The Trinity of Relational Quantum Dynamics

Abstract

The problem of time in quantum gravity calls for a relational solution. Using quantum reduction maps, we establish a previously unknown equivalence between three approaches to relational quantum dynamics: 1) relational observables in the clock-neutral picture of Dirac quantization, 2) Page and Wootters' (PW) Schrödinger picture formalism, and 3) the relational Heisenberg picture obtained via symmetry reduction. Constituting three faces of the same dynamics, we call this equivalence the trinity. We develop a quantization procedure for relational Dirac observables using covariant POVMs which encompass non-ideal clocks. The quantum reduction maps reveal this procedure as the quantum analog of gauge-invariantly extending gauge-fixed quantities. We establish algebraic properties of these relational observables. We extend a recent clock-neutral approach to changing temporal reference frames, transforming relational observables and states, and demonstrate a clock dependent temporal nonlocality effect. We show that Kuchař's criticism, alleging that the conditional probabilities of the PW formalism violate the constraint, is incorrect. They are a quantum analog of a gauge-fixed description of a gauge-invariant quantity and equivalent to the manifestly gauge-invariant evaluation of relational observables in the physical inner product. The trinity furthermore resolves a previously reported normalization ambiguity and clarifies the role of entanglement in the PW formalism. The trinity finally permits us to resolve Kuchař's criticism that the PW formalism yields wrong propagators by showing how conditional probabilities of relational observables give the correct transition probabilities. Unlike previous proposals, our resolution does not invoke approximations, ideal clocks or ancilla systems, is manifestly gauge-invariant, and easily extends to an arbitrary number of conditionings.

38+15 pages, 6 figures, simplified notation, some simplified results, addressed Unruh's and Wald's non-monotonicity issue of realistic quantum clocks, expanded comparison with previous proposals for resolving Kuchar's criticisms, references updated

References in corpus (82)

• The Dynamics of General Relativity
• Loop Quantum Cosmology: A Status Report
• Reference frames, superselection rules, and quantum information
• Generalized uncertainty relations: Theory, examples, and Lorentz invariance
• Quantum Nature of the Big Bang: An Analytical and Numerical Investigation
• Extending Noether's theorem by quantifying the asymmetry of quantum states
• Partial and Complete Observables for Hamiltonian Constrained Systems
• Quantum mechanics and the covariance of physical laws in quantum reference frames
• Partial and Complete Observables for Canonical General Relativity
• Observables in effective gravity
• The theory of manipulations of pure state asymmetry: basic tools and equivalence classes of states under symmetric operations
• Time and a physical Hamiltonian for quantum gravity
• Three dimensional loop quantum gravity: physical scalar product and spin foam models
• Quantum Time
• Quantum Observables and Recollapsing Dynamics
• Algebraic Quantum Gravity (AQG) IV. Reduced Phase Space Quantisation of Loop Quantum Gravity
• Introduction to Loop Quantum Cosmology
• Gravity quantized
• Reduced Phase Space Quantization and Dirac Observables
• Conditional probabilities with Dirac observables and the problem of time in quantum gravity
• Time from quantum entanglement: an experimental illustration
• A change of perspective: switching quantum reference frames via a perspective-neutral framework
• An effective approach to the problem of time
• Effective approach to the problem of time: general features and examples
• Quantum clocks and the temporal localisability of events in the presence of gravitating quantum systems
• Relational Observables in Gravity: a Review
• Fundamental decoherence from quantum gravity: a pedagogical review
• Quantizing time: Interacting clocks and systems
• The WAY theorem and the quantum resource theory of asymmetry
• Quantum clocks observe classical and quantum time dilation
• Switching internal times and a new perspective on the 'wave function of the universe'
• Are the spectra of geometrical operators in Loop Quantum Gravity really discrete?
• Quantum communication using a bounded-size quantum reference frame
• Revisiting observables in generally covariant theories in the light of gauge fixing methods
• A perturbative approach to Dirac observables and their space-time algebra
• Physics within a quantum reference frame
• Realistic clocks, universal decoherence and the black hole information paradox
• Equivalence of approaches to relational quantum dynamics in relativistic settings
• Relativistic quantum reference frames: the operational meaning of spin
• Almost Ideal Clocks in Quantum Cosmology: A Brief Derivation of Time
• Evolution without evolution, and without ambiguities
• Comparing Formulations of Generalized Quantum Mechanics for Reparametrization-Invariant Systems
• Symmetry, Reference Frames, and Relational Quantities in Quantum Mechanics
• Entanglement of quantum clocks through gravity
• Relational physics with real rods and clocks and the measurement problem of quantum mechanics
• Changing quantum reference frames
• Effective relational dynamics of a nonintegrable cosmological model
• Chaos in Quantum Cosmology
• Minisuperspaces: Observables and Quantization
• How to switch between relational quantum clocks
• Switching quantum reference frames in the N-body problem and the absence of global relational perspectives
• Gauge invariant perturbations around symmetry reduced sectors of general relativity: applications to cosmology
• Time in quantum physics: From an external parameter to an intrinsic observable
• Can chaos be observed in quantum gravity?
• Refined Algebraic Quantization: Systems with a single constraint
• Simplest cosmological model with the scalar field
• Quantum constraints, Dirac observables and evolution: group averaging versus Schroedinger picture in LQC
• Physical time and other conceptual issues of QG on the example of LQC
• Construction of quantum Dirac observables and the emergence of WKB time
• Quantum reference frames associated with non-compact groups: the case of translations and boosts, and the role of mass
• Generalized probability rules from a timeless formulation of Wigner's friend scenarios
• History state formalism for scalar particles
• Constraint analysis for variational discrete systems
• Reduced Loop Quantization with four Klein-Gordon Scalar Fields as Reference Matter
• Group Averaging and Refined Algebraic Quantization: Where are we now?
• Optimal estimation of squeezing
• Multiple-event probability in general-relativistic quantum mechanics
• The Pauli objection
• Relative Quantum Time
• Universal quantum modifications to general relativistic time dilation in delocalised clocks
• History states of systems and operators
• The Conditional Probability Interpretation of the Hamiltonian Constraint
• An operational approach to spacetime symmetries: Lorentz transformations from quantum communication
• The Construction Interpretation: Conceptual Roads to Quantum Gravity
• Quantum parameter estimation with imperfect reference frames
• An axiomatic formulation of the Montevideo interpretation of quantum mechanics
• Relational time in anyonic systems
• Communicating without shared reference frames
• Quantization of dynamical symplectic reduction
• Chaos, Dirac observables and constraint quantization
• Massive Unruh particles cannot be directly observed
• Implementation of the Quantum Equivalence Principle

