LoCuSS: Comparison of Observed X-ray and Lensing Galaxy Cluster Scaling Relations with Simulations
arXiv:0802.0770 · doi:10.1051/0004-6361:20079103
Abstract
The Local Cluster Substructure Survey (LoCuSS, Smith et al.) is a systematic multi-wavelength survey of >100 X-ray luminous galaxy clusters (0.14<z<0.3) selected from the ROSAT all sky survey. We used data on 37 LoCuSS clusters from the XMM-Newton archive to investigate the global scaling relations of galaxy clusters. The scaling relations based solely on the X-ray data obey empirical self-similarity and reveal no additional evolution beyond the LSS growth. Weak lensing mass measurements are also available in the literature for 19 of the clusters with XMM-Newton data. The average of the weak lensing mass to X-ray based mass ratio is 1.09+/-8, setting the limit of the non-thermal pressure support to 9+/-8%. The mean of the weak lensing mass to X-ray based mass ratio of these clusters is ~1 with 31-51% scatter. The scatter in the mass--observable relations (M-Y_X, M-M_{gas} and M-T) is smaller using X-ray based masses than using weak lensing masses by a factor of 2. Using the scaled radius defined by the Y_X profile, we obtain lower scatter in the weak lensing mass based mass--observable relations. The normalization of the M-Y_X relation (also M-M_{gas} and M-T relations) using X-ray (weak lensing) mass estimates is lower than the one from simulations by up to 20% at ~3 sigma (~2 sigma) significance. Despite the large scatter in the X-ray to lensing comparison, the agreement between these two completely independent observational methods is an important step towards controlling astrophysical and measurement systematics in cosmological scaling relations.
arXiv comment56 pages, 32 figure, 2008A&A...482..451Z, typos corrected in Table A.1
References in corpus (94)
- A Universal Density Profile from Hierarchical Clustering
- Wilkinson Microwave Anisotropy Probe (WMAP) Three Year Results: Implications for Cosmology
- Statistical Properties of X-ray Clusters: Analytic and Numerical Comparisons
- Chandra sample of nearby relaxed galaxy clusters: mass, gas fraction, and mass-temperature relation
- The Inner Structure of LambdaCDM Halos III: Universality and Asymptotic Slopes
- The Mass Function of an X-Ray Flux-Limited Sample of Galaxy Clusters
- Constraints on dark energy from Chandra observations of the largest relaxed galaxy clusters
- Tracing cosmic evolution with clusters of galaxies
- Effects of Galaxy Formation on Thermodynamics of the Intracluster Medium
- The ROSAT Brightest Cluster Sample (BCS) - I. The compilation of the sample and the cluster log N-log S distribution
- The ROSAT-ESO Flux Limited X-ray (REFLEX) Galaxy Cluster Survey. V. The cluster catalogue
- Mass Estimates of X-Ray Clusters
- Properties of the Intracluster Medium in an Ensemble of Nearby Galaxy Clusters
- The Lx-T Relation and Temperature Function for Nearby Clusters Revisited
- Chandra temperature profiles for a sample of nearby relaxed galaxy clusters
- Testing X-ray Measurements of Galaxy Clusters with Cosmological Simulations
- A New Robust Low-Scatter X-ray Mass Indicator for Clusters of Galaxies
- The Imprint of Galaxy Formation on X-ray Clusters
- The Lx-T Relation and Intracluster Gas Fractions of X-ray Clusters
- The Temperature Structure of 30 Nearby Clusters Observed with ASCA. Similarity of Temperature Profiles
- The Evolution of X-ray Clusters and the Entropy of the Intra Cluster Medium
- The structural and scaling properties of nearby galaxy clusters - II. The M-T relation
- X-ray properties of galaxy clusters and groups from a cosmological hydrodynamical simulation
- Dark matter maps reveal cosmic scaffolding
- The ROSAT Brightest Cluster Sample (BCS) - IV. The extended sample
- Details of the mass--temperature relation for clusters of galaxies
