Plasma vs Drude modelling of the Casimir force: beyond the proximity force approximation
arXiv:1705.04196 · doi:10.1103/PhysRevLett.119.043901
Abstract
We calculate the Casimir force and its gradient between a spherical and a planar gold surface. Significant numerical improvements allow us to extend the range of accessible parameters into the experimental regime. We compare our numerically exact results with those obtained within the proximity force approximation (PFA) employed in the analysis of all Casimir force experiments reported in the literature so far. Special attention is paid to the difference between the Drude model and the dissipationless plasma model at zero frequency. It is found that the correction to PFA is too small to explain the discrepancy between the experimental data and the PFA result based on the Drude model. However, it turns out that for the plasma model, the corrections to PFA lie well outside the experimental bound obtained by probing the variation of the force gradient with the sphere radius [D. E. Krause et al., Phys. Rev. Lett. 98, 050403 (2007)]. The corresponding corrections based on the Drude model are significantly smaller but still in violation of the experimental bound for small distances between plane and sphere.
arXiv comment6 pages, 3 figures; final version accepted for publication in PRL
References in corpus (32)
- The Casimir force between real materials: experiment and theory
- Tests of new physics from precise measurements of the Casimir pressure between two gold-coated plates
- Casimir forces between arbitrary compact objects
- Observation of the thermal Casimir force
- Scattering Theory Approach to Electrodynamic Casimir Forces
- Casimir force between metallic mirrors
- Novel constraints on light elementary particles and extra-dimensional physics from the Casimir effect
- The Casimir effect within scattering theory
- Gradient of the Casimir force between Au surfaces of a sphere and a plate measured using atomic force microscope in a frequency shift technique
- Isoelectronic determination of the thermal Casimir force
- Demonstration of the Casimir force between ferromagnetic surfaces of a Ni-coated sphere and a Ni-coated plate
- Casimir forces beyond the proximity approximation
- The proximity force approximation for the Casimir energy as a derivative expansion
- Casimir energy between a plane and a sphere in electromagnetic vacuum
- Fluctuation induced quantum interactions between compact objects and a plane mirror
- Material dependence of Casimir forces: gradient expansion beyond proximity
- Casimir Force and In Situ Surface Potential Measurements on Nanomembranes
- Casimir interaction between plane and spherical metallic surfaces
- Thermal Casimir Effect in the Plane-Sphere Geometry
- Thermal Casimir effect for Drude metals in the plane-sphere geometry
- Probing the Casimir force with optical tweezers
- On the corrections beyond proximity force approximation (PFA)
- Exact results for classical Casimir interactions: Dirichlet and Drude model in the sphere-sphere and sphere-plane geometry
- Going beyond PFA: a precise formula for the sphere-plate Casimir force
- Classical Casimir interaction in the plane-sphere geometry
- The derivative expansion approach to the interaction between close surfaces
- Derivation of the Lifshitz-Matsubara sum formula for the Casimir pressure between metallic plane mirrors
- Comment on "Casimir Force and In Situ Surface Potential Measurements on Nanomembranes"
- Progress in Experimental Measurements of the Surface-Surface Casimir Force: Electrostatic Calibrations and Limitations to Accuracy
- Disentangling geometric and dissipative origins of negative Casimir entropies
- On the Derivative Expansion for the Electromagnetic Casimir Free Energy at High Temperatures
- Classical Casimir interaction of perfectly conducting sphere and plate
Cited by in corpus (45)
- Measurement of the Casimir Force between 0.2 and 8 mum: Experimental Procedures and Comparison with Theory
- Casimir Puzzle and Casimir Conundrum: Discovery and Search for Resolution
- Precision measurements of the gradient of the Casimir force between ultra clean metallic surfaces at larger separations
- Examining the Casimir puzzle with upgraded technique and advanced surface cleaning
- Demonstration of an Unusual Thermal Effect in the Casimir Force from Graphene
- Reducing detrimental electrostatic effects in Casimir-force measurements and Casimir-force-based microdevices
- Experimental and theoretical investigation of the thermal effect in the Casimir interaction from graphene
- An alternative response to the off-shell quantum fluctuations: A step forward in resolution of the Casimir puzzle
- Proximity force approximation and specular reflection: Application of the WKB limit of Mie scattering to the Casimir effect
- The State of the Art in Constraining Axion-to-Nucleon Coupling and Non-Newtonian Gravity from Laboratory Experiments
- Thermal effect in the Casimir force for graphene and graphene-coated substrates: Impact of nonzero mass gap and chemical potential
- Casimir and Casimir-Polder Forces in Graphene Systems: Quantum Field Theoretical Description and Thermodynamics
- Probing the screening of the Casimir interaction with optical tweezers
- Scattering theory of the screened Casimir interaction in electrolytes
- Theory-experiment comparison for the Casimir force between metallic test bodies: A spatially nonlocal dielectric response
- Beyond-PFA Casimir Force between two spheres at finite temperature
- Casimir Effect Invalidates the Drude Model for Transverse Electric Evanescent Waves
- The role of diffraction in the Casimir effect beyond the proximity force approximation
- Plane-wave approach to the exact van der Waals interaction between colloid particles
- Advancing numerics for the Casimir effect to experimentally relevant aspect ratios
- Casimir effect for magnetic media: Spatially nonlocal response to the off-shell quantum fluctuation
- Nonadditive Enhancement of Nonequilibrium Atom-Surface Interactions
- Current status of the problem of thermal Casimir force
- Nonequilibrium effects in the Casimir force between two similar metallic plates kept at different temperatures
- Casimir entropy and nonlocal response functions to the off-shell quantum fluctuations
- Sensitivity and accuracy of Casimir force measurements in air
- Beyond-proximity-force-approximation Casimir force between two spheres at finite temperature II: plasma versus Drude modeling, grounded versus isolated spheres
- Unifying Theory for Casimir Forces: Bulk and Surface Formulations
- The Casimir effect in graphene systems: Experiment and theory
- Casimir forces and high-Tc superconductors
- Repulsive vacuum-induced forces on a magnetic particle
- Casimir induced instabilities at metallic surfaces and interfaces
- High-accuracy Casimir-Polder force calculations using the Discontinuous Galerkin Time-Domain method
- Casimir forces in the flatland: interplay between photo-induced phase transitions and quantum Hall physics
- The Casimir force, causality and the Gurzhi model
- Spectrally Sharp Near-Field Thermal Emission: Revealing Some Disagreements between a Casimir-Polder Sensor and Predictions from Far-Field Emittance
- Apparatus to probe the influence on the Casimir effect of the Mott-Anderson metal-insulator transition in doped semiconductors
- Testing Gravity and Predictions Beyond the Standard Model at Short Distances: The Casimir Effect
- Casimir repulsion with biased semiconductors
- Casimir Interaction Between a Plane and a Sphere: Correction to the Proximity-Force Approximation at Intermediate Temperatures
- Casimir effect between spherical objects: proximity-force approximation and beyond using plane waves
- Proposal to measure the Casimir Effect Across the Superconducting Transition
- Distinguishing models of surface response through the self-energy of an electron
- Comparison of the Lifshitz Theory Using the Nonconventional Fit of Response Functions with Precise Measurements of the Casimir Force
- Corrected Proximity-Force Approximation for Lateral Casimir Forces