structures
• Equivariant graph neural networks for fast electron density estimation of molecules, liquids, and solids
• Trilinear coupling driven ferroelectricity in HfO${}_2$
• Meta-GGA exchange-correlation functional with a balanced treatment of nonlocality
• High thermal conductivity in semiconducting Janus and non-Janus diamanes
• T-square resistivity without Umklapp scattering in dilute metallic Bi${}_2$O${}_2$Se
• Semiclassical atom theory applied to solid-state physics
• Impact of lattice dynamics on the phase stability of metamagnetic FeRh: Bulk and thin films
• Creating superconductivity in WB2 through pressure-induced metastable planar defects
• Surface Energetics of Alkaline-Earth Metal Oxides: Trends in Stability and Adsorption of Small Molecules
• First-principles quantitative prediction of the lattice thermal conductivity in random semiconductor alloys: the role of force-constant disorder
• Assessing the performance of the recent non-empirical semilocal density functionals on describing the lattice constants, bulk moduli and cohesive energies of alkali, alkaline-earth, and transition metals
• The quantum paraelectric phase of SrTiO${}_3$ from first principles
• Origin of relaxor behavior in barium-titanate based lead-free perovskites
• Vibrational Frequencies of Cerium Oxide-Bound CO: A Challenge for Conventional DFT Methods
• A dynamical magnetic field accompanying the motion of ferroelectric domain walls
• Systematic investigation of a family of gradient-dependent functionals for solids
• Cohesive properties of noble metals by van der Waals-corrected Density Functional Theory
• Assessment of a nonempirical semilocal density functional on solids and surfaces
• Aziridinium lead iodide: a stable, low bandgap hybrid halide perovskite for photovoltaics
• Testing the broad applicability of the PBEint GGA functional and its one-parameter hybrid form
• Improving the performance of Tao-Mo non-empirical density functional with broader applicability in quantum chemistry and material sciences
• Tunable vertical ferroelectricity and domain walls by interlayer sliding in $\beta$-ZrI${}_2$
• Hierarchical symbolic regression for identifying key physical parameters correlated with bulk properties of perovskites
• Assessing exchange-correlation functional performance for structure and property predictions of oxyfluoride compounds from first principles
• Oxidation of GaN: An ab initio thermodynamic approach
• Assessing exchange-correlation functional performance in the chalcogenide lacunar spinels GaM${}_4$Q${}_8$ (M = Mo, V, Nb, Ta; Q = S, Se)
• Ab initio study of the half-metallic full-Heusler compounds Co${}_2$ZAl [Z = Sc, Ti, V, Cr, Mn, Fe]; the role of electronic correlations
• Crystal structure optimisation using an auxiliary equation of state
• Thermoelectric transport trends in group 4 half-Heusler alloys
• Chemical bonding and Born charge in 1T-HfS${}_2$
• Multiple magnetism controlled topological states in EuAgAs
• Highly confined phonon polaritons in monolayers of oxide perovskites
• Flexibility of the quasi-non-uniform exchange-correlation approximation
• Origin and evolution of ferroelectricity in the layered rare-earth-titanate, $R_2$Ti${}_2$O${}_7$, Lichtenberg phases
• Application of screened hybrid functionals to the bulk transition metals Rh, Pd, and Pt
• Site-Specific Structure at Multiple Length Scales in Kagome Quantum Spin Liquid Candidates
• Highly Accurate Local Pseudopotentials of Li, Na, and Mg for Orbital Free Density Functional Theory
• Test set for materials science and engineering with user-friendly graphic tools for error analysis: Systematic benchmark of the numerical and intrinsic errors in state-of-the-art electronic-structure approximations
• Signature of lattice dynamics in twisted 2D homo/hetero-bilayers
• Ab initio study of oxygen segregation in silicon grain boundaries: the role of strain and vacancies
• Finding a junction partner for candidate solar cell absorbers enargite and bournonite from electronic band and lattice matching
• Automatic diffusion path exploration for multivalent battery cathodes using geometrical descriptors
• Effect of doping on SGS and weak half-metallic properties of inverse Heusler Alloys
• Semilocal exchange hole with an application to range-separation density functional
• Extent of Fock-exchange mixing for a hybrid van der Waals density functional?
