Gravitational-wave versus X-ray tests of strong-field gravity

Abstract

Electromagnetic observations of the radiation emitted by an accretion disk around a black hole, as well as gravitational wave observations of coalescing binaries, can be used to probe strong-field gravity. We here compare the constraints that these two types of observations can impose on theory-agnostic, parametric deviations from the Schwarzschild metric. On the gravitational wave side, we begin by computing the leading-order deviation to the Hamiltonian of a binary system in a quasi-circular orbit within the post-Newtonian approximation, given a parametric deformation of the Schwarzschild metrics of each binary component. We then compute the leading-order deviation to the gravitational waves emitted by such a binary in the frequency domain, assuming purely Einsteinian radiation-reaction. We compare this model to the LIGO-Virgo collaboration gravitational wave detections and place constraints on the metric deformation parameters, concluding with an estimate of the constraining power of aLIGO at design sensitivity. On the electromagnetic side, we first simulate observations with current and future X-ray instruments of an X-ray binary with a parametrically-deformed Schwarzschild black hole, and we then estimate constraints on the deformation parameters using these observations.We find that current gravitational wave observations have already placed constraints on the metric deformation parameters than are slightly more stringent than what can be achieved with current X-ray instruments. Moreover, future gravitational wave observations with aLIGO at design sensitivity by 2026 will be even more stringent, becoming stronger than constraints achievable with future ATHENA X-ray observations before it flies in 2034.

arXiv comment13 pages, 6 figures, updated to match published version

References in corpus (47)

• First M87 Event Horizon Telescope Results. I. The Shadow of the Supermassive Black Hole
• The Confrontation between General Relativity and Experiment
• GWTC-1: A Gravitational-Wave Transient Catalog of Compact Binary Mergers Observed by LIGO and Virgo during the First and Second Observing Runs
• X-ray Properties of Black-Hole Binaries
• Effective one-body approach to general relativistic two-body dynamics
• Frequency-domain gravitational waves from non-precessing black-hole binaries. II. A phenomenological model for the advanced detector era
• Testing the nature of dark compact objects: a status report
• Tests of General Relativity with the Binary Black Hole Signals from the LIGO-Virgo Catalog GWTC-1
• Frequency-domain gravitational waves from non-precessing black-hole binaries. I. New numerical waveforms and anatomy of the signal
• A simple model of complete precessing black-hole-binary gravitational waveforms
• Chern-Simons Modified General Relativity
• Theoretical Physics Implications of the Binary Black-Hole Mergers GW150914 and GW151226
• The PyCBC search for gravitational waves from compact binary coalescence
• Fundamental Theoretical Bias in Gravitational Wave Astrophysics and the Parameterized Post-Einsteinian Framework
• Gravitational Wave Tests of General Relativity with Ground-Based Detectors and Pulsar Timing Arrays
• Testing the No-Hair Theorem with Observations in the Electromagnetic Spectrum: II. Black-Hole Images
• Testing the no-hair theorem with GW150914
• Probes and Tests of Strong-Field Gravity with Observations in the Electromagnetic Spectrum
• Dynamical Chern-Simons Modified Gravity I: Spinning Black Holes in the Slow-Rotation Approximation
• Testing black hole candidates with electromagnetic radiation
• Non-Spinning Black Holes in Alternative Theories of Gravity
• New parametrization for spherically symmetric black holes in metric theories of gravity
• Testing the No-Hair Theorem with Event Horizon Telescope Observations of Sagittarius A*
• Bayesian model selection for testing the no-hair theorem with black hole ringdowns
• Poincaré invariance in the ADM Hamiltonian approach to the general relativistic two-body problem
• Linking Tests of Gravity On All Scales: from the Strong-Field Regime to Cosmology
• Testing the binary black hole nature of a compact binary coalescence
• Testing the Kerr black hole hypothesis using X-ray reflection spectroscopy
• Testing the no-hair theorem with black hole ringdowns using TIGER
• Testing General Relativity using Bayesian model selection: Applications to observations of gravitational waves from compact binary systems
• Foundations of an effective-one-body model for coalescing binaries on eccentric orbits
• Testing the no-hair theorem with the continuum-fitting and the iron line methods: a short review
• Black Hole Solutions in String Theory with Gauss-Bonnet Curvature Correction
• Testing general relativity with the reflection spectrum of the supermassive black hole in 1H0707$-$495
• A NICER Spectrum of MAXI J1535-571: Near-Maximal Black Hole Spin and Potential Disk Warping
• Public Release of RELXILL_NK: A Relativistic Reflection Model for Testing Einstein's Gravity
• Detection of Reflection Features in the Neutron Star Low-Mass X-ray Binary Serpens X-1 with NICER
• Testing the black hole no-hair theorem at the galactic center: Perturbing effects of stars in the surrounding cluster
• Constraints on the spacetime metric around seven "bare" AGNs using X-ray reflection spectroscopy
• Verifying the no-hair property of massive compact objects with intermediate-mass-ratio inspirals in advanced gravitational-wave detectors
• Challenges testing the no-hair theorem with gravitational waves
• A study of the strong gravity region of the black hole in GS 1354-645
• An evolving broad iron line from the first Galactic ultraluminous X-ray pulsar Swift J0243.6+6124
• NuSTAR and NICER reveal IGR J17591-2342 as a new accreting millisecond X-ray pulsar
• Testing the Kerr black hole hypothesis: comparison between the gravitational wave and the iron line approaches
• Inferring black hole spins and probing accretion/ejection flows in AGNs with the Athena X-ray Integral Field Unit
• Experimental Relativity with Accretion Disk Observations

