The Elephant in the Room of Density Functional Theory Calculations

Abstract

Using multiwavelets, we have obtained total energies and corresponding atomization energies for the GGA-PBE and hybrid-PBE0 density functionals for a test set of 211 molecules with an unprecedented and guaranteed $\mu$Hartree accuracy. These quasi-exact references allow us to quantify the accuracy of standard all-electron basis sets that are believed to be highly accurate for molecules, such as Gaussian-type orbitals (GTOs), all-electron numeric atom-centered orbitals (NAOs) and full-potential augmented plane wave (APW) methods. We show that NAOs are able to achieve the so-called chemical accuracy (1 kcal/mol) for the typical basis set sizes used in applications, for both total and atomization energies. For GTOs, a triple-zeta quality basis has mean errors of ~10kcal/mol in total energies, while chemical accuracy is almost reached for a quintuple-zeta basis. Due to systematic error cancellations, atomization energy errors are reduced by almost an order of magnitude, placing chemical accuracy within reach also for medium to large GTO bases, albeit with significant outliers. In order to check the accuracy of the computed densities, we have also investigated the dipole moments, where in general, only the largest NAO and GTO bases are able to yield errors below 0.01 Debye. The observed errors are similar across the different functionals considered here.

References in corpus (1)

• Libxc: a library of exchange and correlation functionals for density functional theory

Cited by in corpus (35)

• A Perspective on Conventional High-Temperature Superconductors at High Pressure: Methods and Materials
• 103-Compound Band Structure Benchmark of Post-SCF Spin-Orbit Coupling Treatments in Density-Functional Theory
• ELSI: A Unified Software Interface for Kohn-Sham Electronic Structure Solvers
• A review on non-relativistic fully numerical electronic structure calculations on atoms and diatomic molecules
• Ab Initio Bethe-Salpeter Equation Approach to Neutral Excitations in Molecules with Numeric Atom-Centered Orbitals
• All-electron periodic $G_0{W}_0$ implementation with numerical atomic orbital basis functions: algorithm and benchmarks
• Reducing qubit requirements while maintaining numerical precision for the Variational Quantum Eigensolver: A Basis-Set-Free Approach
• Many recent density functionals are numerically ill-behaved
• How Large is the Elephant in the Density Functional Theory Room?
• GPGPU Acceleration of All-Electron Electronic Structure Theory Using Localized Numeric Atom-Centered Basis Functions
• CIDER: An Expressive, Nonlocal Feature Set for Machine Learning Density Functionals with Exact Constraints
• Microhartree Precision in Density-Functional-Theory Calculations
• Meta-GGA density functional calculations on atoms with spherically symmetric densities in the finite element formalism
• Polarized Gaussian basis sets from one-electron ions
• Reproducibility of density functional approximations: how new functionals should be reported
• PyFLOSIC: Python-based Fermi-Löwdin orbital self-interaction correction
• Accuracy of Charge Densities in Electronic Structure Calculations
• Exploring organic semiconductors in solution: The effects of solvation, alkylization, and doping
• Similarity of materials and data-quality assessment by fingerprinting
• Fast and robust all-electron density functional theory calculations in solids using orthogonalized enriched finite elements
• Solving the electronic structure problem for over 100,000 atoms in real-space
• Scalar relativistic effects with Multiwavelets: Implementation and benchmark
• Combining Pseudopotential and All Electron Density Functional Theory for the Efficient Calculation of Core Spectra using a Multiresolution Approach
• Shortcut to Chemically Accurate Quantum Computing via Density-based Basis-set Correction
• Full Breit Hamiltonian in the Multiwavelets Framework
• Linear scalability of density functional theory calculations without imposing electron localization
• VAMPyR -- A High-Level Python Library for Mathematical Operations in a Multiwavelets Representation
• Adaptive algorithm for electronic structure calculations using reduction of Gaussian mixtures
• Noise Tolerant Force Calculations in Density Functional Theory: A Surface Integral Approach for Wavelet-Based Methods
• Importance profiles. Visualization of atomic basis set requirements
• Atomic Confinement Potentials and the Generation of Numerical Atomic Orbitals
• Basis set convergence and extrapolation of connected triple excitation contributions (T) in computational thermochemistry: the W4-17 benchmark with up to k functions
• Multiresolution of the one dimensional free-particle propagator. Part 1: Construction
• Wavefunction optimization at the complete basis set limit with Multiwavelets and DMRG
• Consistent GMTKN55 and molecular-crystal accuracy using minimally empirical DFT with XDM(Z) dispersion