Artificial Intelligence: the global landscape of ethics guidelines
arXiv:1906.11668 · doi:10.1038/s42256-019-0088-2
Abstract
In the last five years, private companies, research institutions as well as public sector organisations have issued principles and guidelines for ethical AI, yet there is debate about both what constitutes "ethical AI" and which ethical requirements, technical standards and best practices are needed for its realization. To investigate whether a global agreement on these questions is emerging, we mapped and analyzed the current corpus of principles and guidelines on ethical AI. Our results reveal a global convergence emerging around five ethical principles (transparency, justice and fairness, non-maleficence, responsibility and privacy), with substantive divergence in relation to how these principles are interpreted; why they are deemed important; what issue, domain or actors they pertain to; and how they should be implemented. Our findings highlight the importance of integrating guideline-development efforts with substantive ethical analysis and adequate implementation strategies.
arXiv comment42 pages (incl. figures and supplementary information)
Cited by in corpus (207)
- Principles alone cannot guarantee ethical AI
- The Ethics of AI Ethics -- An Evaluation of Guidelines
- Trust in AI and Its Role in the Acceptance of AI Technologies
- ChatGPT and a New Academic Reality: Artificial Intelligence-Written Research Papers and the Ethics of the Large Language Models in Scholarly Publishing
- Decolonial AI: Decolonial Theory as Sociotechnical Foresight in Artificial Intelligence
- Artificial Intelligence, Values and Alignment
- The Ethics of ChatGPT in Medicine and Healthcare: A Systematic Review on Large Language Models (LLMs)
- A Systematic Literature Review of User Trust in AI-Enabled Systems: An HCI Perspective
- Worldwide AI Ethics: a review of 200 guidelines and recommendations for AI governance
- Where Responsible AI meets Reality: Practitioner Perspectives on Enablers for shifting Organizational Practices
- The Fallacy of AI Functionality
- Lessons from Archives: Strategies for Collecting Sociocultural Data in Machine Learning
- Human-Centred Learning Analytics and AI in Education: a Systematic Literature Review
- A Clarification of the Nuances in the Fairness Metrics Landscape
- Auditing large language models: a three-layered approach
- The Flaws of Policies Requiring Human Oversight of Government Algorithms
- GenAI Against Humanity: Nefarious Applications of Generative Artificial Intelligence and Large Language Models
- AI-Ethics by Design. Evaluating Public Perception on the Importance of Ethical Design Principles of AI
- Designing Interpretable ML System to Enhance Trust in Healthcare: A Systematic Review to Proposed Responsible Clinician-AI-Collaboration Framework
- Ethics-Based Auditing of Automated Decision-Making Systems: Nature, Scope, and Limitations
- A Review of Some Techniques for Inclusion of Domain-Knowledge into Deep Neural Networks
- Incorporating Domain Knowledge into Deep Neural Networks
- Modern Computing: Vision and Challenges
- Contemporary Symbolic Regression Methods and their Relative Performance
- Conformity Assessments and Post-market Monitoring: A Guide to the Role of Auditing in the Proposed European AI Regulation
- Auditing of AI: Legal, Ethical and Technical Approaches
- Rethinking Fairness: An Interdisciplinary Survey of Critiques of Hegemonic ML Fairness Approaches
- Meaningful human control: actionable properties for AI system development
- Mapping the Ethics of Generative AI: A Comprehensive Scoping Review
- Actionable Principles for Artificial Intelligence Policy: Three Pathways
- The Forgotten Margins of AI Ethics
- Dislocated Accountabilities in the AI Supply Chain: Modularity and Developers' Notions of Responsibility
- Exciting, Useful, Worrying, Futuristic: Public Perception of Artificial Intelligence in 8 Countries
- AI virtues -- The missing link in putting AI ethics into practice
- Operationalising AI governance through ethics-based auditing: An industry case study
- How Different Groups Prioritize Ethical Values for Responsible AI
- The Contestation of Tech Ethics: A Sociotechnical Approach to Technology Ethics in Practice
- Investigating How Practitioners Use Human-AI Guidelines: A Case Study on the People + AI Guidebook
- AI Ethics Principles in Practice: Perspectives of Designers and Developers
- Conservative AI and social inequality: Conceptualizing alternatives to bias through social theory
- Fairness and Bias in Algorithmic Hiring: a Multidisciplinary Survey
- Tackling Algorithmic Disability Discrimination in the Hiring Process: An Ethical, Legal and Technical Analysis
- Towards Accountability in the Use of Artificial Intelligence for Public Administrations
- On the Quest for Effectiveness in Human Oversight: Interdisciplinary Perspectives
- Responsible and Regulatory Conform Machine Learning for Medicine: A Survey of Challenges and Solutions
- AI Certification: Advancing Ethical Practice by Reducing Information Asymmetries
- Metrics for Dataset Demographic Bias: A Case Study on Facial Expression Recognition
- Ethics in the Software Development Process: From Codes of Conduct to Ethical Deliberation
- Twenty-Four Years of Empirical Research on Trust in AI: A Bibliometric Review of Trends, Overlooked Issues, and Future Directions
- The climate impact of ICT: A review of estimates, trends and regulations
- The illusion of artificial inclusion
- Behavioral Use Licensing for Responsible AI
- Filling gaps in trustworthy development of AI
- `It is currently hodgepodge'': Examining AI/ML Practitioners' Challenges during Co-production of Responsible AI Values
- The Conflict Between Explainable and Accountable Decision-Making Algorithms
- WEIRD FAccTs: How Western, Educated, Industrialized, Rich, and Democratic is FAccT?