- Systematics in the X-ray Cluster Mass Estimators
- The impact of mergers on relaxed X-ray clusters - I. Dynamical evolution and emergent transient structures
- Combining Strong and Weak Gravitational Lensing in Abell 1689
- The Birmingham-CfA cluster scaling project - III: entropy and similarity in galaxy systems
- Cosmological constraints from the X-ray gas mass fraction in relaxed lensing clusters observed with Chandra
- The X-ray virial relations for relaxed lensing clusters observed with Chandra
- A dynamical model for the distribution of dark matter and gas in galaxy clusters
- Statistics of X-ray observables for the cooling-core and non-cooling core galaxy clusters
- The Representative XMM-Newton Cluster Structure Survey (REXCESS) of an X-ray Luminosity Selected Galaxy Cluster Sample
- The Surprisingly Steep Mass Profile of Abell 1689, from a Lensing Analysis of Subaru Images
- Investigating AGN Heating in a Sample of Nearby Clusters
- The entropy and energy of intergalactic gas in galaxy clusters
- Resolving the discrepancy between X-ray and gravitational lensing mass measurements for clusters of galaxies
- A Wide Field Hubble Space Telescope Study of the Cluster Cl0024+1654 at z=0.4 II: The Cluster Mass Distribution
- Temperature profiles of a representative sample of nearby X-ray galaxy clusters
- Effects of cooling and star formation on the baryon fractions in clusters
- How well can we determine cluster mass profiles from weak lensing?
- A New Measurement of the X-ray Temperature Function of Clusters of Galaxies
- Calibration of the galaxy cluster M_500-Y_X relation with XMM-Newton
- Deep inside the core of Abell 1795: the Chandra view
- Comparison of weak lensing masses and X-ray properties of galaxy clusters
- Probing the Dark Matter and Gas Fraction in Relaxed Galaxy Groups with X-ray observations from Chandra and XMM
- Outer Regions of the Cluster Gaseous Atmospheres
- A New Shear Estimator for Weak Lensing Observations
- The REFLEX Galaxy Cluster Survey VII: Omega_m and sigma_8 from cluster abundance and large-scale clustering
- First Results On Shear-Selected Clusters From the Deep Lens Survey: Optical Imaging, Spectroscopy, and X-ray Followup
- The X-Ray Luminosity--Mass Relation for Local Clusters of Galaxies
- Gravitational Lensing in Clusters of Galaxies: New Clues Regarding the Dynamics of Intracluster Gas
- A statistically-selected Chandra sample of 20 galaxy clusters -- I. Temperature and cooling time profiles
- The effect of radiative cooling on the X-ray properties of galaxy clusters
- Parametric Strong Gravitational Lensing Analysis of Abell 1689
- The RASS-SDSS Galaxy Cluster Survey. III. Scaling relations of galaxy clusters
- Temperature and entropy profiles of nearby cooling flow clusters observed with XMM-Newton
- The Evolution of Structure in X-ray Clusters of Galaxies
- Evolution of the cluster X-ray scaling relations since z>0.4
- Constraining the cosmological parameters with the gas mass fraction in local and z>0.7 Galaxy Clusters
- X-ray Temperatures for the EMSS High Redshift Cluster Sample: Constraints on Cosmology and the Dark Energy Equation of State
- The Cluster Mass Function from Weak Gravitational Lensing
- Mismatch between X-ray and emission-weighted temperatures in galaxy clusters: cosmological implications
- Structure and scaling of the entropy in nearby galaxy clusters
- X-ray properties in massive galaxy clusters: XMM-Newton observations of the REFLEX-DXL sample
- Effects of asphericity and substructure on the determination of cluster mass with weak gravitational lensing
- A Subaru Weak Lensing Survey I: Cluster Candidates and Spectroscopic Verification
- A Lensing Survey of X-ray Luminous Galaxy Clusters at Redshift z ~ 0.2: II: CFH12k Weak Lensing Analysis and Global Correlations
- Scaling relations and mass calibration of the X-ray luminous galaxy clusters at z~0.2: XMM-Newton observations
