Combining multiple structural inversions to constrain the Solar modelling problem

Abstract

The Sun is the most studied of all stars. It is a reference for all other observed stars and a laboratory of fundamental physics helping us understand processes occuring in conditions irreproducible on Earth. However, our understanding of the Sun is currently stained by the solar modelling problem which can stem from various causes, such as the opacities, the equation of state and the mixing of chemical elements. We combine inversions of sound speed, an entropy proxy and the Ledoux discriminant with constraints such as the position of the base of the convective zone and the photospheric helium abundance. We test various combinations of standard ingredients for solar modelling such as abundance tables, equation of state, formalism for convection and diffusion and opacity tables and study the diagnostic potential of the inversions to constrain ad-hoc modifications of the opacity profile and additional mixing below the convective envelope. Combining inversions provides stringent constraints on the modifications on the models, far beyond what is achievable only from sound speed inversions. We constrain the form and amplitude of the opacity increase required and show that a 15% increase at log T=6.35 provides a significant improvement but that a more global increase of the opacity, within the uncertainties of current tables, coupled with an additional mixing at the bottom of the convective zone gives the best agreement for low metallicity models. We show that high metallicity models do not satisfy all the inversion results. We conclude that the solar problem likely occurs from various small sources, as ingredients such as the equation of state or the formalism of convection can induce small but significant changes and that using phase shift analyses combined with our approach is the next step for a better understanding of the inaccuracies of solar models just below the convective envelope.

arXiv commentAccepted for publication in Astronomy and Astrophysics

References in corpus (55)

• The chemical composition of the Sun
• Low Temperature Opacities
• Astrophysics Source Code Library
• Solar Chemical Abundances Determined with a CO5BOLD 3D Model Atmosphere
• Solar fusion cross sections II: the pp chain and CNO cycles
• Line formation in solar granulation: IV. [O I], OI and OH lines and the photospheric O abundance
• Element Diffusion in the Solar Interior
• Updated Electron-Conduction Opacities: The Impact on Low-Mass Stellar Models
• Helioseismology and Solar Abundances
• Up-dated opacities from the Opacity Project
• Influence of gravity waves on the internal rotation and Li abundance of solar-type stars
• A new Generation of Standard Solar Models
• New Solar Composition: The Problem With Solar Models Revisited
• Stellar Turbulent Convection: A Selfconsistent Model
• The elemental composition of the Sun II. The iron group elements Sc to Ni
• Implications of WMAP observations on Li abundance and stellar evolution models
• Line formation in solar granulation VI. [C I], C I, CH and C2 lines and the photospheric C abundance
• CLES, Code Liegeois d'Evolution Stellaire
• The elemental composition of the Sun I. The intermediate mass elements Na to Ca
• Standard Solar models in the Light of New Helioseismic Constraints II. Mixing Below the Convective Zone
• A New Generation of Los Alamos Opacity Tables
• The elemental composition of the Sun III. The heavy elements Cu to Th
• Stellar Evolution with Rotation and Magnetic Fields IV: The Solar Rotation Profile
• Fresh insights on the structure of the solar core
• The Liege Oscillation Code
• A more realistic representation of overshoot at the base of the solar convective envelope as seen by helioseismology
• The discrepancy between solar abundances and helioseismology
• Asymptotic g modes: Evidence for a rapid rotation of the solar core
• Can Enhanced Diffusion Improve Helioseismic Agreement for Solar Models with Revised Abundances?
• Exploring mass loss, low-Z accretion, and convective overshoot in solar models to mitigate the solar abundance problem
• Seismic tests for solar models with tachocline mixing
• Toward a consistent use of overshooting parametrizations in 1D stellar evolution codes
• On the choice of parameters in solar structure inversion
• On the surface physics affecting solar oscillation frequencies
• Element abundance ratios in the quiet Sun transition region
• Estimating stellar mean density through seismic inversions
• Large enhancement in high-energy photoionization of Fe XVII and missing continuum plasma opacity
• Our Sun. IV. The Standard Model and Helioseismology: Consequences of Uncertainties in Input Physics and in Observed Solar Parameters
• Solar overshoot region and small-scale dynamo with realistic energy flux
• Prospects for asteroseismology
• Fragile detection of solar g modes by Fossat et al
• On the hydrostatic stratification of the solar tachocline
• Microscopic diffusion of partly ionized metals in the Sun and metal-poor stars
• First solar models with OPAS opacity tables
• Evolution of lithium abundance in the Sun and solar twins
• Determining the metallicity of the solar envelope using seismic inversion techniques
• Comment on "Large enhancement in high-energy photoionization of Fe XVII and missing continuum plasma opacity"
• Comparisons for Esta-Task3: Cles and Cesam
• Helioseismic Measurements in the Solar Envelope Using Group Velocities of Surface Waves
• Seismic inversion of the solar entropy: A case for improving the Standard Solar Model
• Inversions of the Ledoux discriminant: a closer look at the tachocline
• A method for the estimation of p-mode parameters from averaged solar oscillation power spectra
• On the computation of eigenfrequencies for equilibrium models including turbulent pressure
• The solar abundance problem: the effect of the turbulent kinetic flux on the solar envelope model
• Microscopic Diffusion in Stellar Evolution Codes: First Comparison results of ESTA-Task~3

Cited by in corpus (23)

• The chemical make-up of the Sun: A 2020 vision
• Observational constraints on the origin of the elements. IV: The standard composition of the Sun
• Solar structure and evolution
• The Future of Solar Neutrinos
• The 3D non-LTE solar nitrogen abundance from atomic lines
• Higher metal abundances do not solve the solar problem
• Imprint of planet formation in the deep interior of the Sun
• Extended atomic data for oxygen abundance analyses
• Helioseismic inference of the solar radiative opacity
• Interpolation of equation-of-state data
• Rotating Solar Models in Agreement with Helioseismic Results and Updated Neutrino Fluxes
• Local heating due to convective overshooting and the solar modelling problem
• The solar abundance problem and eMSTOs in clusters
• Core overshoot constrained by the absence of a solar convective core and some solar-like stars
• The age of the Methuselah star in light of stellar evolution models with tailored abundances
• Testing a non-local 1-equation turbulent convection model: A solar model
• Solar Models and Astrophysical S-factors Constrained by Helioseismic Results and Updated Neutrino Fluxes
• Solar models with protosolar accretion and turbulent mixing
• The impact of the transport of chemicals and electronic screening on helioseismic and neutrino observations in solar models
• Testing the 3-equation Kuhfuss Convection Model using the Sun
• Investigating the impact of Solar Fusion III reaction rates on helioseismic constraints and solar neutrino fluxes
• A data-driven estimate of the protosolar helium mass fraction
• Global Helioseismology