Comment on entropy bounds and the generalized second law

Abstract

In a gedanken experiment in which a box initially containing energy $E$ and entropy $S$ is lowered toward a black hole and then dropped in, it was shown by Unruh and Wald that the generalized second law of black hole thermodynamics holds, without the need to assume any bounds on $S$ other than the bound that arises from the fact that entropy at a given energy and volume is bounded by that of unconstrained thermal matter. The original analysis by Unruh and Wald made the approximation that the box was ``thin'', but they later generalized their analysis to thick boxes (in the context of a slightly different process). Nevertheless, Bekenstein has argued that, for a certain class of thick boxes, the buoyancy force of the ``thermal atmosphere'' of the black hole is negligible, and that his previously postulated bound on $S/E$ is necessary for the validity of the generalized second law. In arguing for these conclusions, Bekenstein made some assumptions about the nature of unconstrained thermal matter and the location of the ``floating point'' of the box. We show here that under these assumptions, Bekenstein's bound on $S/E$ follows automatically from the fact that $S$ is bounded by the entropy of unconstrained thermal matter. Thus, a box of matter which violates Bekenstein's bound would violate the assumptions made in his analysis, rather than violate the generalized second law. Indeed, we prove here that no universal entropy bound need be hypothesized in order to ensure the validity of the generalized second law in this process.

12 pages, revtex

References in corpus (1)

• Entropy Bounds and Black Hole Remnants

Cited by in corpus (30)

• The holographic principle
• The Thermodynamics of Black Holes
• Relative entropy and the Bekenstein bound
• Proof of Classical Versions of the Bousso Entropy Bound and of the Generalized Second Law
• The "physical process" version of the first law and the generalized second law for charged and rotating black holes
• Bekenstein bounds in de Sitter and flat space
• Non-Archimedean character of quantum buoyancy and the generalized second law of thermodynamics
• The Quantum Physics of Black Holes: Results from String Theory
• Black hole polarization and new entropy bounds
• Bekenstein bound and uncertainty relations
• Are there hyperentropic objects ?
• Universal Entropy Bound for Rotating Systems
• Perfect mirrors and the self-accelerating box paradox
• Lifetime of unstable hairy black holes
• Entropy localization and extensivity in the semiclassical black hole evaporation
• Bound states and the Bekenstein bound
• Defining Entropy Bounds
• Bekenstein-Hawking entropy in expanding universes from black hole theorems
• The optimal entropy bound and the self-energy of test objects in the vicinity of a black hole
• Entropy Bound of Horizons for Accelerating, Rotating and Charged Plebanski-Demianski Black Hole
• Does the generalized second law require entropy bounds for a charged system?
• Entropy bound for a rotating system from Anti de Sitter black holes
• Extensive Entropy Bounds
• Entropy bounds for charged and rotating systems
• New thought experiment to test the generalized second law of thermodynamics
• Massive gravity solution of Black Holes and Entropy Bounds
• D-bound and Bekenstein bound for McVittie solution surrounded by dark energy cosmological fields
• Categorical Geometry and the Mathematical Foundations of Quantum General Relativity
• D-bound and Bekenstein Bound for the Surrounded Vaidya Black Hole
• Quantum information measures and their applications in quantum field theory