- Cosmological constraints from evolution of cluster baryon mass function at z~0.5
- XMM-Newton Observations of Evolution of Cluster X-Ray Scaling Relations at z=0.4-0.7
- Chandra X-ray analysis of the massive high-redshift galaxy clusters ClJ1113.1-2615 and ClJ0152.7-1357
- A CFH12k lensing survey of X-ray luminous galaxy clusters - I: Weak lensing methodology
- Wide field weak lensing observations of A1835 and A2204
- The Formation Histories of Galaxy Clusters
- XMM-Newton study of the two-dimensional structure of the REFLEX-DXL galaxy clusters
- The X-ray surface brightness profiles of hot galaxy clusters up to z~0.8: evidence for self-similarity and constraints on Omega_0
- Temperature gradients in XMM-Newton observed REFLEX-DXL galaxy clusters at z~0.3
- The Virial Mass Function of Nearby SDSS Galaxy Clusters
- A combined analysis of cluster mass estimates from strong lensing, X-ray measurement and the universal density profile
- XMM-Newton observation of Abell 1835 : temperature, mass and gas mass fraction profiles
- Calibration of the Mass-Temperature Relation for Clusters of Galaxies Using Weak Gravitational Lensing
- XMM-Newton study of the lensing cluster of galaxies CL0024+17
- Measuring Sigma8 with Cluster Lensing : Biases from Unrelaxed Clusters
- Galaxies Under the Cosmic Microscope: Resolved Spectroscopy and New Constraints on the z=1 Tully-Fisher relation
- Self-similarity of clusters of galaxies and the L_X-T relation
- Tracing gas motions in the Centaurus Cluster
- The entropy distribution in clusters: evidence of feedback?
- Further evidence for a merger in Abell 2218 from an XMM-Newton observation
- Distribution of dark and baryonic matter in clusters of galaxies
- The scalar perturbation spectral index n_s: WMAP sensitivity to unresolved point sources
- Exploring the Structure of Galaxy Clusters: XMM-Newton observations of the REFLEX-DXL clusters at z~0.3
Cited by in corpus (148)
- Weak Gravitational Lensing
- Toward a halo mass function for precision cosmology: the limits of universality
- Chandra Cluster Cosmology Project III: Cosmological Parameter Constraints
- The Large Scale Bias of Dark Matter Halos: Numerical Calibration and Model Tests
- Chandra Cluster Cosmology Project II: Samples and X-ray Data Reduction
- Gravitational Lensing
- Residual Gas Motions in the Intracluster Medium and Bias in Hydrostatic Measurements of Mass Profiles of Clusters
- Gas entropy in a representative sample of nearby X-ray galaxy clusters (REXCESS): relationship to gas mass fraction
- On the Accuracy of Weak Lensing Cluster Mass Reconstructions
- Weighing the Giants IV: Cosmology and Neutrino Mass
- Weighing simulated galaxy clusters using lensing and X-ray
- A Weak Lensing Study of X-ray Groups in the COSMOS survey: Form and Evolution of the Mass-Luminosity Relation
- The Observed Growth of Massive Galaxy Clusters II: X-ray Scaling Relations
- Weighing the Giants - III. Methods and Measurements of Accurate Galaxy Cluster Weak-Lensing Masses
- LoCuSS: Subaru Weak Lensing Study of 30 Galaxy Clusters
- Scaling Properties of a Complete X-ray Selected Galaxy Group Sample
- Cosmological Constraints from Sunyaev-Zel'dovich-Selected Clusters with X-ray Observations in the First 178 Square Degrees of the South Pole Telescope Survey
- Joint Analysis of Cluster Observations: II. Chandra/XMM-Newton X-ray and Weak Lensing Scaling Relations for a Sample of 50 Rich Clusters of Galaxies
- Lensing and X-ray mass estimates of clusters (SIMULATION)
- Total mass biases in X-ray galaxy clusters
- Robust Optical Richness Estimation with Reduced Scatter
- Mass profiles of Galaxy Clusters from X-ray analysis
- X-ray Properties of the First SZE-selected Galaxy Cluster Sample from the South Pole Telescope
- Massive Halos in Millennium Gas Simulations: Multivariate Scaling Relations