- Certification Labels for Trustworthy AI: Insights From an Empirical Mixed-Method Study
- Pairing Conceptual Modeling with Machine Learning
- Human-Centered Responsible Artificial Intelligence: Current & Future Trends
- Will we ever have Conscious Machines?
- Towards an Ethical Framework in the Complex Digital Era
- A Rapid Review of Responsible AI frameworks: How to guide the development of ethical AI
- IEEE 7010: A New Standard for Assessing the Well-being Implications of Artificial Intelligence
- Warmth and competence in human-agent cooperation
- A Principles-based Ethics Assurance Argument Pattern for AI and Autonomous Systems
- Generative AI for Requirements Engineering: A Systematic Literature Review
- Towards a Privacy and Security-Aware Framework for Ethical AI: Guiding the Development and Assessment of AI Systems
- Inherent Limitations of AI Fairness
- Three lines of defense against risks from AI
- A Scoping Study of Evaluation Practices for Responsible AI Tools: Steps Towards Effectiveness Evaluations
- AI Regulation in the European Union: Examining Non-State Actor Preferences
- AI and Blackness: Towards moving beyond bias and representation
- Automated scholarly paper review: Concepts, technologies, and challenges
- Beyond principlism: Practical strategies for ethical AI use in research practices
- Studying the Transfer of Biases from Programmers to Programs
- Normative Challenges of Risk Regulation of Artificial Intelligence and Automated Decision-Making
- Characteristics of ChatGPT users from Germany: implications for the digital divide from web tracking data
- Bridging adaptive management and reinforcement learning for more robust decisions
- Out of Context: Investigating the Bias and Fairness Concerns of "Artificial Intelligence as a Service"
- Ethical Considerations and Statistical Analysis of Industry Involvement in Machine Learning Research
- How to Assess Trustworthy AI in Practice
- Blaming Humans and Machines: What Shapes People's Reactions to Algorithmic Harm
- The Digital Transformation in Health: How AI Can Improve the Performance of Health Systems
- Canada Protocol: an ethical checklist for the use of Artificial Intelligence in Suicide Prevention and Mental Health
- FATE in AI: Towards Algorithmic Inclusivity and Accessibility
- Implementing Responsible AI: Tensions and Trade-Offs Between Ethics Aspects
- Ever heard of ethical AI? Investigating the salience of ethical AI issues among the German population
- The Conflict Between People's Urge to Punish AI and Legal Systems
- Explainability Auditing for Intelligent Systems: A Rationale for Multi-Disciplinary Perspectives
- AI Challenges for Society and Ethics
- Using automated decision-making (ADM) to allocate Covid-19 vaccinations? Exploring the roles of trust and social group preference on the legitimacy of ADM vs. human decision-making
- Stronger Together: on the Articulation of Ethical Charters, Legal Tools, and Technical Documentation in ML
- Towards Implementing Responsible AI
- Human-centered trust framework: An HCI perspective
- A Review on Machine Learning for Neutrino Experiments
- Model extraction from counterfactual explanations
- Crossing the principle-practice gap in AI ethics with ethical problem-solving
