Nebular Abundance Errors

Abstract

The errors inherent to the use of the standard "ionization correction factor" ("i_CF") method of calculating nebular conditions and relative abundances of H, He, N, O, Ne, S, and Ar in emission line nebulae have been investigated under conditions typical for planetary nebulae. The photoionization code CLOUDY was used to construct a series of model nebulae with properties spanning the range typical of PNe. Its radial "profiles" of bright, frequently observed optical emission lines were then summed over a variety of "apertures" to generate sets of emission line measurements. These resulting line ratios were processed using the i_CF method to "derive" nebular conditions and abundances. We find that for lines which are summed over the entire nebula the i_CF-derived abundances differ from the input abundances by less than 5% for He and O up to 25% or more for Ne, S, and Ar. For resolved observations, however, the discrepancies are often much larger and are systematically variable with radius. This effect is especially pronounced in low-ionization zones where nitrogen and oxygen are neutral or once-ionized such as in FLIERs, ansae and ionization fronts. We argue that the reports of stellar-enriched N in the FLIERs of several PNe are probably specious.

22 pages, 4 tables, and 1 figure. Accepted for publication in the Astronomical Journal. Replaced to correct a reference

Cited by in corpus (25)

• Ionization Correction Factors for Planetary Nebulae: I- Using optical spectra
• The Necklace: equatorial and polar outflows from the binary central star of the new planetary nebula IPHASXJ194359.5+170901
• Chemical Abundances of Planetary Nebulae in the Bulge and Disk of M31
• Elemental abundances of Galactic bulge planetary nebulae from optical recombination lines
• New abundances of planetary nebulae in the Galactic Bulge
• Chemical abundances of Seyfert 2 AGNs I. Comparing oxygen abundances from distinct methods using SDSS
• The physical parameters, excitation and chemistry of the rim, jets and knots of the planetary nebula NGC 7009
• On the nitrogen abundance of FLIERs: the outer knots of the planetary nebula NGC 7009
• Morphology and kinematics of Planetary Nebulae II. A Diabolo model for NGC 3132
• The 3-D ionization structure and evolution of NGC 7009 (Saturn Nebula)
• HST Observations of the Wolf-Rayet Nebula NGC 6888
• Large Magellanic Cloud Planetary Nebula Morphology: Probing Stellar Populations and Evolution
• Spatially resolved physical and chemical properties of the planetary nebula NGC 3242
• The structure of Planetary Nebulae: theory vs. practice
• The 3--D ionization structure of NGC 6818: a Planetary Nebula threatened by recombination
• Modelling of aspherical nebulae. I. A quick pseudo-3D photoionization code
• Physical Structure of Planetary Nebulae. II. NGC 7662
• The 3-D shaping of NGC 6741: a massive, fast-evolving Planetary Nebula at the recombination--reionization edge
• Panchromatic HST/WFC3 Imaging Studies of Young, Rapidly Evolving Planetary Nebulae. I. NGC 6302
• The 3-D ionization structure of the planetary nebula NGC6565
• Chemical abundances in Seyfert galaxies -- VIII. Argon abundance estimates
• Morphology and kinematics of Planetary Nebulae. I.A new modeling tool
• Rings and arcs around evolved stars -- III. Physical conditions of the ring-like structures in the planetary nebula IC 4406 revealed by MUSE
• When Shape Matters: correcting the ICFs to derive the chemical abundances of bipolar and elliptical PNe
• Chemical abundances in Seyfert galaxies -- VII. Direct abundance determination of neon based on optical and infrared emission lines