- Combining cluster observables and stacked weak lensing to probe dark energy: Self-calibration of systematic uncertainties
- LoCuSS: A Comparison of Cluster Mass Measurements from XMM-Newton and Subaru - Testing Deviation from Hydrostatic Equilibrium and Non-Thermal Pressure Support
- Constraining the Scatter in the Mass-Richness Relation of maxBCG Clusters With Weak Lensing and X-ray Data
- LoCuSS: First Results from Strong-lensing Analysis of 20 Massive Galaxy Clusters at z~0.2
- The X-ray Cluster Normalization of the Matter Power Spectrum
- XMM-Newton Observation of the Northwest Radio Relic Region in Abell 3667
- Planck Early Results. X. Statistical analysis of Sunyaev-Zeldovich scaling relations for X-ray galaxy clusters
- Calibration of the optical mass proxy for clusters of galaxies and an update of the WHL12 cluster catalog
- Weighing the Giants V: Galaxy Cluster Scaling Relations
- LoCuSS: the connection between brightest cluster galaxy activity, gas cooling and dynamical disturbance of X-ray cluster cores
- Sunyaev-Zel'dovich Cluster Profiles Measured with the South Pole Telescope
- Suzaku Observation of Abell 1689: Anisotropic Temperature and Entropy Distributions Associated with the Large-Scale Structure
- Outskirts of Galaxy Clusters
- HIFLUGCS: Galaxy cluster scaling relations between X-ray luminosity, gas mass, cluster radius, and velocity dispersion
- Scaling relations for galaxy clusters: properties and evolution
- Testing the Low-Mass End of X-Ray Scaling Relations with a Sample of Chandra Galaxy Groups
- CLASH: Mass Distribution in and around MACS J1206.2-0847 from a Full Cluster Lensing Analysis
- Observational constraints on the redshift evolution of X-ray scaling relations of galaxy clusters out to z ~ 1.5
- LoCuSS: Calibrating Mass-Observable Scaling Relations for Cluster Cosmology with Subaru Weak Lensing Observations
- Suzaku measurement of Abell 2204's intracluster gas temperature profile out to 1800 kpc
- LoCuSS: The mid-infrared Butcher-Oemler effect
- A New Look at Massive Clusters: weak lensing constraints on the triaxial dark matter halos of Abell 1689, Abell 1835, & Abell 2204
- LoCuSS: The Sunyaev-Zel'dovich Effect and Weak Lensing Mass Scaling Relation
- Using Radio Halos and Minihalos to Measure the Distributions of Magnetic Fields and Cosmic-Rays in Galaxy Clusters
- Cosmology and Astrophysics from Relaxed Galaxy Clusters III: Thermodynamic Profiles and Scaling Relations
- The Atacama Cosmology Telescope (ACT): Beam Profiles and First SZ Cluster Maps
- LoCuSS: Connecting the Dominance and Shape of Brightest Cluster Galaxies with the Assembly History of Massive Clusters
- Temperature Structure of the Intra-Cluster Medium from SPH and AMR simulations
- Thermodynamic perturbations in the X-ray halo of 33 clusters of galaxies observed with Chandra ACIS
- HICOSMO - Cosmology with a complete sample of galaxy clusters: I. Data analysis, sample selection and luminosity-mass scaling-relation
- On the Self-Similar Appearance of Galaxy Clusters in X-rays
- X-ray Substructure Studies of Four Galaxy Clusters using XMM-Newton Data
- LoCuSS: A Comparison of Sunyaev-Zel'dovich Effect and Gravitational Lensing Measurements of Galaxy Clusters
- Keck spectroscopic survey of strongly lensed galaxies in Abell 1703: further evidence for a relaxed, unimodal cluster
- HICOSMO - Cosmology with a complete sample of galaxy clusters: II. Cosmological results
- XMM-Newton/SDSS: star formation efficiency in galaxy clusters and constraints on the matter density parameter
- The eROSITA Final Equatorial-Depth Survey (eFEDS): X-ray Properties and Scaling Relations of Galaxy Clusters and Groups
- Subaru weak-lensing study of A2163: bimodal mass structure
- Precision cluster mass determination from weak lensing
- The 400d Galaxy Cluster Survey weak lensing programme: III: Evidence for consistent WL and X-ray masses at
