Evidence for a Non-Dichotomous Solution to the Kepler Dichotomy: Mutual Inclinations of Kepler Planetary Systems from Transit Duration Variations

Abstract

Early analyses of exoplanet statistics from the Kepler Mission revealed that a model population of multiple-planet systems with low mutual inclinations ($\sim 1^{\circ }-2^{\circ }$) adequately describes the multiple-transiting systems but underpredicts the number of single-transiting systems. This so-called "Kepler dichotomy" signals the existence of a sub-population of multi-planet systems possessing larger mutual inclinations. However, the details of these inclinations remain uncertain. In this work, we derive constraints on the intrinsic mutual inclination distribution by statistically exploiting Transit Duration Variations (TDVs) of the Kepler planet population. When planetary orbits are mutually inclined, planet-planet interactions cause orbital precession, which can lead to detectable long-term changes in transit durations. These TDV signals are inclination-sensitive and have been detected for roughly two dozen Kepler planets. We compare the properties of the Kepler observed TDV detections to TDV detections of simulated planetary systems constructed from two population models with differing assumptions about the mutual inclination distribution. We find strong evidence for a continuous distribution of relatively low mutual inclinations that is well-characterized by a power law relationship between the median mutual inclination (${\tilde{\mu }}_{i,n}$) and the intrinsic multiplicity ($n$): ${\tilde{\mu }}_{i,n}={\tilde{\mu }}_{i,5}(n/5{)}^{\alpha }$, where ${\tilde{\mu }}_{i,5}=1.10_{-0.11}^{+0.15}$ and $\alpha =-1.73_{-0.08}^{+0.09}$. These results suggest that late-stage planet assembly and possibly stellar oblateness are the dominant physical origins for the excitation of Kepler planet mutual inclinations.

arXiv commentAccepted to AJ, 19 pages, 10 figures (excluding appendix)

References in corpus (85)