- A Hippocratic Oath for mathematicians? Mapping the landscape of ethics in mathematics
- Frontier AI developers need an internal audit function
- Persona-Based Conversational AI: State of the Art and Challenges
- The Value-Sensitive Conversational Agent Co-Design Framework
- Specification Overfitting in Artificial Intelligence
- A Capability Approach to AI Ethics
- The Switch, the Ladder, and the Matrix: Models for Classifying AI Systems
- The social dilemma in artificial intelligence development and why we have to solve it
- A Shift In Artistic Practices through Artificial Intelligence
- BeFair: Addressing Fairness in the Banking Sector
- Software Engineering for Responsible AI: An Empirical Study and Operationalised Patterns
- ECCOLA -- a Method for Implementing Ethically Aligned AI Systems
- Blockchain-based Trustworthy Federated Learning Architecture
- Governance of Ethical and Trustworthy AI Systems: Research Gaps in the ECCOLA Method
- Epistemic Power in AI Ethics Labor: Legitimizing Located Complaints
- Macro Ethics Principles for Responsible AI Systems: Taxonomy and Future Directions
- Moral Dilemmas for Moral Machines
- Using Formal Methods for Autonomous Systems: Five Recipes for Formal Verification
- ESR: Ethics and Society Review of Artificial Intelligence Research
- Trustworthy AI in practice: an analysis of practitioners' needs and challenges
- RE-centric Recommendations for the Development of Trustworthy(er) Autonomous Systems
- African Data Ethics: A Discursive Framework for Black Decolonial Data Science
- What do we teach to engineering students: embedded ethics, morality, and politics
- Stakeholder Participation for Responsible AI Development: Disconnects Between Guidance and Current Practice
- The Sanction of Authority: Promoting Public Trust in AI
- Assessing Computer Science Student Attitudes Towards AI Ethics and Policy
- Negative Human Rights as a Basis for Long-term AI Safety and Regulation
- The Limits of Global Inclusion in AI Development
- FUTURE-AI: Guiding Principles and Consensus Recommendations for Trustworthy Artificial Intelligence in Medical Imaging
- POLARIS: A framework to guide the development of Trustworthy AI systems
- Resolving Ethics Trade-offs in Implementing Responsible AI
- Towards a Feminist Metaethics of AI
- Fairness Hacking: The Malicious Practice of Shrouding Unfairness in Algorithms
- Solidarity should be a core ethical principle of Artificial Intelligence
- Why business adoption of quantum and AI technology must be ethical
- The Future of Work Is Here: Toward a Comprehensive Approach to Artificial Intelligence and Labour
- AI and Ethics -- Operationalising Responsible AI
- Towards Artefact-based Requirements Engineering for Data-Centric Systems
- Human participants in AI research: Ethics and transparency in practice
- The corruptive force of AI-generated advice
- Good proctor or "Big Brother"? AI Ethics and Online Exam Supervision Technologies
- Supporting Industry Computing Researchers in Assessing, Articulating, and Addressing the Potential Negative Societal Impact of Their Work
- Beyond "Fairness:" Structural (In)justice Lenses on AI for Education
- Artificial Intelligence Ethics: An Inclusive Global Discourse?