- Weak-Lensing Mass Measurements of Five Galaxy Clusters in the South Pole Telescope Survey Using Magellan/Megacam
- Dynamical state for 964 galaxy clusters from Chandra X-ray images
- A Relationship Between Halo Mass, Cooling, AGN Heating, and the Coevolution of Massive Black Holes
- LoCuSS: Luminous infrared galaxies in the merging cluster Abell 1758 at z=0.28
- Studying the properties of galaxy cluster morphology estimators
- Non-parametric modeling of the intra-cluster gas using APEX-SZ bolometer imaging data
- The MUSIC of Galaxy Clusters II: X-ray global properties and scaling relations
- The impact of numerical viscosity in SPH simulations of galaxy clusters
- Galaxy population properties of the massive X-ray luminous galaxy cluster XDCP J0044.0-2033 at z=1.58: red-sequence formation, massive galaxy assembly, and central star formation activity
- Sensitivity of galaxy cluster dark energy constraints to halo modeling uncertainties
- Star-formation efficiency and metal enrichment of the intracluster medium in local massive clusters of galaxies
- Dynamical state of galaxy clusters evaluated from X-ray images
- Galaxy cluster mass estimation with deep learning and hydrodynamical simulations
- Cosmological parameters constraints from galaxy cluster mass function measurements in combination with other cosmological data
- Validity of Hydrostatic Equilibrium in Galaxy Clusters from Cosmological Hydrodynamical Simulations
- Chandra Measurements of a Complete Sample of X-ray Luminous Galaxy Clusters: The Luminosity-Mass Relation
- Universal Profiles of the Intracluster Medium from Suzaku X-Ray and Subaru Weak Lensing Obesrvations
- Statistics and implications of substructure detected in a representative sample of X-ray clusters
- Resolving the discrepancy between lensing and X-ray mass estimates of the complex galaxy cluster Abell 1689
- A pan-chromatic view of the galaxy cluster XMMU J1230.3+1339 at z=0.975 - Observing the assembly of a massive system
- Galaxy Clusters, a Novel Look at Diffuse Baryons Withstanding Dark Matter Gravity
- The dark matter distribution in z~0.5 clusters of galaxies. I : Determining scaling relations with weak lensing masses
- LoCuSS: A Herschel view of obscured star formation in Abell 1835
- Annealing a Follow-up Program: Improvement of the Dark Energy Figure of Merit for Optical Galaxy Cluster Surveys
- The 400d Galaxy Cluster Survey Weak Lensing Programme: I: MMT/Megacam Analysis of CL0030+2618 at z=0.50
- Implications of the remarkable homogeneity of galaxy groups and clusters
- High significance detection of the tSZ effect relativistic corrections
- Linking a universal gas density profile to the core-excised X-ray luminosity in galaxy clusters up to z ~ 1.1
- Model-independent X-ray mass determinations
- The Atacama Cosmology Telescope: High-Resolution Sunyaev-Zel'dovich Array Observations of ACT SZE-selected Clusters from the Equatorial Strip
- A Gibbs Sampler for Multivariate Linear Regression
- Covariance matrices for galaxy cluster weak lensing: from virial regime to uncorrelated large-scale structure
- The 400d Galaxy Cluster Survey weak lensing programme: II: Weak lensing study of seven clusters with MMT/Megacam
- Possible indication for non-zero neutrino mass and additional neutrino species from cosmological observations
- Detailed SZ study of 19 LoCuSS galaxy clusters: masses and temperatures out to the virial radius
- Gas rotation in galaxy clusters: signatures and detectability in X-rays
- Weak lensing calibration of mass bias in the REFLEX+BCS X-ray galaxy cluster catalogue
- HIFLUGCS: X-ray luminosity -- dynamical mass relation and its implications for mass calibrations with the SPIDERS and 4MOST surveys
- Weak lensing observations of potentially X-ray underluminous galaxy clusters
- What do cluster counts really tell us about the Universe?
