Satellites Around Milky Way Analogs: Tension in the Number and Fraction of Quiescent Satellites Seen in Observations Versus Simulations

Abstract

We compare the star-forming properties of satellites around Milky Way (MW) analogs from the Stage~II release of the Satellites Around Galactic Analogs Survey (SAGA-II) to those from the APOSTLE and Auriga cosmological zoom-in simulation suites. We use archival GALEX UV imaging as a star-formation indicator for the SAGA-II sample and derive star-formation rates (SFRs) to compare with those from APOSTLE and Auriga. We compare our detection rates from the NUV and FUV bands to the SAGA-II H$\alpha$ detections and find that they are broadly consistent with over $85\%$ of observed satellites detected in all three tracers. We apply the same spatial selection criteria used around SAGA-II hosts to select satellites around the MW-like hosts in APOSTLE and Auriga. We find very good overall agreement in the derived SFRs for the star-forming satellites as well as the number of star-forming satellites per host in observed and simulated samples. However, the number and fraction of quenched satellites in the SAGA-II sample are significantly lower than those in APOSTLE and Auriga below a stellar mass of $M_{\ast }\sim 10^8{M}_{\odot }$, even when the SAGA-II incompleteness and interloper corrections are included. This discrepancy is robust with respect to the resolution of the simulations and persists when alternative star-formation tracers are employed. We posit that this disagreement is not readily explained by vagaries in the observed or simulated samples considered here, suggesting a genuine discrepancy that may inform the physics of satellite populations around MW analogs.

Accepted for publication in ApJ Letters after minor changes to text

References in corpus (9)

• The EAGLE project: Simulating the evolution and assembly of galaxies and their environments
• The EAGLE simulations of galaxy formation: calibration of subgrid physics and model variations
• The Auriga Project: the properties and formation mechanisms of disc galaxies across cosmic time
• The Gas Content and Stripping of Local Group Dwarf Galaxies
• Gas accretion and galactic fountain flows in the Auriga cosmological simulations: angular momentum and metal re-distribution
• Discovery of diffuse dwarf galaxy candidates around M101
• Galaxy And Mass Assembly (GAMA): Environmental Quenching of Centrals and Satellites in Groups
• Can cosmological simulations capture the diverse satellite populations of observed Milky Way analogues?
• The Mass Dependence of Dwarf Satellite Galaxy Quenching

Cited by in corpus (19)

• ELVES I: Structures of Dwarf Satellites of MW-like Galaxies; Morphology, Scaling Relations, and Intrinsic Shapes
• Resolved Dwarf Galaxy Searches within ~5 Mpc with the Vera Rubin Observatory and Subaru Hyper Suprime-Cam
• Extinguishing the FIRE: environmental quenching of satellite galaxies around Milky Way-mass hosts in simulations
• Tucana B: A Potentially Isolated and Quenched Ultra-faint Dwarf Galaxy at D$\approx$1.4 Mpc
• Hubble Space Telescope Observations of NGC 253 Dwarf Satellites: Discovery of Three Ultra-faint Dwarf Galaxies
• Satellites of Milky Way- and M31-like galaxies with TNG50: quenched fractions, gas content, and star formation histories
• The SAGA Survey. IV. The Star Formation Properties of 101 Satellite Systems around Milky Way-mass Galaxies
• ELVES III: Environmental Quenching by Milky Way-Mass Hosts
• Relating the Diverse Merger Histories and Satellite Populations of Nearby Galaxies
• Hedgehog: An Isolated Quiescent Dwarf Galaxy at 2.4 Mpc
• Colour and infall time distributions of satellite galaxies in simulated Milky-Way analogs
• The Quenched Satellite Population Around Milky Way Analogs
• HI Properties of Satellite Galaxies around Local Volume Hosts
• Census of Gaseous Satellites around Local Spiral Galaxies
• The AGORA High-Resolution Galaxy Simulations Comparison Project VII: Satellite quenching in zoom-in simulation of a Milky Way-mass halo
• Beyond Ultra-diffuse Galaxies. II. Environmental Quenching of Mass-Size Outliers among the Satellites of Milky Way Analogs
• The Role of Mass and Environment on Satellite distributions around Milky Way analogs in the Romulus25 simulation
• Quenching of satellite galaxies of Milky Way analogues: reconciling theory and observations
• The Exploration of Local VolumE Satellites (ELVES) Survey: A Nearly Volume-Limited Sample of Nearby Dwarf Satellite Systems