Power counting in chiral effective field theory and nuclear binding
arXiv:2011.11584 · doi:10.1103/PhysRevC.103.054304
Abstract
Chiral effective field theory (EFT), as originally proposed by Weinberg, promises a theoretical connection between low-energy nuclear interactions and quantum chromodynamics (QCD). However, the important property of renormalization-group (RG) invariance is not fulfilled in current implementations and its consequences for predicting atomic nuclei beyond two- and three-nucleon systems has remained unknown. In this work we present a first and systematic study of recent RG-invariant formulations of EFT and their predictions for the binding energies and other observables of selected nuclear systems with mass-numbers up to . Specifically, we have carried out ab initio no-core shell-model and coupled cluster calculations of the ground-state energy of H, He, Li, and O using several recent power-counting (PC) schemes at leading order (LO) and next-to-leading order (NLO), where the subleading interactions are treated in perturbation theory. Our calculations indicate that RG-invariant and realistic predictions can be obtained for nuclei with mass number . We find, however, that O is either unbound with respect to the four -particle threshold, or deformed, or both. Similarly, we find that the Li ground-state resides above the -deuteron separation threshold. These results are in stark contrast with experimental data and point to either necessary fine-tuning of all relevant counterterms, or that current state-of-the-art RG-invariant PC schemes at LO in EFT lack necessary diagrams -- such as three-nucleon forces -- to realistically describe nuclei with mass number .
arXiv comment18 pages, 12 figures, published version
References in corpus (124)
- An accurate nucleon-nucleon potential with charge-independence breaking
- Modern Theory of Nuclear Forces
- The high-precision, charge-dependent Bonn nucleon-nucleon potential (CD-Bonn)
- Chiral Dynamics in Nucleons and Nuclei
- Quantum Monte Carlo methods for nuclear physics
- Effective Field Theory for Few-Nucleon Systems
- The two-nucleon system at next-to-next-to-next-to-leading order
- Two-Nucleon Systems from Effective Field Theory
- The Two-Nucleon Potential from Chiral Lagrangians
- Coupled-cluster computations of atomic nuclei
- Properties of C in the {\it ab initio} nuclear shell-model
- Self-consistent Green's function method for nuclei and nuclear matter
- Accurate nuclear radii and binding energies from a chiral interaction
- Three-body forces and the limit of oxygen isotopes
- From low-momentum interactions to nuclear structure
- Nuclear effective field theory: status and perspectives
- The In-Medium Similarity Renormalization Group: A Novel Ab Initio Method for Nuclei
- Improved chiral nucleon-nucleon potential up to next-to-next-to-next-to-leading order
- Effective Field Theory for Short-Range Forces
- Nuclear forces from chiral Lagrangians using the method of unitary transformation II: The two-nucleon system
- Structure of A=10-13 nuclei with two- plus three-nucleon interactions from chiral effective field theory
- Charge, neutron, and weak size of the atomic nucleus
- Renormalization of One-Pion Exchange and Power Counting
- High-quality two-nucleon potentials up to fifth order of the chiral expansion
- Nucleon-Nucleon Scattering from Effective Field Theory
- Discrepancy between experimental and theoretical -decay rates resolved from first principles
- An optimized chiral nucleon-nucleon interaction at next-to-next-to-leading order
- Chiral interactions up to next-to-next-to-next-to-leading order and nuclear saturation
- Nuclear forces from chiral Lagrangians using the method of unitary transformation I: Formalism
- Quantum Monte Carlo Calculations with Chiral Effective Field Theory Interactions
- Heavy Baryon Chiral Perturbation Theory with Light Deltas
- Semilocal momentum-space regularized chiral two-nucleon potentials up to fifth order
- Effective Field Theory of Nuclear Forces
- Lattice simulations for few- and many-body systems
- Quantifying truncation errors in effective field theory
- A high-precision variational approach to three- and four-nucleon bound and zero-energy scattering states
- Local chiral effective field theory interactions and quantum Monte Carlo applications
- Peripheral NN-Scattering: Role of Delta-Excitation, Correlated Two-Pion and Vector Meson Exchange
- Structure of the lightest tin isotopes
- Few-nucleon systems in translationally invariant harmonic oscillator basis
- More Effective Field Theory for Nonrelativistic Scattering
- Ab initio coupled-cluster approach to nuclear structure with modern nucleon-nucleon interactions
- Continuum effects and three-nucleon forces in neutron-rich oxygen isotopes
- Accurate Nucleon-Nucleon Potential Based upon Chiral Perturbation Theory
- Saturation with chiral interactions and consequences for finite nuclei
- Ab Initio Calculations of Even Oxygen Isotopes with Chiral Two- Plus Three-Nucleon Interactions
- Ab initio alpha-alpha scattering
- Ab Initio Path to Heavy Nuclei
