Underdetermination in Classic and Modern Tests of General Relativity

Abstract

Canonically, `classic' tests of general relativity (GR) include perihelion precession, the bending of light around stars, and gravitational redshift; `modern' tests have to do with, inter alia, relativistic time delay, equivalence principle tests, gravitational lensing, strong field gravity, and gravitational waves. The orthodoxy is that both classic and modern tests of GR afford experimental confirmation of that theory in particular. In this article, we question this orthodoxy, by showing there are classes of both relativistic theories (with spatiotemporal geometrical properties different from those of GR) and non-relativistic theories (in which the lightcones of a relativistic spacetime are `widened') which would also pass such tests. Thus, (a) issues of underdetermination in the context of GR loom much larger than one might have thought, and (b) given this, one has to think more carefully about what exactly such tests in fact are testing.

This is a revised version of the previous draft

References in corpus (21)

• The Confrontation between General Relativity and Experiment
• Quantum Gravity at a Lifshitz Point
• Strong constraints on cosmological gravity from GW170817 and GRB 170817A
• Detection of the Schwarzschild precession in the orbit of the star S2 near the Galactic centre massive black hole
• General coordinate invariance and conformal invariance in nonrelativistic physics: Unitary Fermi gas
• Horava-Lifshitz Cosmology: A Review
• Non-Relativistic Strings and Limits of the AdS/CFT Correspondence
• Comparing Equivalent Gravities: common features and differences
• Underdetermination of dark energy
• Pulsars and Gravity
• Bigravity and Lorentz-violating Massive Gravity
• Standard Sirens as a novel probe of dark energy
• Noether charge and black hole entropy in teleparallel gravity
• Role of spacetime boundaries in Einstein's other gravity
• Lifshitz Hydrodynamics from Lifshitz Black Branes with Linear Momentum
• Methodological Reflections on the MOND/Dark Matter Debate
• The Non-Relativistic Geometric Trinity of Gravity
• On the geometric trinity of gravity, non-relativistic limits, and Maxwell gravitation
• Fields as Bodies: a unified presentation of spacetime and internal gauge symmetry
• Cosmological Inflation and Meta-Empirical Theory Assessment
• Is spacetime curved? Assessing the underdetermination of general relativity and teleparallel gravity

Cited by in corpus (2)

• Is spacetime curved? Assessing the underdetermination of general relativity and teleparallel gravity
• Equivalent Gravities and Equivalence Principle: Foundations and experimental implications