- Weak lensing measurements of the APEX-SZ galaxy cluster sample
- Probing Gas Motions in the Intra-Cluster Medium: A Mixture Model Approach
- Probing of the Interactions Between the Hot Plasmas and Galaxies in Clusters from z=0.1 to 0.9
- Supermodel Analysis of Galaxy Clusters
- Comparing different mass estimators for a large subsample of the {\it Planck}-ESZ clusters
- Entropy Flattening, Gas Clumping and Turbulence in Galaxy Clusters
- Probing the evolution of the substructure frequency in galaxy clusters up to z~1
- Hot atmospheres of galaxies, groups, and clusters of galaxies
- Sunyaev-Zel'dovich observations of galaxy clusters out to the virial radius with the Arcminute Microkelvin Imager
- Simulating the LOcal Web (SLOW) II: Properties of local galaxy clusters
- Forming one of the most massive objects in the Universe: The quadruple merger in Abell 1758
- The Scales of Gravitational Lensing
- Pointing to the minimum scatter: the generalized scaling relations for galaxy clusters
- Benchmarks and Explanations for Deep Learning Estimates of X-ray Galaxy Cluster Masses
- Cluster counts III. CDM extensions and the cluster tension
- A parametric physical model for the intracluster medium and its use in joint SZ/X-ray analyses of galaxy clusters
- A good mass proxy for galaxy clusters with XMM-Newton
- Multiwavelength study of X-ray Luminous Clusters in the Hyper Suprime-Cam Subaru Strategic Program S16A field
- Next Generation Virgo Cluster Survey. XXI. The weak lensing masses of the CFHTLS and NGVS RedGOLD galaxy clusters and calibration of the optical richness
- Galaxy cluster scaling relations measured with APEX-SZ
- Evolution of the gas mass fraction in galaxy clusters
- AMI observations of ten CLASH galaxy clusters: SZ and X-ray data used together to determine cluster dynamical states
- Where are the missing baryons in clusters?
- Disentangling Resonant Scattering and Gas Motions in Galaxy Cluster Emission Line Profiles
- Evidence for a merger-revived radio phoenix in MaxBCG J217.95869+13.53470
- The Halo Mass-Temperature Relation for Clusters, Groups, and Galaxies
- Halo Concentrations and the New Baseline X-ray Luminosity-Temperature and Mass Relations of Galaxy Clusters
- Probing Saraswati's heart: evaluating the dynamical state of the massive galaxy cluster A2631 through a comprehensive weak-lensing and dynamical analysis
- Sunyaev-Zel'dovich scaling relations from a simple phenomenological model for galaxy clusters
- Galaxy cluster hydrostatic masses using Tolman-Oppenheimer-Volkoff equation
- X-ray properties of high-richness CAMIRA clusters in the Hyper Suprime-Cam Subaru Strategic Program field
- Probing Cosmology and Galaxy Cluster Structure with the Sunyaev-Zel'dovich Decrement vs. X-ray Temperature Scaling Relation
- Probing cluster dynamics in RXCJ1504.1-0248 via radial and two-dimensional gas and galaxy properties
- SZ observations with AMI of the hottest galaxy clusters detected in the XMM-Newton Cluster Survey
- Galaxy Infall by Interacting with its Environment: a Comprehensive Study of 340 Galaxy Clusters
- Scaling relations of X-ray Luminous Clusters in the Hyper Suprime-Cam Subaru Strategic Program Field
- Imaging results from the legacy GMRT Galaxy Cluster Key Project
- The dependence of cluster galaxy properties on the central entropy of their host cluster
- Deprojected analysis of Abell 1835 observed with Chandra and compared with XMM-Newton
- Density Profile of a Cool Core of Galaxy Clusters
- X-ray emission from RX J1720.1+2638 and Abell 267: a comparison between a fossil and a non-fossil system
- Unbiased Correction Relations for Galaxy Cluster properties Derived from Chandra and XMM-Newton
- XMM-Newton study of six massive, X-ray luminous galaxy clusters systems in the redshift range z = 0.25 to 0.5
- The eROSITA Final Equatorial-Depth Survey (eFEDS): X-ray stacking analysis of Subaru's optically selected clusters spanning low richness regime