- Power counting with one-pion exchange
- Novel chiral Hamiltonian and observables in light and medium-mass nuclei
- Isotopic chains around oxygen from evolved chiral two- and three-nucleon interactions
- Chiral 2pi exchange at order four and peripheral NN scattering
- Quantifying Correlated Truncation Errors in Effective Field Theory
- Accurate bulk properties of nuclei from to from potentials with isobars
- Ab-initio Gorkov-Green's function calculations of open-shell nuclei
- Bayesian truncation errors in chiral effective field theory: nucleon-nucleon observables
- Ab initio calculation of the spectrum and structure of O
- Uncertainty analysis and order-by-order optimization of chiral nuclear interactions
- Nuclear forces with Delta-excitations up to next-to-next-to-leading order I: peripheral nucleon-nucleon waves
- Radii and binding energies in oxygen isotopes: a puzzle for nuclear forces
- How short is too short? Constraining zero-range interactions in nucleon-nucleon scattering
- Regularization, renormalization and "peratization" in effective field theory for two nucleons
- On the correlation between the binding energies of the triton and the alpha-particle
- Corrections to nuclear energies and radii in finite oscillator spaces
- Global sensitivity analysis of bulk properties of an atomic nucleus
- Convergence properties of {\itshape ab initio} calculations of light nuclei in a harmonic oscillator basis
- A recipe for EFT uncertainty quantification in nuclear physics
- Bayesian parameter estimation for effective field theories
- Perturbative renormalizability of chiral two pion exchange in nucleon-nucleon scattering
- Renormalizing Chiral Nuclear Forces: Triplet Channels
- Effective Field Theory for Lattice Nuclei
- No-core shell model in an effective-field-theory framework
- Delta isobars and nuclear saturation
- Charge radii of exotic neon and magnesium isotopes
- Universal properties of infrared oscillator basis extrapolations
- Ground-State Properties of He and O Extrapolated from Lattice QCD with Pionless EFT
- Exploring Bayesian parameter estimation for chiral effective field theory using nucleon-nucleon phase shifts
- Essential elements for nuclear binding
- Perturbative Renormalizability of Chiral Two Pion Exchange in Nucleon-Nucleon Scattering: P- and D-waves
- Dominant contributions to the nucleon-nucleon interaction at sixth order of chiral perturbation theory
- Short-range nuclear forces in singlet channels
- Bayesian Methods for Parameter Estimation in Effective Field Theories
- Few- and many-nucleon systems with semilocal coordinate-space regularized chiral nucleon-nucleon forces
- Infrared length scale and extrapolations for the no-core shell model
- Renormalizing Chiral Nuclear Forces: A Case Study of 3P0
- Ab-initio approach to effective single-particle energies in doubly closed shell nuclei
- On the renormalization of the one-pion exchange potential and the consistency of Weinberg's power counting
- Pion-less effective field theory for atomic nuclei and lattice nuclei
- Deconstructing triplet nucleon-nucleon scattering
- Charge radii and electromagnetic moments of Li and Be isotopes from the ab initio no-core shell model
- How (not) to renormalize integral equations with singular potentials in effective field theory
- Universal Correlations in Pion-less EFT with the Resonating Group Model: Three and Four Nucleons
- Effective Theory of 3H and 3He
- Regulator Artifacts in Uniform Matter for Chiral Interactions
- Dimensional Power Counting in Nuclei
- Subtractive renormalization of the NN interaction in chiral effective theory up to next-to-next-to-leading order: S waves
- Wilsonian renormalization group versus subtractive renormalization in effective field theories for nucleon--nucleon scattering
- Subtractive renormalization of the chiral potentials up to next-to-next-to-leading order in higher NN partial waves
- Nuclear matter properties from local chiral interactions with isobar intermediate states
- Spectra and Scattering of Light Lattice Nuclei from Effective Field Theory
- Large-scale exact diagonalizations reveal low-momentum scales of nuclei
- Infrared extrapolations for atomic nuclei
- Role of final state interaction and of three-body force on the longitudinal response function of 4He
- Power Counting in Peripheral Partial Waves: The Singlet Channels
- The Two-Nucleon 1S0 Amplitude Zero in Chiral Effective Field Theory
- Ground State Wave Functions in the Hyperspherical Formalism for Nuclei with A > 4
- Perturbative scattering in chiral effective field theory
- Infinite-cutoff renormalization of the chiral nucleon-nucleon interaction at N3LO
- Improved convergence of chiral effective field theory for 1S0 of NN scattering
- How to renormalize integral equations with singular potentials in effective field theory
- The exact discontinuity of a partial wave along the left-hand cut and the exact method in non-relativistic scattering
- Chiral potential renormalized in harmonic-oscillator space
- Do we know how to count powers in pionless and pionful effective field theory?