Cited by in corpus (42)

• First Sagittarius A* Event Horizon Telescope Results. VI: Testing the Black Hole Metric
• New Horizons for Fundamental Physics with LISA
• Towards precision measurements of accreting black holes using X-ray reflection spectroscopy
• Improved gravitational-wave constraints on higher-order curvature theories of gravity
• EHT tests of the strong-field regime of General Relativity
• Spin-induced dynamical scalarization, de-scalarization and stealthness in scalar-Gauss-Bonnet gravity during black hole coalescence
• Testing General Relativity with NuSTAR data of Galactic Black Holes
• Adaptive Analytical Ray Tracing of Black Hole Photon Rings
• Bayesian Metric Reconstruction with Gravitational Wave Observations
• Universal signatures of singularity-resolving physics in photon rings of black holes and horizonless objects
• Spectral Method for the Gravitational Perturbations of Black Holes: Schwarzschild Background Case
• Probing the Black Hole Metric. I. Black Hole Shadows and Binary Black-Hole Inspirals
• Parameterizations of black-hole spacetimes beyond circularity
• Testing general relativity with the stellar-mass black hole in LMC X-1 using the continuum-fitting method
• Testing the Kerr black hole hypothesis with GRS 1716-249 by combining the continuum-fitting and the iron-line methods
• Testing General Relativity with X-ray reflection spectroscopy: The Konoplya-Rezzolla-Zhidenko parametrization
• Testing regular black holes with X-ray and GW data
• Testing the Kerr black hole hypothesis with the continuum-fitting and the iron line methods: the case of GRS 1915+105
• A parametrized quasi-normal mode framework for non-Schwarzschild metrics
• Testing General Relativity with black hole X-ray data: a progress report
• A Lensing-Band Approach to Spacetime Constraints
• Qualifying ringdown and shadow of black holes under general parametrized metrics with photon orbits
• Constraining the Konoplya-Rezzolla-Zhidenko deformation parameters II: limits from stellar-mass black hole X-ray data
• Toward General-Relativistic Magnetohydrodynamics Simulations in Stationary Non-Vacuum Spacetimes
• Testing horizon topology with electromagnetic observations
• Measuring deviations from the Kerr geometry with black hole ringdown
• Testing gravity with Extreme-Mass-Ratio Inspirals
• Constraining the KRZ deformation parameters I: limits from supermassive black hole X-ray data
• Non-Kerr Constraints using Binary Black Hole inspirals considering phase modifications up to 4 PN order
• Testing Gravity with Black Hole X-Ray Data
• Testing the $\delta$-Kerr metric with black hole X-ray data
• General relativistic viscous accretion flow around Konoplya-Zhidenko black hole
• X-Ray Tests of General Relativity with Black Holes
• Quasi-normal modes of slowly-rotating Johannsen black holes
• Testing beyond-Kerr spacetimes with GWTC-3
• Testing General Relativity with Black Hole X-ray Data
• Tests of General Relativity using black hole X-ray data
• Testing black hole metrics with binary black hole inspirals
• Generalized Perturbed Kepler Problem: Gravitational Wave Imprints from Eccentric Compact Binaries
• Improved Constraints on Non-Kerr Deviations from Binary Black Hole Inspirals Using GWTC-4 Data
• Testing the Kerr nature with binary black hole inspirals
• Constraining the Konoplya-Rezzolla-Zhidenko deformation parameters III: limits from stellar-mass black holes using gravitational-wave observations