• Graphenylene nanoribbons: electronic, optical and thermoelectric properties from first-principles calculations
• Fast and Accurate Prediction of Material Properties with Three-Body Tight-Binding Model for the Periodic Table
• Quasi-non-local gradient-level exchange-correlation approximation for metals and alloys
• Molecular Mott state in the deficient spinel GaV${}_4$S${}_8$
• Elastic constants of the II-IV nitride semiconductors MgSiN${}_2$, MgGeN${}_2$ and MgSnN${}_2$
• Multiple lattice instabilities and complex ground state in Cs${}_2$AgBiBr${}_6$
• Optoelectronic properties of the CuI, AgI and Janus Cu2BrI, and Ag2BrI monolayers by many-body perturbation theory
• Classical and Machine Learning Interatomic Potentials for BCC Vanadium
• Semiconducting SiGeSn High-Entropy Alloy: A Density Functional Theory Study
• MGNN: Moment Graph Neural Network for Universal Molecular Potentials
• Nonreciprocal directional dichroism at telecom wavelengths
• Magnetic phase transitions and spin density distribution in the molecular multiferroic GaV${}_4$S${}_8$ system
• Molecule-surface interaction from van der Waals-corrected semilocal density functionals: the example of thiophene on transition-metal surfaces
• A first-principles study of structural and elastic properties of bulk SrRuO${}_3$
• Zero-point lattice expansion and band gap renormalization: Grüneisen approach versus free energy minimization
• Adsorption geometry and the interface states: The relaxed and compressed phases of NTCDA/Ag(111)
• Computational study of antiferromagnetic and mixed-valent diamagnetic phase of AgF2: crystal, electronic and phonon structure and p-T phase diagram
• Finite-size effects on the ferroelectricity in rhombohedral HfO${}_2$
• Improved proton-transfer barriers with van der Waals density functionals: Role of repulsive non-local correlation
• Charging/discharging mechanism in Mg3Bi2 anode for Mg-ion batteries; The role of the spin-orbit coupling
• On the origin of supertetragonality in BaTiO${}_3$
• Suppression of material transfer at contacting surfaces: The effect of adsorbates on Al/TiN and Cu/diamond interfaces from first-principles calculations
• Testing Predictions from Density Functional Theory at Finite Temperatures: ${\beta }_2$-Like Ground States in Co-Pt
• Shallow impurity band in ZrNiSn
• Structure, elastic and dynamical properties of KN${}_3$ and RbN${}_3$: A van der Waals density functional study
• The Tin Pest Problem as a Test of Density Functionals Using High-Throughput Calculations
• The anti-symmetric and anisotropic symmetric exchange interactions between electric dipoles in hafnia
• AFLOW-QHA3P: Robust and automated method to compute thermodynamic properties of solids
• Lattice dynamics of KAgF3 perovskite, unique 1D antiferromagnet
• Formation of two-dimensional electron and hole gases at the interface of half-Heusler semiconductors
• Uncertainty quantification in first-principles predictions of phonon properties and lattice thermal conductivity
• Local atomic arrangement in LaCuAl3 and LaAuAl3 by NMR and density functional theory
• Kapitza stabilization of quantum critical order
• Lattice constants and magnetism of L10-ordered FePt under high pressure
• On the crystalline structure of orthorhombic SrRuO${}_3$: A benchmark study of DFT functionals
• Consistency between the Green-Kubo formula and Lorentz model for predicting the infrared dielectric function of polar materials
• Landau theory description of autferroicity
• Two-dimensional multiferroic NbPc COF with strong magnetoelectric coupling and room-temperature ferroelectricity
• Hydrogen trapping at surface and subsurface vacancies of low-index surfaces of Pd
• Crystal structure, lattice dynamics and superexchange in MAgF3 1D antiferromagnets (M = K, Rb, Cs) and Rb3Ag2F7 Ruddlesden-Popper phase
• Modeling Chemical Exfoliation of Non-van der Waals Chromium Sulfides by Machine Learning Interatomic Potentials and Monte Carlo Simulations
• On the thermal expansion in MgSiN${}_2$
• Anomalous Dispersion of LO Phonons in Oxygen-Doped La${}_{2-x}$Sr${}_x$CuO${}_{4+\delta }$
• Melting behavior of CaO at high temperature and pressure: a molecular dynamics study
• Ab initio phase diagram of PbSe crystals calculated with the Random Phase Approximation
• Effect of Dynamic Surface Polarization on the Oxidative Stability of Solvents in Nonaqueous Li-O${}_2$ Batteries
• Role of octahedral tilting induced acoustic softening on limiting thermal transport in SrSnO3
• Topological Textures in Zr-Substituted Barium Titanate
• First-principles based study of magnetic states and high-pressure enthalpy landscape of manganese sulfide polymorphs
• Anharmonic effects on the reflectivity of CaS and MgS: A first-principles based study
• Defect chemistry of Eu dopants in NaI scintillators studied by atomically resolved force microscopy
• Temperature-dependent thermodynamic properties of CrNbO4 and CrTaO4 by first-principles calculations
• The role of ionic sizes in inducing the cubic to tetragonal distortion in AV${}_2$O${}_4$ and ACr${}_2$O${}_4$ (A=Zn, Mg and Cd) compounds
• Structural phase transitions and magnetic superexchange in MIAgIIF3 perovskites at high pressure
• Realistic indirect spin-interactions between magnetic impurities on a metallic Pb(110) surface
• Atomic scale structure and dynamical properties of (TeO${}_2$)${}_{1-x}$-(Na${}_2$O)${}_x$ glasses through first-principles modeling and XRD measurements
• Functional relations for the density functional exchange and correlation functionals connecting functionals at three densities
• Theory-Guided Discovery of Pressure-Induced Transitions in Fast-Ion Conductor BaSnF4
• II-VI Organic-Inorganic Hybrid Nanostructures with Greatly Enhanced Optoelectronic Properties, Perfectly Ordered Structures, and Over 15-Year Shelf Stability
• A Denser Hydrogen Inferred from First-Principles Simulations Challenges Jupiter's Interior Models
• Chemical control of polymorphism and ferroelectricity in PbTiO3 and SrTiO3 monolayers and bilayers
• Revisiting the epitaxial Si${}_3$N${}_4$ crystalline cap on AlGaN/GaN via evolutionary structure search
• A weak topological insulator state in quasi-one-dimensional superconductor TaSe${}_3$
• Finite-temperature bulk moduli from an EOS-based Grüneisen function