A Consistency Test of EFT Power Countings from Residual Cutoff Dependence

Abstract

A method to quantitatively assess the consistency of power-counting proposals in Effective Field Theories (EFT) which are non-perturbative at leading order is presented. The Renormalisation Group evolution of an observable predicts the functional form of its residual cutoff dependence on the breakdown scale of an EFT, on the low-momentum scales, and on the order of the calculation. Passing this test is a necessary but not sufficient consistency criterion for a suggested power counting whose exact nature is disputed. In Chiral Effective Field Theory (ChiEFT) with more than one nucleon, a lack of universally accepted analytic solutions obfuscates the convergence pattern in results. This led to proposals which predict different sets of Low Energy Coefficients (LECs) at the same chiral order, and at times even predict a different ordering long-range contributions. The method may independently check whether an observable is renormalised at a given order, and proves estimates of both the breakdown scale and the momentum-dependent order-by-order convergence pattern. Conversely, it helps identify those LECs (and long-range pieces) which ensure renormalised observables at a given order. I also discuss assumptions and the relation to Wilson's Renormalisation Group; useful observable and cutoff choices; the momentum window with likely best signals; its dependence on the values and forms of cutoffs as well as on the EFT parameters; the impact of fitting LECs to data; and caveats as well as limitations. Since the test is designed to minimise the use of data, it quantitatively falsifies if the EFT has been renormalised consistently. This complements other tests which quantify how an EFT compares to experiment. Its application in particular to the 3P0 and P2-3F2 partial waves of NN scattering in ChiEFT may elucidate persistent power-counting issues.

arXiv comment15 pages LaTeX2e (pdflatex) including 5 figures as .pdf files using includegraphics. Final version to appear in Europ. J. Phys. A topical issue "The Tower of Effective (Field) Theories and the Emergence of Nuclear Phenomena". arXiv admin note: substantial text overlap with arXiv:1511.00490 Author's note: substantial corrections in key argument and expansions. Version appearing in Eur Phys J A

References in corpus (48)

• Universality in Few-body Systems with Large Scattering Length
• Asymptotic expansion of Feynman integrals near threshold
• Effective Field Theory for Few-Nucleon Systems
• A New Expansion for Nucleon-Nucleon Interactions
• Two-Nucleon Systems from Effective Field Theory
• Improved chiral nucleon-nucleon potential up to next-to-next-to-next-to-leading order
• Renormalization of One-Pion Exchange and Power Counting
• Nucleon-Nucleon Scattering from Effective Field Theory
• Quantifying truncation errors in effective field theory
• NNLO Corrections to Nucleon-Nucleon Scattering and Perturbative Pions
• Generalized Dimensional Analysis
• Nuclear forces in the chiral limit
• Power counting with one-pion exchange
• Low Energy Expansion in the Three Body System to All Orders and the Triton Channel
• The Quark-Mass Dependence of Two-Nucleon Systems
• Regularization, renormalization and "peratization" in effective field theory for two nucleons
• Improving the Convergence of NN Effective Field Theory
• A recipe for EFT uncertainty quantification in nuclear physics
• Perturbative renormalizability of chiral two pion exchange in nucleon-nucleon scattering
• Renormalizing Chiral Nuclear Forces: Triplet Channels
• Improved Convergence in the Three-Nucleon System at Very Low Energies
• A renormalisation group approach to two-body scattering in the presence of long-range forces
• Nuclear Physics Around the Unitarity Limit
• Perturbative Renormalizability of Chiral Two Pion Exchange in Nucleon-Nucleon Scattering: P- and D-waves
• Short-range nuclear forces in singlet channels
• Naive Dimensional Analysis for Three-Body Forces Without Pions
• Low-Energy Universality in Atomic and Nuclear Physics
• On the renormalization of the one-pion exchange potential and the consistency of Weinberg's power counting
• Fully Perturbative Calculation of $nd$ Scattering to Next-to-next-to-leading-order
• Deconstructing triplet nucleon-nucleon scattering
• Antinucleon-nucleon interaction at next-to-next-to-next-to-leading order in chiral effective field theory
• Perturbative nuclear physics
• Correlations imposed by the unitary limit between few-nucleon systems, nuclear matter and neutron stars
• Threshold Expansion and Dimensionally Regularised NRQCD
• The Three-Boson System at Next-To-Next-To-Leading Order
• Power Counting and Wilsonian Renormalization in Nuclear Effective Field Theory
• Removing Pions from Two-Nucleon Effective Field Theory
• Effective Field Theory Analysis of Three-Boson Systems at Next-To-Next-To-Leading Order
• Regularization Methods for Nucleon-Nucleon Effective Field Theory
• Parity-violating neutron spin rotation in hydrogen and deuterium
• The Long and Short of Nuclear Effective Field Theory Expansions
• On Parity-Violating Three-Nucleon Interactions and the Predictive Power of Few-Nucleon EFT at Very Low Energies
• Deconstructing 1S0 nucleon-nucleon scattering
• Efimov physics with $1/2$ spin-isospin fermions
• Second-order perturbation theory for 3He and pd scattering in pionless EFT
• Do we know how to count powers in pionless and pionful effective field theory?
• Parity-Violating Three Nucleon Interactions at Low Energies and Large-$N_C$
• Effective short-range interaction for spin-singlet P-wave nucleon-nucleon scattering

Cited by in corpus (15)

• New Ideas in Constraining Nuclear Forces
• Power counting in chiral effective field theory and nuclear binding
• Five-body calculation of $s$-wave $n$-${}^4$He scattering at next-to-leading order pionless effective field theory
• What Can Possibly Go Wrong?
• An alternative scheme for effective range corrections in pionless EFT
• Nature of the $\Lambda nn$ $(J^{\pi }=1/2^{+},I=1)$ and ${}_{\mathrm{\Lambda }}^3{\mathrm{H}}^{\ast }(J^{\pi }=3/2^{+},I=0)$ states
• Few nucleons scattering in pionless effective field theory
• Bayesian Analysis of $\chi$EFT at Leading Order in a Modified Weinberg Power Counting Approach
• Towards a power counting in nuclear energy-density-functional theories through a perturbative analysis
• A further study on the renormalization group aspect of perturbative corrections
• Calculations for nuclear matter and finite nuclei within and beyond energy--density--functional theories through interactions guided by effective field theory
• Reexamining the perturbative renormalizability of the coupled triplets
• Few-Nucleon Systems within Finite-Cutoff Pionless EFT
• Residual cut-off dependence and power counting: the deuteron as a case study
• Perturbative application of next-to-leading order pionless EFT for $A\le 3$ nuclei in a finite volume