- Ethics in conversation: Building an ethics assurance case for autonomous AI-enabled voice agents in healthcare
- On the Connection between Game-Theoretic Feature Attributions and Counterfactual Explanations
- Collective Privacy Recovery: Data-sharing Coordination via Decentralized Artificial Intelligence
- Who is Responsible When AI Fails? Mapping Causes, Entities, and Consequences of AI Privacy and Ethical Incidents
- C3AI: Crafting and Evaluating Constitutions for Constitutional AI
- Unravelling Responsibility for AI
- "Why do we do this?": Moral Stress and the Affective Experience of Ethics in Practice
- Technology as uncharted territory: Contextual integrity and the notion of AI as new ethical ground
- Skilled and Mobile: Survey Evidence of AI Researchers' Immigration Preferences
- Developing Future Human-Centered Smart Cities: Critical Analysis of Smart City Security, Interpretability, and Ethical Challenges
- Good AI for the Present of Humanity Democratizing AI Governance
- From the Pursuit of Universal AGI Architecture to Systematic Approach to Heterogenous AGI: Addressing Alignment, Energy, & AGI Grand Challenges
- A Deployment Model to Extend Ethically Aligned AI Implementation Method ECCOLA
- Open Player Modeling: Empowering Players through Data Transparency
- Disciplining Deliberation: A Sociotechnical Perspective on Machine Learning Trade-offs
- What should AI see? Using the Public's Opinion to Determine the Perception of an AI
- Model Cards Revisited: Bridging the Gap Between Theory and Practice for Ethical AI Requirements
- Give Me a Choice: The Consequences of Restricting Choices Through AI-Support for Perceived Autonomy, Motivational Variables, and Decision Performance
- Trustworthy, responsible, ethical AI in manufacturing and supply chains: synthesis and emerging research questions
- Design Considerations for Human Oversight of AI: Insights from Co-Design Workshops and Work Design Theory
- Survey on AI Ethics: A Socio-technical Perspective
- Educating a Responsible AI Workforce: Piloting a Curricular Module on AI Policy in a Graduate Machine Learning Course
- Towards More Trustworthy and Interpretable LLMs for Code through Syntax-Grounded Explanations
- Face Recognition: to Deploy or not to Deploy? A Framework for Assessing the Proportional Use of Face Recognition Systems in Real-World Scenarios
- Ethical Issues Regarding the Use of AI Profiling Services for Recruiting: The Japanese Rikunabi Data Scandal
- Multi-Agent LLMs as Ethics Advocates for AI-Based Systems
- Explainability Case Studies
- How Generative AI Empowers Attackers and Defenders Across the Trust & Safety Landscape
- Influential scientists shape knowledge flows between science and IGO policy
- Time Can Invalidate Algorithmic Recourse
- Building the ethical AI framework of the future: from philosophy to practice
- We Haven't Gone Paperless Yet: Why the Printing Press Can Help Us Understand Data and AI
- Why Talking about ethics is not enough: a proposal for Fintech's AI ethics
- Readying Medical Students for Medical AI: The Need to Embed AI Ethics Education
- FLRA: A Reference Architecture for Federated Learning Systems
- Predicting Trust In Autonomous Vehicles: Modeling Young Adult Psychosocial Traits, Risk-Benefit Attitudes, And Driving Factors With Machine Learning
- Signs for Ethical AI: A Route Towards Transparency
- Time for AI (Ethics) Maturity Model Is Now
- Insiders and Outsiders in Research on Machine Learning and Society
- Fair and Responsible AI: A Focus on the Ability to Contest
- A Human-Centered Privacy Approach (HCP) to AI
- Are machine learning technologies ready to be used for humanitarian work and development?
- Problem Learning: Towards the Free Will of Machines
- Personalized Constitutionally-Aligned Agentic Superego: Secure AI Behavior Aligned to Diverse Human Values
- AI Ethics Education in India: A Syllabus-Level Review of Computing Courses
- Machine Learning Featurizations for AI Hacking of Political Systems
- The societal and ethical relevance of computational creativity
- Artificial Intelligence Literacy and Sustainable Development: An Ethical Governance and Development Goals Framework
- Confucius, Cyberpunk and Mr. Science: Comparing AI ethics between China and the EU
- Not Quite 'Ask a Librarian': AI on the Nature, Value, and Future of LIS
- European Strategy on AI: Are we truly fostering social good?
- Nose to Glass: Looking In to Get Beyond
- Ethics in the digital era
- Conceptualising Contestability: Perspectives on Contesting Algorithmic Decisions
- Reconsidering CO2 emissions from Computer Vision
- "EHLO WORLD" -- Checking If Your Conversational AI Knows Right from Wrong
- Public Goods From Private Data -- An Efficacy and Justification Paradox for Digital Contact Tracing
- Toward Ethical AI Through Bayesian Uncertainty in Neural Question Answering
- P4AI: Approaching AI Ethics through Principlism
- CFL: Causally Fair Language Models Through Token-level Attribute Controlled Generation
- Evaluation of AI Ethics Tools in Language Models: A Developers' Perspective Case Study
- Responsible AI: The Good, The Bad, The AI
- StackingNet: Collective Inference Across Independent AI Foundation Models
- Ethics of Food Recommender Applications
- Auditing LLM-Governed Social Robots with Culture-Specific Moral Gradients
- Ethics and EU AI Act in Cases of Work Disability Risk and Alzheimer's Disease Risk Prediction