The Many Definitions of a Black Hole

Abstract

Although black holes are objects of central importance across many fields of physics, there is no agreed upon definition for them, a fact that does not seem to be widely recognized. Physicists in different fields conceive of and reason about them in radically different, and often conflicting, ways. All those ways, however, seem sound in the relevant contexts. After examining and comparing many of the definitions used in practice, I consider the problems that the lack of a universally accepted definition leads to, and discuss whether one is in fact needed for progress in the physics of black holes. I conclude that, within reasonable bounds, the profusion of different definitions is in fact a virtue, making the investigation of black holes possible and fruitful in all the many different kinds of problems about them that physicists consider, although one must take care in trying to translate results between fields.

33 pages, 29 pages of text, 4 tables; previously titled "What Is a Black Hole?"

References in corpus (4)

• The region with trapped surfaces in spherical symmetry, its core, and their boundaries
• Ten Proofs of the Generalized Second Law
• Black Holes as Quantum Gravity Condensates
• Classical Black Holes Are Hot

Cited by in corpus (35)

• Testing the nature of dark compact objects: a status report
• The $8Pmmn$ borophene sheet: A solid-state platform for space-time engineering
• On the Universality of Hawking Radiation
• Schematizing the Observer and the Epistemic Content of Theories
• Curvature Invariants and Lower Dimensional Black Hole Horizons
• Penrose's 1965 singularity theorem: From geodesic incompleteness to cosmic censorship
• Singularities, black holes, and cosmic censorship: A tribute to Roger Penrose
• On the Limits of Experimental Knowledge
• Self-consistent description of a spherically-symmetric gravitational collapse
• Universal properties of the near-horizon geometry
• Pandora's box lid: geometry near the apparent horizon
• Kerr-Vaidya black holes
• Atemporality from Conservation Laws of Physics in Lorentzian-Euclidean Black Hole
• Nomen non est omen: Why it is too soon to identify ultra-compact objects as black holes
• Black holes as spherically-symmetric horizon-bound objects
• Semiclassical black holes and horizon singularities
• The Next Generation Event Horizon Telescope Collaboration: History, Philosophy, and Culture
• Matter and forces near physical black holes
• Physical black holes in fourth-order gravity
• Thermodynamic phase transition and winding number for the third-order Lovelock black hole
• Models of cosmological black holes
• Are quantum corrections on horizon scale physically motivated?
• The Devil in the (Implicit) Details. On the AMPS Paradox and its Resolution
• Spherically symmetric black holes in metric gravity
• Emergence and Correspondence for String Theory Black Holes
• A dialog on the fate of information in black hole evaporation
• Physical black holes in semiclassical gravity
• On the Definition of Black Holes: Bridging the Gap Between Black Holes and Singularities
• Basics of Apparent Horizons in Black Hole Physics
• Exotic Encounters: Buchdahl's Conditions and Physical Black Holes
• A note on Strong Cosmic Censorship and its violation in Reissner-Nordström de Sitter black hole space-times
• Reissner-Nordström black holes in de Sitter space-time: bounds with quasinormal frequencies
• Constraining modified gravity theories with physical black holes
• Detection of quantum entanglement across the event horizon
• Black holes and their horizons in semiclassical and modified theories of gravity