Spin-2 and the Weak Gravity Conjecture

Abstract

Recently, it has been argued that application of the Weak Gravity Conjecture (WGC) to spin-2 fields implies a universal upper bound on the cutoff of the effective theory for a single spin-2 field. We point out here that these arguments are largely spurious, because of the absence of states carrying spin-2 Stuckelberg $U(1)$ charge, and because of incorrect scaling assumptions. Known examples such as Kaluza-Klein theory that respect the usual WGC do so because of the existence of a genuine $U(1)$ field under which states are charged, as in the case of the Stuckelberg formulation of spin-1 theories, for which there is an unambiguously defined $U(1)$ charge. Theories of bigravity naturally satisfy a naive formulation of the WGC, $M_W<M_{\mathrm{Pl}}$, since the force of the massless graviton is always weaker than the massive spin-2 modes. It also follows that theories of massive gravity trivially satisfies this form of the WGC. We also point out that the identification of a massive spin-2 state in a truncated higher derivative theory, such as Einstein-Weyl-squared or its supergravity extension, bears no relationship with massive spin-2 states in the UV completion, contrary to previous statements in the literature. We also discuss the conjecture from a swampland perspective and show how the emergence of a universal upper bound on the cutoff relies on strong assumptions on the scale of the couplings between the spin-2 and other fields, an assumption which is known to be violated in explicit examples.

Improved discussions

References in corpus (26)

• Resummation of Massive Gravity
• On the Geometry of the String Landscape and the Swampland
• Causality, Analyticity and an IR Obstruction to UV Completion
• Symmetries and Strings in Field Theory and Gravity
• The Swampland: Introduction and Review
• Massive Gravity in Three Dimensions
• Infrared-modified gravities and massive gravitons
• On couplings to matter in massive (bi-)gravity
• Ghosts & Matter Couplings in Massive (bi-&multi-)Gravity
• Positivity Bounds for Massive Spin-1 and Spin-2 Fields
• Positivity bounds on vector boson scattering at the LHC
• Spin-2 spectrum of defect theories
• Riding on irrelevant operators
• Photon Masses in the Landscape and the Swampland
• Positivity Constraints for Pseudo-linear Massive Spin-2 and Vector Galileons
• Appearance of Boulware-Deser ghost in bigravity with doubly coupled matter
• A Model Independent Ultraviolet Cutoff for Theories with Charged Massive Higher Spin Fields
• Massive Anti-de Sitter Gravity from String Theory
• A Spin-2 Conjecture on the Swampland
• A Universal Bound on the Strong Coupling Scale of a Gravitationally Coupled Massive Spin-2 Particle
• On the (A)dS Decoupling Limits of Massive Gravity
• A Scale-up of Lambda_3
• Bimetric, Conformal Supergravity and its Superstring Embedding
• Massive AdS Supergravitons and Holography
• Ghost-free infinite derivative gravity
• Black Hole Mechanics for Massive Gravitons

Cited by in corpus (12)

• Festina Lente: EFT Constraints from Charged Black Hole Evaporation in de Sitter
• The Speed of Gravity
• Black Hole Gravitational Waves in the Effective Field Theory of Gravity
• Causality in Curved Spacetimes: The Speed of Light & Gravity
• Asymptotic Safety: Swampland or Wonderland?
• Positivity Constraints on Interacting Pseudo-Linear Spin-2 Fields
• Spinning Sum Rules for the Dimension-Six SMEFT
• Islands and Light Gravitons in type IIB String Theory
• Causality Constraints in Large $N$ QCD Coupled to Gravity
• SCoRe: A New Framework to Study Unmodeled Physics from Gravitational Wave Data
• Hitchhiker's Guide to the Swampland: The Cosmologist's Handbook to the string-theoretical Swampland Programme
• Causality, unitarity and stability in quantum gravity: a non-perturbative perspective