Nonthermal hard X-ray excess in the Coma cluster: resolving the discrepancy between the results of different PDS data analyses

Abstract

The detection of a nonthermal excess in the Coma cluster spectrum by two BeppoSAX observations analyzed with the XAS package (Fusco-Femiano et al.) has been disavowed by an analysis (Rossetti & Molendi) performed with a different software package (SAXDAS) for the extraction of the spectrum. To resolve this discrepancy we reanalyze the PDS data considering the same software used by Rossetti & Molendi. A correct selection of the data and the exclusion of contaminating sources in the background determination show that also the SAXDAS analysis reports a nonthermal excess with respect to the thermal emission at about the same confidence level of that obtained with the XAS package (~4.8sigma). Besides, we report the lack of the systematic errors investigated by Rossetti & Molendi and Nevalainen et al. taking into account the whole sample of the PDS observations off the Galactic plane, as already shown in our data analysis of Abell 2256 (Fusco-Femiano, Landi & Orlandini). All this eliminates any ambiguity and confirms the presence of a hard tail in the spectrum of the Coma cluster.

12 pages, 2 figures. Accepted for publication in ApJ Letters

References in corpus (13)

• Hard X-Ray Radiation in the Coma Cluster Spectrum
• The giant radio halo in Abell 2163
• Confirmation of non-thermal hard X-ray excess in the Coma cluster from two epoch observations
• Hard X-ray emission from the galaxy cluster A2256
• Is there a hard tail in the Coma Cluster X-ray spectrum?
• Results from a Second RXTE Observation of the Coma Cluster
• Non-thermal hard X-ray emission in galaxy clusters observed with the BeppoSAX PDS
• BeppoSAX Spectral Survey of BL Lacs - new spectra and results
• Hard X-ray emission from the galaxy cluster A3667
• Long RXTE Observations of A2163
• Hard X-ray and radio observations of Abell 754
• Analysis and Interpretation of Hard X-ray Emission from the Bullet Cluster (1E0657-56), the Most Distant Cluster of Galaxies Observed by RXTE
• Nonthermal hard X-ray excess in the cluster Abell 2256 from two epoch observations

Cited by in corpus (28)

• Clusters of galaxies : observational properties of the diffuse radio emission
• Cosmic rays in galaxy clusters and their non-thermal emission
• Observations of extended radio emission in clusters
• Simulating cosmic rays in clusters of galaxies - II. A unified scheme for radio halos and relics with predictions of the gamma-ray emission
• Galaxy Clusters in the Swift/BAT era: Hard X-rays in the ICM
• A $\mathcal{M}\gtrsim 3$ shock in `El Gordo' cluster and the origin of the radio relic
• Simulating cosmic rays in clusters of galaxies - III. Non-thermal scaling relations and comparison to observations
• Nonthermal phenomena in clusters of galaxies
• Chandra measurements of non-thermal-like X-ray emission from massive, merging, radio-halo clusters
• Heating and Acceleration of Intracluster Medium Electrons by Turbulence
• The redshift evolution of major merger triggering of luminous AGN: a slight enhancement at z$\sim$2
• Hard X-ray Properties of the Merging Cluster Abell 3667 as Observed with Suzaku
• A Suzaku Search for Non-thermal Emission at Hard X-ray Energies in the Coma Cluster
• Suzaku Observation of the Radio Halo Cluster Abell 2319: Gas Dynamics and Hard X-ray Properties
• A NuSTAR observation of the center of the Coma Cluster
• Galaxy Clusters in the Swift/BAT era II: 10 more Clusters detected above 15 keV
• Nonthermal emission from clusters of galaxies
• N-body + Magnetohydrodynamical Simulations of Merging Clusters of Galaxies: Characteristic Magnetic Field Structures Generated by Bulk Flow Motion
• Particle energy cascade in the Intergalactic Medium
• The Lack of Diffuse, Nonthermal Hard X-ray Emission in the Coma Cluster: The Swift BAT's Eye View
• Suzaku Observations of Iron K-lines from the Intracluster Medium of the Coma Cluster
• Non-thermal emission in the core of Perseus: results from a long XMM-Newton observation
• An analysis of electron distributions in galaxy clusters by means of the flux ratio of iron lines FeXXV and XXVI
• Clusters of galaxies: setting the stage
• Supermodel Analysis of the Hard X-Ray Excess in the Coma Cluster
• Stochastic particle acceleration and the problem of backgroud plasma overheating
• Suzaku Constraints on the Soft and Hard Excess Emissions from Abell 2199
• Suzaku Observation of Abell 1555 and Abell 1558: Searching for Non-thermal Emission from Large Scale Structure Formation