The shortcomings of semi-local and hybrid functionals: what we can learn from surface science studies

Abstract

A study of the adsorption of CO on late 4d and $5d$ transition metal (111) surfaces (Ru, Rh, Pd, Ag, Os, Ir, and Pt) considering atop and hollow site adsorption is presented. The applied functionals include the gradient corrected PBE and BLYP functional, and the corresponding hybrid Hartree-Fock density functionals HSE and B3LYP. We find that PBE based hybrid functionals (specifically HSE) yield, with the exception of Pt, the correct site order on all considered metals, but they also considerably overestimate the adsorption energies compared to experiment. On the other hand, the semi-local BLYP functional and the corresponding hybrid functional B3LYP yield very satisfactory adsorption energies and the correct adsorption site for all surfaces. We are thus faced with a Procrustean problem: the B3LYP and BLYP functionals seem to be the overall best choice for describing adsorption on metal surfaces, but they simultaneously fail to account well for the properties of the metal, vastly overestimating the equilibrium volume and underestimating the atomization energies. Setting out from these observations, general conclusions are drawn on the relative merits and drawbacks of various semi-local and hybrid functionals. The discussion includes a revised version of the PBE functional specifically optimized for bulk properties and surface energies (PBEsol), a revised version of the PBE functional specifically optimized to predict accurate adsorption energies (rPBE), as well as the aforementioned BLYP functional. We conclude that no semi-local functional is capable to describe all aspects properly, and including non-local exchange also only improves some, but worsens other properties.

12 pages, 6 figures; to be published in New Journal of Physics

References in corpus (3)

• Restoring the density-gradient expansion for exchange in solids and surfaces
• Generalized gradient approximation for solids and their surfaces
• CO adsorption on metal surfaces: a hybrid functional study with plane wave basis set

Cited by in corpus (34)

• Assessing the Performance of Recent Density Functionals for Bulk Solids
• Surface energies, work functions, and surface relaxations of low index metallic surfaces from first-principles
• Unravelling CO adsorption on model single-atom catalysts
• Quantum Hydrogen-Bond Symmetrization and High-Temperature Superconductivity in Hydrogen Sulfide
• Properties of real metallic surfaces: Effects of density functional semilocality and van der Waals nonlocality
• Screened hybrid functional applied to 3d^0-->3d^8 transition-metal perovskites LaMO3 (M=Sc-Cu): influence of the exchange mixing parameter on the structural, electronic and magnetic properties
• Spin-phonon coupling effects in transition-metal perovskites:a DFT+$U$ and hybrid-functional study
• Hybrid functional study of proper and improper multiferroics
• Hybrid-functional calculations with plane-wave basis sets: The effect of the singularity correction on total energies, energy eigenvalues, and defect energy levels
• Unraveling the Jahn-Teller effect in Mn doped GaN using the Heyd-Scuseria-Ernzerhof hybrid functional
• Re-thinking CO adsorption on transition-metal surfaces: Density-driven error?
• Comparative study of hybrid functionals applied to structural and electronic properties of semiconductors and insulators
• Signatures of nonadiabatic O2 dissociation at Al(111): First-principles fewest-switches study
• Spin Manipulation by Creation of Single-Molecule Radical Cations
• Interface dipoles of organic molecules on Ag(111) in hybrid density-functional theory
• Assessing computationally efficient isomerization dynamics: Delta-SCF density-functional theory study of azobenzene molecular switching
• A comparative study of CO adsorption on flat, stepped and kinked Au surfaces using density functional theory
• Stabilizing a Molecular Switch at Solid Surfaces: A Density-Functional Theory Study of Azobenzene at Cu(111), Ag(111), and Au(111)
• Accurate Hartree-Fock energy of extended systems using large Gaussian basis sets
• Combining Machine Learning and Many-Body Calculations: Coverage-Dependent Adsorption of CO on Rh(111)
• Excited-state potential-energy surfaces of metal-adsorbed organic molecules from Linear Expansion Δ-Self-Consistent Field Density-Functional Theory (ΔSCF-DFT)
• Structure and morphology of hydroxylated nickel oxide (111) surfaces
• Adsorption energies of benzene on close packed transition metal surfaces using the random phase approximation
• Gold and Methane: A Noble Combination for Delicate Oxidation
• KSSOLV 2.0: An efficient MATLAB toolbox for solving the Kohn-Sham equations with plane-wave basis set
• Accurate non-empirical range-separated hybrid van der Waals density functional for complex molecular problems, solids, and surfaces
• Local correlation method for metals: benchmarks for surface and adsorption energies
• Fast real-time time-dependent hybrid functional calculations with the parallel transport gauge and the adaptively compressed exchange formulation
• vdW-DF-ahcx: a range-separated van der Waals density functional hybrid
• Data-driven analysis of the electronic-structure factors controlling the work functions of perovskite oxides
• Mechanism of spin ordering in Fe${}_3$O${}_4$ nanoparticles by surface coating with organic acids
• Regularized Perturbation Theory for Ab initio Solids
• Vibrational Energy Dissipation in Non-Contact Single-Molecule Junctions Governed by Local Geometry and Electronic Structure
• Coexistence of Rashba and Dirac dispersions on the surface of centrosymmetric topological insulator decorated with transition metals