The strong and weak holographic principles

Abstract

We review the different proposals which have so far been made for the holographic principle and the related entropy bounds and classify them into the strong, null and weak forms. These are analyzed, with the aim of discovering which may hold at the level of the full quantum theory of gravity. We find that only the weak forms, which constrain the information available to observers on boundaries, are implied by arguments using the generalized second law. The strong forms, which go further and posit a bound on the entropy in spacelike regions bounded by surfaces, are found to suffer from serious problems, which give rise to counterexamples already at the semiclassical level. The null form, proposed by Fischler, Susskind, Bousso and others, in which the bound is on the entropy of certain null surfaces, appears adequate at the level of a bound on the entropy of matter in a single background spacetime, but attempts to include the gravitational degrees of freedom encounter serious difficulties. Only the weak form seems capable of holding in the full quantum theory. The conclusion is that the holographic principle is not a relationship between two independent sets of concepts: bulk theories and measures of geometry vrs boundary theories and measures of information. Instead, it is the assertion that in a fundamental theory the first set of concepts must be completely reduced to the second.

Latex, 53 pages, no figures

References in corpus (4)

• Gauge Theory Correlators from Non-Critical String Theory
• Non-perturbative Lorentzian Quantum Gravity, Causality and Topology Change
• Quantum geometry with intrinsic local causality
• Nonperturbative dynamics for abstract (p,q) string networks

Cited by in corpus (20)

• The holographic principle
• Black Hole Remnants and the Information Loss Paradox
• Black Holes in Loop Quantum Gravity
• Conservative solutions to the black hole information problem
• Do black holes radiate?
• On the energy-momentum tensor for a scalar field on manifolds with boundaries
• The Persistence of the Large Volumes in Black Holes
• Quantum evolution of black hole initial data sets: Foundations
• Black Holes as Quantum Gravity Condensates
• Holography and the scale-invariance of density fluctuations
• Never Judge a Black Hole by Its Area
• Quantum-Corrected Cardy Entropy for Generic 1+1-Dimensional Gravity
• Does brane cosmology have realistic principles?
• Dynamical evaporation of quantum horizons
• A note on entanglement entropy and quantum geometry
• The Fate of Monsters in Anti-de Sitter Spacetime
• Light Sheets and the Covariant Entropy Conjecture
• On the Hydrogen Atom in the Holographic Universe
• Holographic Weyl Entropy Bounds
• Twistors and Holography