On the accuracy of common moment-based radiative transfer methods for simulating reionization

Abstract

Cosmological simulations of reionization often treat radiative transfer by solving for the monopole and dipoles of the intensity field and by making ansatz for the quadrupole moments to close the system of equations. We investigate the accuracy of the most common closure methods, i.e. Eddington tensor choices. We argue that these algorithms are most likely to err after reionization and study quasi-analytic test problems mimicking these situations: large-scale post-reionization ionizing background fluctuations and radiative transfer in a predominantly ionized medium with discrete absorbers. We show that OTVET and M1 over-ionize self-shielding absorbers when fixing the background photoionization rate, leading to 30-40% higher emissivity to balance the increased recombination. This over-ionization results in a simulation run with these algorithms having a factor of ~2 lower average metagalactic photoionization rate relative to truth given an ionizing emissivity. Furthermore, these algorithms are unlikely to reproduce ionizing background fluctuations on scales below the photon mean path: OTVET tends to overpredict the fluctuations there when the simulation box is smaller than twice the mean free path and underpredict otherwise, while M1 drastically underpredicts these fluctuations. As a result, these numerical methods are likely not sufficiently accurate to interpret the Ly$\alpha$ forest opacity fluctuations observed after reionzation. We show that a high number of angular directions need to be followed to capture the post-reionization ionizing background fluctuations accurately with ray-tracing codes. Lastly, we argue that the strong dependence of the post-reionization ionizing background on the value of the reduced speed of light found in many simulations signals that the ionizing photon mean free path is several times larger in such simulations than the observationally measured value.

arXiv commentrevision 1, submitted to JCAP

References in corpus (91)

