MWC 656 is unlikely to contain a black hole

Abstract

Context. MWC 656 was reported as the first known Be star with a black-hole (BH) companion in a 60 d period. The mass of the proposed BH companion is estimated to be between 4 - 7 MSun. This estimate is based on radial velocity (RV) measurements derived from the Fe ii 4583 emission line of the Be star disc and from the He ii 4686 emission line, assumed to be formed in a disc around the putative BH. Aims. Using new high-resolution spectroscopic data, we investigate whether MWC 656 truly contains a BH. Methods. We used the cross-correlation method to calculate the RVs of both the Be star and the He ii 4686 emission line and we derive a new orbital solution. We also performed disentangling to look for the spectral signature of a companion. Results. We derive an orbital period of 59.028 +- 0.011 d and a mass ratio q = M_Heii/M_Be = 0.12 +- 0.03, much lower than the previously reported q = 0.41 +- 0.07. Adopting a mass of the Be star of M_Be = 7.8 +- 2.0MSun, the companion has a mass of 0.94 +- 0.34MSun. For the upper limit of M_Be = 16MSun and q = 0.15, the companion has a mass 2.4MSun. Performing disentangling on mock spectra shows that the spectral signature of a non-degenerate stellar companion with such a low mass cannot be retrieved using our data. Conclusions. Our measurements do not support the presence of a BH companion in MWC 656. The derived upper limit on the mass of the companion rather indicates that it is a neutron star, a white dwarf, or a hot helium star. Far-UV data will help to reject or confirm a hot helium-star companion.

6 pages, 2 + 6 figures, 3 + 1 tables, accepted for publication in A&A

References in corpus (17)

• A Grid of NLTE Line-Blanketed Model Atmospheres of Early B-type Stars
• Cross-Correlation and Maximum Likelihood Analysis: A New Approach to Combine Cross-Correlation Functions
• Is HR 6819 a triple system containing a black hole? -- An alternative explanation
• Investigating the lack of main-sequence companions to massive Be stars
• Detection of a Hot Subdwarf Companion to the Be Star FY Canis Majoris
• A new radio census of neutron star X-ray binaries
• The Tarantula Massive Binary Monitoring VI: Characterisation of hidden companions in 51 single-lined O-type binaries, a flat mass-ratio distribution, and black-hole binary candidates
• The First Simultaneous X-Ray/Radio Detection of the First Be/BH System MWC 656
• Discovery of X-ray emission from the first Be/black hole system
• The X-ray emission of Be+stripped star binaries
• Swift J004427.3-734801- a probable Be/white dwarf system in the Small Magellanic Cloud
• Exploratory Spectroscopy of Magnetic Cataclysmic Variables Candidates and Other Variable Objects
• Classical OBe Stars as Post-Supernova Runaways: Confirming Binary Origins
• A MeerKAT Survey of Nearby Novalike Cataclysmic Variables
• Properties of the Be-type stars in 30 Doradus
• The gamma-ray source AGL J2241+4454 as the possible counterpart of MWC 656
• An updated gamma-ray analysis of the Be-BH binary HD~215227