Cited by in corpus (112)

• Singularity resolution depends on the clock
• Equivalence of approaches to relational quantum dynamics in relativistic settings
• How to switch between relational quantum clocks
• Quantum Relativity of Subsystems
• Switching quantum reference frames in the N-body problem and the absence of global relational perspectives
• Unitarity, clock dependence and quantum recollapse in quantum cosmology
• Edge modes as reference frames and boundary actions from post-selection
• Quantum reference frame transformations as symmetries and the paradox of the third particle
• Quantum reference frames, measurement schemes and the type of local algebras in quantum field theory
• Edge modes as dynamical frames: charges from post-selection in generally covariant theories
• Optimal Universal Quantum Error Correction via Bounded Reference Frames
• Quantum Mechanics from Relational Properties, Part I: Basic Formulation
• Internal quantum reference frames for finite Abelian groups
• Relational observables, reference frames, and conditional probabilities
• Non-covariance of the dressed-metric approach in loop quantum cosmology
• Quantum dynamics of the black hole interior in LQC
• Quantum fluctuations in the effective relational GFT cosmology
• Noncausal Page-Wootters circuits
• Second-quantized Unruh-DeWitt detectors and their quantum reference frame transformations
• Phantom-like dark energy from quantum gravity
• Effective dynamics of scalar cosmological perturbations from quantum gravity
• Non-inertial quantum clock frames lead to non-Hermitian dynamics
• Quantum Null Geometry and Gravity
• Quantum Reference Frames at the Boundary of Spacetime
• Operational Quantum Reference Frame Transformations
• Time Observables in a Timeless Universe
• Quantum reference frames for an indefinite metric
• Geometric Event-Based Relativistic Quantum Mechanics
• Hamiltonian group field theory with multiple scalar matter fields
• Identification is Pointless: Quantum Coordinates, Localisation of Events, and the Quantum Hole Argument
• Flow of time during energy measurements and the resulting time-energy uncertainty relations
• Entanglement-asymmetry correspondence for internal quantum reference frames
• Inference of gravitational field superposition from quantum measurements
• Edge modes without edge modes
• A relational perspective on the Wigner-Araki-Yanase theorem
• Frozen formalism and canonical quantization in group field theory
• Big Bang Singularity Resolution In Quantum Cosmology
• A model of quantum spacetime
• Embedding cyclic information-theoretic structures in acyclic spacetimes: no-go results for indefinite causality
• A gravitationally induced decoherence model using Ashtekar variables
• The time-energy uncertainty relation for quantum events
• On consistent gauge fixing conditions in polymerized gravitational systems
• Visions in Quantum Gravity
• Relational evolution with oscillating clocks
• Watching the Clocks: Interpreting the Page-Wootters Formalism and the Internal Quantum Reference Frame Programme
• Peaceful coexistence of thermal equilibrium and the emergence of time
• Spacetime quantum and classical mechanics with dynamical foliation
• Quantum conformal symmetries for spacetimes in superposition
• Quantum generalisation of Einstein's Equivalence Principle can be verified with entangled clocks as quantum reference frames
• Scalar Cosmological Perturbations from Quantum Entanglement within Lorentzian Quantum Gravity
• Robustness of the Page-Wootters construction across different pictures, states of the universe and system-clock interactions
• Quantum Reference Frames for Lorentz Symmetry
• Measurement events relative to temporal quantum reference frames
• Indefinite causal order and quantum coordinates
• Crossed products and quantum reference frames: on the observer-dependence of gravitational entropy
• Scalar Cosmological Perturbations from Quantum Gravitational Entanglement
• Beyond semiclassical time
• The solution to the problem of time in quantum gravity also solves the time of arrival problem in quantum mechanics
• Minimal Areas from Entangled Matrices
