Many recent density functionals are numerically ill-behaved

Abstract

Most computational studies in chemistry and materials science are based on the use of density functional theory. Although the exact density functional is unknown, several density functional approximations (DFAs) offer a good balance of affordable computational cost and semi-quantitative accuracy for applications. The development of DFAs still continues on many fronts, and several new DFAs aiming for improved accuracy are published every year. However, the numerical behavior of these DFAs is an often overlooked problem. In this work, we look at all 592 DFAs for three-dimensional systems available in Libxc 5.2.2 and examine the convergence of the density functional total energy based on tabulated atomic Hartree-Fock wave functions. We show that several recent DFAs, including the celebrated SCAN family of functionals, show impractically slow convergence with typically used numerical quadrature schemes, making these functionals unsuitable both for routine applications or high-precision studies, as thousands of radial quadrature points may be required to achieve sub-$\mu E_h$ accurate total energies for these unctionals, while standard quadrature grids like the SG-3 grid only contain $\mathcal{O}(100)$ radial quadrature points. These results are both a warning to users to lways check the sufficiency of the quadrature grid when adopting novel functionals, as well as a guideline to the theory community to develop better behaved density functionals.

arXiv comment16 pages, 6 figures

References in corpus (30)

• Climbing the Density Functional Ladder: Non-Empirical Meta-Generalized Gradient Approximation Designed for Molecules and Solids
• A More Accurate Generalized Gradient Approximation for Solids
• Recent developments in the PySCF program package
• Long-Range Corrected Hybrid Density Functionals with Improved Dispersion Corrections
• NWChem: Past, Present, and Future
• Regularized SCAN functional
• Semilocal and Hybrid Meta-Generalized Gradient Approximations Based on the Understanding of the Kinetic-Energy-Density Dependence
• Laplacian-level density functionals for the kinetic energy density and exchange-correlation energy
• Accurate semilocal density functional for condensed matter physics and quantum chemistry
• The Elephant in the Room of Density Functional Theory Calculations
• Semilocal Pauli-Gaussian Kinetic Functionals for Orbital-Free Density Functional Theory Calculations of Solids
• Deorbitalized meta-GGA Exchange-Correlation Functionals in Solids
• Deorbitalization strategies for meta-GGA exchange-correlation functionals
• Meta-GGA Performance in Solids at Almost GGA Cost
• An assessment of initial guesses for self-consistent field calculations. Superposition of Atomic Potentials: simple yet efficient
• Constraint-based, Single-point Approximate Kinetic Energy Functionals
• An overview of self-consistent field calculations within finite basis sets
• A review on non-relativistic fully numerical electronic structure calculations on atoms and diatomic molecules
• Construction of meta-GGA functionals through restoration of exact constraint adherence to regularized SCAN functionals
• Enhancing the efficiency of density functionals with a novel iso-orbital indicator
• Fully numerical calculations on atoms with fractional occupations. Range-separated exchange functionals
• Fully numerical Hartree-Fock and density functional calculations. I. Atoms
• Visualization and analysis of the Kohn-Sham kinetic energy density and its orbital-free description in molecules
• Improving the performance of Tao-Mo non-empirical density functional with broader applicability in quantum chemistry and material sciences
• Fully numerical Hartree-Fock and density functional calculations. II. Diatomic molecules
• Generalized gradient approximation correlation energy functionals based on the uniform electron gas with gap model
• Beyond the local approximation to exchange and correlation: the role of the Laplacian of the density in the energy density of Si
• Exchange functionals based on finite uniform electron gases
• Meta-local density functionals: a new rung on Jacob's ladder
• How good are recent density functionals for ground and excited states of one-electron systems?

Cited by in corpus (9)

• Meta-GGA density functional calculations on atoms with spherically symmetric densities in the finite element formalism
• Atomic electronic structure calculations with Hermite interpolating polynomials
• Reproducibility of density functional approximations: how new functionals should be reported
• Machine learning for accuracy in density functional approximations
• On the accuracy of a recent regularized nuclear potential
• Ensemble Generalization of the Perdew-Zunger Self-Interaction Correction: a Way Out of Multiple Minima and Symmetry Breaking
• Systematic study of confinement induced effects on atomic electronic structure
• VAMPyR -- A High-Level Python Library for Mathematical Operations in a Multiwavelets Representation
• Review of the finite difference Hartree-Fock method for atoms and diatomic molecules, and its implementation in the x2dhf program