• The PLATO 2.0 Mission
• REBOUND: An open-source multi-purpose N-body code for collisional dynamics
• Planetary Candidates Observed by Kepler, III: Analysis of the First 16 Months of Data
• The Occurrence and Architecture of Exoplanetary Systems
• Architecture and Dynamics of Kepler's Candidate Multiple Transiting Planet Systems
• Architecture of Kepler's Multi-transiting Systems: II. New investigations with twice as many candidates
• Dynamics of Protoplanetary Disks
• WHFast: A fast and unbiased implementation of a symplectic Wisdom-Holman integrator for long term gravitational simulations
• Planetary Candidates Observed by Kepler. VIII. A Fully Automated Catalog With Measured Completeness and Reliability Based on Data Release 25
• Breaking the Chains: Hot Super-Earth systems from migration and disruption of compact resonant chains
• Migration and the formation of systems of hot super-Earths and Neptunes
• Orbital perturbations on transiting planets: A possible method to measure stellar quadrupoles and to detect Earth-mass planets
• About 30% of Sun-like Stars Have Kepler-like Planetary Systems: A Study of their Intrinsic Architecture
• Testing In Situ Assembly with the Kepler Planet Candidate Sample
• The Exoplanet Population Observation Simulator. I - The Inner Edges of Planetary Systems
• Architecture of Planetary Systems Based on Kepler Data: Number of Planets and Coplanarity
• Alignment of the stellar spin with the orbits of a three-planet system
• Occurrence Rates of Planets orbiting FGK Stars: Combining Kepler DR25, Gaia DR2 and Bayesian Inference
• Transit Timing Observations from Kepler. IX. Catalog of the Full Long-Cadence Data Set
• On the formation of planetary systems via oligarchic growth in thermally evolving viscous discs
• An Excess of Jupiter Analogs in Super-Earth Systems
• The Super Earth-Cold Jupiter Relations
• The Gaia-Kepler Stellar Properties Catalog. II. Planet Radius Demographics as a Function of Stellar Mass and Age
• The statistics of multi-planet systems
• Star-Disc-Binary Interactions in Protoplanetary Disc Systems and Primordial Spin-Orbit Misalignments
• The Kepler Dichotomy among the M Dwarfs: Half of Systems Contain Five or More Coplanar Planets
• Photometric Amplitude Distribution of Stellar Rotation of Kepler KOIs-Indication for Spin-Orbit Alignment of Cool Stars and High Obliquity for Hot Stars
• Hot super-Earths and giant planet cores from different migration histories
• AMD-stability and the classification of planetary systems
• Architectures of Exoplanetary Systems. I: A Clustered Forward Model for Exoplanetary Systems around Kepler's FGK Stars
• Can planetary instability explain the Kepler dichotomy?
• Comparing HARPS and Kepler surveys: The alignment of multiple-planet systems
• Transit Timing Observations from Kepler: I. Statistical Analysis of the First Four Months
• Obliquity-Driven Sculpting of Exoplanetary Systems
• Architectures of Exoplanetary Systems. III: Eccentricity and Mutual Inclination Distributions of AMD-stable Planetary Systems
• Five Kepler target stars that show multiple transiting exoplanet candidates
• WASP-107b's density is even lower: a case study for the physics of planetary gas envelope accretion and orbital migration
• Correlations between compositions and orbits established by the giant impact era of planet formation
• Julia: A Fresh Approach to Numerical Computing
• Accounting for Incompleteness due to Transit Multiplicity in Kepler Planet Occurrence Rates
• The 55 Cancri Planetary System: Fully Self-Consistent N-body Constraints and a Dynamical Analysis
• HAT-P-11: Discovery of a Second Planet and a Clue to Understanding Exoplanet Obliquities
• An Empirically Derived Three-Dimensional Laplace Resonance in the Gliese 876 Planetary System
• The effects of external planets on inner systems: multiplicities, inclinations, and pathways to eccentric warm Jupiters
• Evidence for a high mutual inclination between the cold Jupiter and transiting super Earth orbiting $\pi$ Men
• Early Excitation of Spin-Orbit Misalignments in Close-in Planetary Systems
• Occurrence and Architecture of Kepler Planetary Systems as Functions of Stellar Mass and Effective Temperature
• Improving the Accuracy of Planet Occurrence Rates from Kepler using Approximate Bayesian Computation
• Spin-orbit Misalignment as a Driver of the Kepler Dichotomy
• Larger mutual inclinations for the shortest-period planets
• The Kepler Dichotomy in Planetary Disks: Linking Kepler Observables to Simulations of Late-Stage Planet Formation
• Formation of Ultra-Short-Period Planets by Obliquity-Driven Tidal Runaway
• Hiding Planets Behind a Big Friend: Mutual Inclinations of Multi-Planet Systems with External Companions
• A Dynamical Analysis of the 47 UMa Planetary System
• Effects of Unseen Additional Planetary Perturbers on Compact Extrasolar Planetary Systems
• Eccentricities and Inclinations of Multi-Planet Systems with External Perturbers
• Kepler-108: A Mutually Inclined Giant Planet System
• Planet Formation in Disks with Inclined Binary Companions: Can Primordial Spin-Orbit Misalignment be Produced?
• HARPS-N radial velocities confirm the low densities of the Kepler-9 planets
• AMD-stability in presence of first order Mean Motion Resonances
• New Constraints on Gliese 876 -- Exemplar of Mean-Motion Resonance
• Mutual Orbital Inclinations Between Cold Jupiters and Inner Super-Earths
• The multiplicity distribution of Kepler's exoplanets
• Orbital misalignment of the super-Earth $\pi$ Men c with the spin of its star
• Outer-planet scattering can gently tilt an inner planetary system
• Eccentric Companions to Kepler-448b and Kepler-693b: Clues to the Formation of Warm Jupiters
• Architectures of Exoplanetary Systems. II: An Increase in Inner Planetary System Occurrence Toward Later Spectral Types for Kepler's FGK Dwarfs
• Hot Stars With Kepler Planets Have High Obliquities
• Formation of compact systems of super-Earths via dynamical instabilities and giant impacts
• K2-146: Discovery of Planet c, Precise Masses from Transit Timing, and Observed Precession
• Alignment of Protostars and Circumstellar Disks During the Embedded Phase
• Kepler Object of Interest Network II. Photodynamical modelling of Kepler-9 over 8 years of transit observations
• Mutual Inclination Excitation by Stellar Oblateness
• Stellar Oblateness versus Distant Giants in Exciting Kepler Planet Mutual Inclinations
• Formation of Close-in Super-Earths by Giant Impacts: Effects of Initial Eccentricities and Inclinations of Protoplanets
• Identifying inflated super-Earths and photo-evaporated cores
• Formation of short-period planets by disk migration
• Visual Analysis and Demographics of Kepler Transit Timing Variations
• No Metallicity Correlation Associated with the Kepler Dichotomy
• The Dynamics of Tightly-packed Planetary Systems in the Presence of an Outer Planet: case studies using Kepler-11 and Kepler-90
• Systematic search for long-term transit duration changes in Kepler transiting planets
• Transit Duration Variations in Multi-Planet Systems
• Robustly detecting changes in warm Jupiters' transit impact parameters
• Light-Curve Evolution due to Secular Dynamics and the Vanishing Transits of KOI 120.01
• A Bayesian neural network predicts the dissolution of compact planetary systems

Cited by in corpus (8)

• Stellar obliquities in exoplanetary systems
• Generalized Peas-in-a-Pod: Extending Intra-System Mass Uniformity to Non-TTV Systems via the Gini Index
• Signatures of impact-driven atmospheric loss in large ensembles of exoplanets
• Migration traps as the root cause of the Kepler dichotomy
• TOI-712: a system of adolescent mini-Neptunes extending to the habitable zone
• The Impact of Stellar Clustering on the Observed Multiplicity of Super-Earth systems: Outside-in Cascade of Orbital Misalignments Initiated by Stellar Flybys
• Dynamical Evolution of Planetary Systems
• K2-99 revisited: a non-inflated warm Jupiter, and a temperate giant planet on a 522-d orbit around a subgiant