• The sum of entanglement and subsystem coherence is invariant under quantum reference frame transformations
• Nonrelativistic spatiotemporal quantum reference frames
• Path Integrals from Spacetime Quantum Actions
• Comparing Quantum Gravity Models: String Theory, Loop Quantum Gravity, and Entanglement gravity versus $SU(\infty )$-QGR
• Cosmology in Lorentzian Regge calculus: causality violations, massless scalar field and discrete dynamics
• Tabletop Experiments for Quantum Gravity Are Also Tests of the Interpretation of Quantum Mechanics
• Measuring time in a timeless universe
• Perspective-neutral approach to quantum frame covariance for general symmetry groups
• "Time"-covariant Schrödinger equation and the canonical quantization of the Reissner-Nordström black hole
• Dynamical diffeomorphisms
• Relational dynamics and Page-Wootters formalism in group field theory
• Making a Quantum Universe: Symmetry and Gravity
• An algebraic approach to the "frozen formalism" problem of time
• Geometrogenesis in GFT: An Analysis
• Universality of quantum time dilation
• Quantum Schwarzschild-(A)dS Black Holes: Unitarity and Singularity Resolution
• Parallel-in-time quantum simulation via Page and Wootters quantum time
• Emergent Time and Time Travel in Quantum Physics
• Spherically-symmetric geometries in a matter reference frame as quantum gravity condensates
• Law of Total Probability in Quantum Theory and Its Application in Wigner's Friend Scenario
• Analyzing quantum gravity spillover in the semiclassical regime
• Algebraic properties of quantum reference frames: Does time fluctuate?
• Simultaneous symmetry breaking in spontaneous Floquet states: temporal Floquet-Nambu-Goldstone modes, Floquet thermodynamics, and the time operator
• Quantum Time and the Time-Dilation induced Interaction Transfer mechanism
• $SU(\infty )$ Quantum Gravity and Cosmology
• Hilbert space formalisms for group field theory
• Exact path integrals on half-line in quantum cosmology with a fluid clock and aspects of operator ordering ambiguity
• Freeze-free cosmological evolution with a non-monotonic internal clock
• Quantum Gravity, Hydrodynamics and Emergent Cosmology: A Collection of Perspectives
• Quantum Mechanics from Relational Properties, Part III: Path Integral Implementation
• Relational Dynamics with Periodic Clocks
• Searching for a physical description relative to a quantum system
• Time dilation of quantum clocks in a relativistic gravitational potential
• Quantum Galilei group as quantum reference frame transformations
• Spacetime quantum mechanics for bosonic and fermionic systems
• (2+1) Lorentzian quantum cosmology from spin-foams: opportunities and obstacles for semi-classicality
• Linearization (in)stabilities and crossed products
• Quantum Euler angles and agency-dependent spacetime
• Barnich-Troessaert Bracket as a Dirac Bracket on the Covariant Phase Space
• Unveiling quantum complementarity tradeoffs in relativistic scenarios
• A spacetime-covariant approach to inertial and accelerated quantum clocks in first-quantization
• What can we do in a symmetry-constrained perspective? The importance of the total charge's status in quantum reference frame frameworks
• Gravitational null rays: Covariant Quantization and the Dressing Time
• Time Evolution in Quantum Mechanics with a Minimal Time Scale
• Quantum state of fields in $SU(\infty )$ Quantum Gravity ($SU(\infty )$-QGR)
• Energy Cost of Localization of Relational Quantum Information
• York time in JT gravity
• Quantum geometric tensor determines the pure-state i.i.d. conversion rate in the resource theory of asymmetry for any compact Lie group
• Does Quantum Mechanics Breed Larger, More Intricate Quantum Theories? The Case for Experience-Centric Quantum Theory and the Interactome of Quantum Theories
• Relational superposition measurements with a material quantum ruler
• Large effects from quantum reference frames
• Time-covariant Schrödinger equation and invariant decay probability: The $\Lambda$-Kantowski-Sachs universe
• Non-linear equation of motion for Page-Wootters mechanism with interaction and quasi-ideal clocks