- The N/D method with non-perturbative left-hand-cut discontinuity and the partial wave
- A Consistency Test of EFT Power Countings from Residual Cutoff Dependence
- Description of light nuclei in pionless effective field theory using the stochastic variational method
- Comment on "How (not) to renormalize integral equations with singular potentials in effective field theory"
- Wilsonian renormalization group and the Lippmann-Schwinger equation with a multitude of cutoff parameters
- Reply to "Comment on "How (not) to renormalize integral equations with singular potentials in effective field theory"
- Multi-fermion systems with contact theories
- Perturbative chiral nucleon-nucleon potential for the partial wave
- Improved description of light nuclei through chiral effective field theory at leading order
- Scattering amplitudes versus potentials in nuclear effective field theory: search for a potential compromise
- Assessing Theory Uncertainties in EFT Power Countings from Residual Cutoff Dependence
Cited by in corpus (28)
- What is ab initio in nuclear theory?
- Nuclear Forces for Precision Nuclear Physics -- a collection of perspectives
- Towards Precise and Accurate Calculations of Neutrinoless Double-Beta Decay: Project Scoping Workshop Report
- Fast & rigorous predictions for nuclei with Bayesian posterior sampling
- Bayesian parameter estimation in EFT using Hamiltonian Monte Carlo
- Nuclear Effective Field Theories: Reverberations of the early days
- Nuclear Structure at the Crossroads
- A Bayesian mixture model approach to quantifying the empirical nuclear saturation point
- Constructing chiral effective field theory around unnatural leading-order interactions
- Inference of the low-energy constants in -full chiral effective field theory including a correlated truncation error
- What Can Possibly Go Wrong?
- Bayesian Analysis of EFT at Leading Order in a Modified Weinberg Power Counting Approach
- Second-Order Perturbation Theory in Continuum Quantum Monte Carlo Calculations
- Two-pion exchange as a leading-order contribution in chiral effective field theory
- Perturbative Calculations of Deuteron Form Factors
- Greedy Emulators for Nuclear Two-Body Scattering
- Perturbative computations of neutron-proton scattering observables using renormalization-group invariant EFT up to NLO
- A further study on the renormalization group aspect of perturbative corrections
- Effective field theory with resonant P-wave interaction
- Renormalization of One-Pion Exchange in Chiral Effective Field Theory for Antinucleon-Nucleon Scattering
- Low-energy theorems for neutron-proton scattering in EFT using a perturbative power counting
- Calculations for nuclear matter and finite nuclei within and beyond energy--density--functional theories through interactions guided by effective field theory
- Feasibility of perturbative generation of bound-states from resonances or virtual states
- Perturbative EFT calculations of the deuteron and triton up to NLO
- Cutoff effects in Hartree-Fock calculations at leading order of chiral effective field theory
- Bayesian method for fitting the low-energy constants in chiral perturbation theory
- Auxiliary counterterms and their role in effective field theory
- Improved Actions for Nuclear Effective Field Theories