• Halo Models of Large Scale Structure
• Constraining the Evolution of the Ionizing Background and the Epoch of Reionization with z ~ 6 Quasars II: A Sample of 19 Quasars
• Model-independent evidence in favor of an end to reionization by z~6
• On the evolution of the HI column density distribution in cosmological simulations
• Reionization of the Inhomogeneous Universe
• Evidence of patchy hydrogen reionization from an extreme Ly$\alpha$ trough below redshift six
• Simulating Cosmic Reionization at Large Scales I: the Geometry of Reionization
• The morphology of HII regions during reionization
• RAMSES-RT: Radiation hydrodynamics in the cosmological context
• Simulations and Analytic Calculations of Bubble Growth During Hydrogen Reionization
• On the (Non)Evolution of HI Disks over Cosmic Time
• New Measurements of the Ionizing Ultraviolet Background over 2 < z < 5 and Implications for Hydrogen Reionization
• The SPHINX Cosmological Simulations of the First Billion Years: the Impact of Binary Stars on Reionization
• Multi--dimensional Cosmological Radiative Transfer with a Variable Eddington Tensor Formalism
• Large Lyman-alpha opacity fluctuations and low CMB tau in models of late reionization with large islands of neutral hydrogen extending to z<5.5
• The Power Spectrum of Mass Fluctuations Measured from the Lyman-alpha Forest at Redshift z=2.5
• Radiative transfer simulations of cosmic reionization I: methodology and initial results
• C^2-Ray: A new method for photon-conserving transport of ionizing radiation
• Cosmological Radiative Transfer Codes Comparison Project I: The Static Density Field Tests
• Taxing the Rich: Recombinations and Bubble Growth During Reionization
• Cosmic Dawn (CoDa): the First Radiation-Hydrodynamics Simulation of Reionization and Galaxy Formation in the Local Universe
• Comparison Of Reionization Models: Radiative Transfer Simulations And Approximate, Semi-Numeric Models
• Simulating Cosmic Reionization at Large Scales II: the 21-cm Emission Features and Statistical Signals
• A scheme for radiation pressure and photon diffusion with the M1 closure in RAMSES-RT
• New constraints on Lyman-α opacity with a sample of 62 quasars at z > 5.7
• The Giant Gemini GMOS survey of z>4.4 quasars - I. Measuring the mean free path across cosmic time
• Enzo+Moray: Radiation Hydrodynamics Adaptive Mesh Refinement Simulations with Adaptive Ray Tracing
• Inhomogeneous recombinations during cosmic reionization
• Long troughs in the Lyman-$\alpha$ forest below redshift 6 due to islands of neutral hydrogen
• The Neutral Hydrogen Cosmological Mass Density at z=5
• On Lyman-limit Systems and the Evolution of the Intergalactic Ionizing Background
• A radiative transfer scheme for cosmological reionization based on a local Eddington tensor
• Adaptive Ray Tracing for Radiative Transfer around Point Sources
• Large Fluctuations in the High-Redshift Metagalactic Ionizing Background
• Large fluctuations in the hydrogen-ionizing background and mean free path following the epoch of reionization
• Physical effects on the Lyman-alpha forest flux power spectrum: damping wings, ionizing radiation fluctuations, and galactic winds
• Near-zone sizes and the rest frame extreme ultra-violet spectral index of the highest redshift quasars
• Imprint of Inhomogeneous Hydrogen Reionization on the Temperature Distribution of the Intergalactic Medium
• Gas Clumping in Self-Consistent Reionisation Models
• Cosmological Radiative Transfer Comparison Project II: The Radiation-Hydrodynamic Tests
• Observing the tail of reionization: neutral islands in the $z=5.5$ Lyman-$\alpha$ Forest
• AREPO-RT: Radiation hydrodynamics on a moving mesh
• Ionizing radiation fluctuations and large-scale structure in the Lyman-alpha forest
• TRAPHIC - Radiative Transfer for Smoothed Particle Hydrodynamics Simulations
• Reionization simulations powered by GPUs I: the structure of the Ultraviolet radiation field
• The effects of UV background correlations on LyA forest flux statistics
• Large scale opacity fluctuations in the Lyman alpha forest: evidence for QSOs dominating the ionising UV background at z ~ 5.5-6 ?
• Predictions for the relation between strong HI absorbers and galaxies at redshift 3
• An implementation of radiative transfer in the cosmological simulation code GADGET
• Probing reionization with LOFAR using 21-cm redshift space distortions
• Reionization on Large Scales III: Predictions for Low-ell Cosmic Microwave Background Polarization and High-ell Kinetic Sunyaev-Zel'dovich Observables
• Galactic Outflows and Photoionization Heating in the Reionization Epoch
• Reionization in Technicolor
• Scale-dependent bias in the BAO-scale intergalactic neutral hydrogen
• Computer Simulations of Cosmic Reionization
• Hydrodynamic Response of the Intergalactic Medium to Reionization
• On the effect of the ionising background on the Lyα forest autocorrelation function
• Direct Numerical Simulation of Reionization II: Recombinations, Clumping Factors, and the Photon Budget for Reionization
• Spatial fluctuations of the intergalactic temperature-density relation after hydrogen reionization
• Multi-frequency, thermally coupled radiative transfer with TRAPHIC: Method and tests
• Hydrogen Reionization in the Illustris universe
• Self-shielding Effects on the Column Density Distribution of Damped Lyman Alpha Systems
• A New Moment Method for Continuum Radiative Transfer in Cosmological Reionization
• Statistical properties of damped Lyman-alpha systems from Sloan Digital Sky Survey DR12
• EMMA: an AMR cosmological simulation code with radiative transfer
• Constraining the second half of reionization with the Lyman-$\beta$ forest
• The Acoustic Peak in the Lyman Alpha Forest
• The ionizing background at the end of overlap
• Inhomogeneous Reionization Models in Cosmological Hydrodynamical Simulations
• The Late Reionization of Filaments
• Imprints of temperature fluctuations on the $z\sim 5$ Lyman-$\alpha$ forest: a view from radiation-hydrodynamic simulations of reionization
• The Inhomogeneous Ionizing Background Following Reionization
• Cosmic Reionization On Computers. Properties of the Post-reionization IGM
• Simulations of galaxy formation with radiative transfer: Hydrogen reionization and radiative feedback
• The observable 21cm signal from reionization may be perturbative
• Neutral island statistics during reionization from 21-cm tomography
• The impact of inhomogeneous subgrid clumping on cosmic reionization
• Self-shielding of hydrogen in the IGM during the epoch of reionization
• Simulating the effect of photoheating feedback during reionization
• Modelling the cosmic neutral hydrogen from DLAs and 21 cm observations
• A novel approach for accurate radiative transfer in cosmological hydrodynamic simulations
• A Census of the LyC Photons that Form the UV Background During Reionization
• The case against large intensity fluctuations in the z ~ 2.5 HeII Lyman-alpha forest
• The Effects of Lyman-Limit Systems on the Evolution and Observability of the Epoch of Reionization
• On the Proper Use of the Reduced Speed of Light Approximation
• ARTIST: Fast radiative transfer for large-scale simulations of the epoch of reionisation
• The influence of metagalactic ultra-violet background fluctuations on the high-redshift Ly$\alpha$ forest
• A tale of seven narrow spikes and a long trough: constraining the timing of the percolation of HII bubbles at the tail-end of reionization with ULAS J1120+0641
• Time-dependent fluctuations in the metagalactic photoionization background
• Revised estimates of CMB $B$-mode polarization induced by patchy reionization
• The Flatness and Sudden Evolution of the Intergalactic Ionizing Background

Cited by in corpus (8)

• Unveiling Dark Matter free-streaming at the smallest scales with high redshift Lyman-alpha forest
• A short mean free path at $z=6$ favors late and rapid reionization by faint galaxies
• Lyman-alpha opacities at z=4-6 require low mass, radiatively-suppressed galaxies to drive cosmic reionization
• Reionization with Simba: How much does astrophysics matter in modeling cosmic reionization?
• Late-end reionization with ATON-HE: towards constraints from Lyman-$\alpha$ emitters observed with JWST
• The impact and response of minihalos and the inter-halo medium on cosmic reionization
• Measuring photo-ionization rate and mean free path of HeII ionizing photons at $2.5\le z\le 3.6$: Evidence for late and rapid HeII reionization Part-II
• The 21-cm signature of X-ray heated halos around galaxies during cosmic dawn