Comparison of the Lifshitz Theory Using the Nonconventional Fit of Response Functions with Precise Measurements of the Casimir Force

Abstract

It has been known that the fundamental Lifshitz theory, which is based on first principles of thermal quantum field theory, experiences difficulties when compared with precise measurements of the Casimir force. We analyze the nonconventional fit of response functions of many materials along the imaginary frequency axis to the empirical model of "modified" oscillators which was recently proposed in the literature. According to our results, this model is unacceptable because at high frequencies it leads to the asymptotic behavior of response functions which is in contradiction with that following from the fundamental physical principles. We calculate the Casimir interaction in the configurations of several precise experiments using the Lifshitz theory and the response functions to quantized electromagnetic field expressed in terms of modified oscillators and demonstrate that the obtained results are excluded by the measurement data. This invalidates a claim made in the literature that the Casimir-van der Waals forces calculated using these response functions are in remarkable agreement with the experimental values. Possible reasons for a disagreement between experiment and theory are discussed, and the way to improve the situation is directed.

13 pages, 4 figures

References in corpus (19)

• Novel constraints on light elementary particles and extra-dimensional physics from the Casimir effect
• Control of the Casimir force by the modification of dielectric properties with light
• Influence of random roughness on the Casimir force at small separations
• Demonstration of the Casimir force between ferromagnetic surfaces of a Ni-coated sphere and a Ni-coated plate
• Conductivity of dielectric and thermal atom-wall interaction
• Kramers-Kronig relations for plasma-like permittivities and the Casimir force
• Significance of the Casimir force and surface roughness for actuation dynamics of MEMS
• Plasma vs Drude modelling of the Casimir force: beyond the proximity force approximation
• Casimir Puzzle and Casimir Conundrum: Discovery and Search for Resolution
• Control of the Casimir Force Using Semiconductor Test Bodies
• Magnetic materials and the problem of thermal Casimir force
• Going beyond PFA: a precise formula for the sphere-plate Casimir force
• An alternative response to the off-shell quantum fluctuations: A step forward in resolution of the Casimir puzzle
• Theory-experiment comparison for the Casimir force between metallic test bodies: A spatially nonlocal dielectric response
• Current status of the problem of thermal Casimir force
• Probing the response of metals to low-frequency s-polarized evanescent fields
• Experimentum crucis for electromagnetic response of metals to evanescent waves and the Casimir puzzle
• Casimir pressure in peptide films on metallic substrates: Change of sign via graphene coating
• Attractive and repulsive fluctuation-induced pressure in peptide films deposited on semiconductor substrates