On the Evidence for Clustering in the Arrival Directions of AGASA's Ultrahigh Energy Cosmic Rays
arXiv:astro-ph/0309159 · doi:10.1016/j.astropartphys.2004.01.006
Abstract
Previous analyses of cosmic rays above 40 EeV observed by the AGASA experiment have suggested that their arrival directions may be clustered. However, estimates of the chance probability of this clustering signal vary from 10^{-2} to 10^{-6} and beyond. It is essential that the strength of this evidence be well understood in order to compare it with anisotropy studies in other cosmic ray experiments. We apply two methods for extracting a meaningful significance from this data set: one can scan for the cuts which optimize the clustering signal, using simulations to determine the appropriate statistical penalty for the scan. This analysis finds a chance probability of about 0.3%. Alternatively, one can optimize the cuts with a first set of data, and then apply them to the remaining data directly without statistical penalty. One can extend the statistical power of this test by considering cross-correlation between the initial data and the remaining data, as long as the initial clustering signal is not included. While the scan is more useful in general, in the present case only splitting the data set offers an unbiased test of the clustering hypothesis. Using this test we find that the AGASA data is consistent at the 8% level with the null hypothesis of isotropically distributed arrival directions.
arXiv comment14 pages, 3 figures. Unbiased test expanded to include cross-correlation between initial and later data sets for greater statistical power; minor revisions to discussion. Accepted by Astropart. Phys
References in corpus (2)
Cited by in corpus (68)
- On astrophysical solution to ultra high energy cosmic rays
- Correlation of the highest-energy cosmic rays with the positions of nearby active galactic nuclei
- Methods for point source analysis in high energy neutrino telescopes
- Cosmic Neutrino Pevatrons: A Brand New Pathway to Astronomy, Astrophysics, and Particle Physics
- Search for Correlations between HiRes Stereo Events and Active Galactic Nuclei
- Anisotropy vs chemical composition at ultra-high energies
- Neutrinos as a diagnostic of cosmic ray Galactic/extra-galactic transition
- Study of Small-Scale Anisotropy of Ultrahigh Energy Cosmic Rays Observed in Stereo by HiRes
- The Galactic magnetic field as spectrograph for ultra-high energy cosmic rays
- Beginning a journey across the universe: the discovery of extragalactic neutrino factories
- Cosmic Rays: The Second Knee and Beyond
- On Active Galactic Nuclei as Sources of Ultra-High Energy Cosmic Rays
- Searches for small-scale anisotropies from neutrino point sources with three years of IceCube data
- High Energy Physics in the Atmosphere: Phenomenology of Cosmic Ray Air Showers
- Cosmic Ray Astronomy
- Ultrahigh Energy Nuclei Propagation in a Structured, Magnetized Universe
- Ultra-high energy cosmic rays from a finite number of point sources
- Search for Point Sources of Ultra-High Energy Cosmic Rays Above 40 EeV Using a Maximum Likelihood Ratio Test
- Cosmic Magnetic Fields and Their Influence on Ultra-High Energy Cosmic Ray Propagation
- IceHEP High Energy Physics at the South Pole
- Clustering of ultra-high energy cosmic ray arrival directions on medium scales
- What can be learnt from UHECR anisotropies observations? Paper I : large-scale anisotropies and composition features
- Does Galactic Magnetic Field Disturb the Correlation of the Highest Energy Cosmic Rays with their Sources?
- Propagation and Signatures of Ultra High Energy Cosmic Rays
- Constraints on the Local Sources of Ultra High-Energy Cosmic Rays
- Very High Energy Cosmic Rays and Their Interactions
- A Search for Arrival Direction Clustering in the HiRes-I Monocular Data above 10^(19.5) eV
- Statistical Analysis of the Correlation between Active Galactic Nuclei and Ultra-High Energy Cosmic Rays
- Clustering properties of ultrahigh energy cosmic rays and the search for their astrophysical sources
- A global autocorrelation study after the first Auger data: impact on the number density of UHECR sources
- On The Origin of Very High Energy Cosmic Rays
- Instant preheating mechanism and UHECR
- Searches for clustering in the time integrated skymap of the ANTARES neutrino telescope
- A doublet of cosmic-ray events with primary energies >10^20 eV
- A closer look at the spectrum and small scale anisotropies of UHECRs
- Status and Recent Results of the Acoustic Neutrino Detection Test System AMADEUS
- Method to Look for Imprints of Ultrahigh Energy Nuclei Sources
- Contributions to the 32nd International Cosmic Ray Conference (ICRC 2011) by the ANTARES collaboration
- Reply to ``Cuts and penalties: comment on `The clustering of ultra-high energy cosmic rays and their sources' ''
- Identification of extragalactic sources of the highest energy EGRET photons by correlation analysis
- Statistics of cluster multiplicity and the nature of UHE cosmic ray sources
- Blind search for the real sample: Application to the origin of ultra-high energy cosmic rays
- Ultra-High Energy Cosmic Ray Nuclei from Individual Magnetized Sources
- Anisotropies and clustering of extragalactic cosmic rays
- Search for clustering of ultra high energy cosmic rays from the Pierre Auger Observatory
- Observations of Ultra-High Energy Cosmic Rays
- Physical conditions in nearby active galaxies correlated with ultra-high-energy cosmic rays detected by the Pierre Auger Observatory
- Astrophysical interpretation of the medium scale clustering in the ultra-high energy sky
- Latest Results from HiRes
- Systematic Survey of the Correlation between Northern HECR Events and SDSS Galaxies
- Experimental Ultra--High-Energy Cosmic Ray Physics
- Small Scale Anisotropy Predictions for the Auger Observatory
- Search for Small-Scale Anisotropy of Cosmic Rays above 10^19 eV with HiRes Stereo
- New physics from ultrahigh energy cosmic rays
- Search for Correlations between Nearby AGNs and Ultra-high Energy Cosmic Rays
- Astronomy with ultra high-energy particles
- High Energy Astroparticle Physics
- The Pierre Auger Observatory -Status and Prospects -
- Extended clustering analyses to constrain the deflection angular scale and source density of the ultra-high-energy cosmic rays
- The origin of ultra high energy cosmic rays
- Uncovering neutrinos from cosmic ray factories: the Multi Point Source method
- The Mysteries of the Highest Energy Cosmic Rays
- Magnetic deflections and possible sources of the ultra-high-energy cosmic rays in the AGASA-HiRes-Yakutsk cluster
- Open questions with ultra-high energy cosmic rays
- The Search for Anisotropy in the Arrival Directions of Ultra-High Energy Cosmic Rays Observed by the High Resolution Fly's Eye Detector in Monocular Mode
- Cosmic Rays at the Highest Energies -- First Data from the Pierre Auger Observatory --
- Angular Correlation Estimates for Ultrahigh Energy Cosmic Rays
- A new method to test the hypothesis of isotropy of the ultrahigh energy cosmic ray flux