Comparing randomized benchmarking figure with average infidelity of quantum gate-set

Abstract

Randomized benchmarking (RB) is a popular procedure used to gauge the performance of a set of gates useful for quantum information processing (QIP). Recently, Proctor et al. [Phys. Rev. Lett. 119, 130502 (2017)] demonstrated a practically relevant example where the RB measurements give a number $r$ very different from the actual average gate-set infidelity $\epsilon$, despite past theoretical assurances that the two should be equal. Here, we derive formulas for $\epsilon$, and for $r$ from the RB protocol, in a manner permitting easy comparison of the two. We show in general that, indeed, $r\ne \epsilon$, i.e., RB does not measure average infidelity, and, in fact, neither one bounds the other. We give several examples, all plausible in real experiments, to illustrate the differences in $\epsilon$ and $r$. Many recent papers on experimental implementations of QIP have claimed the ability to perform high-fidelity gates because they demonstrated small $r$ values using RB. Our analysis shows that such a statement from RB alone has to be interpreted with caution.

arXiv comment9 pages, 1 figure

References in corpus (46)

• Mixed State Entanglement and Quantum Error Correction
• Logic gates at the surface code threshold: Superconducting qubits poised for fault-tolerant quantum computing
• Randomized Benchmarking of Quantum Gates
• An addressable quantum dot qubit with fault-tolerant control fidelity
• Prescription for experimental determination of the dynamics of a quantum black box
• Robust randomized benchmarking of quantum processes
• A simple formula for the average gate fidelity of a quantum dynamical operation
• Complete Characterization of a Quantum Process: the Two-Bit Quantum Gate
• Exact and Approximate Unitary 2-Designs: Constructions and Applications
• High-fidelity preparation, gates, memory and readout of a trapped-ion quantum bit
• Scalable Noise Estimation with Random Unitary Operators
• Characterizing Quantum Gates via Randomized Benchmarking
• Efficient measurement of quantum gate error by interleaved randomized benchmarking
• Characterization of addressability by simultaneous randomized benchmarking
• Symmetrised Characterisation of Noisy Quantum Processes
• Experimental fault-tolerant universal quantum gates with solid-state spins under ambient conditions
• Randomized benchmarking and process tomography for gate errors in a solid-state qubit
• Randomized benchmarking of single qubit gates in a 2D array of neutral atom qubits
• Optimal quantum control using randomized benchmarking
• Implementing optimal control pulse shaping for improved single-qubit gates
• Process verification of two-qubit quantum gates by randomized benchmarking
• Estimating the Coherence of Noise
• Fidelity of Single Qubit Maps
• Randomized Benchmarking with Confidence
• Gate fidelity and coherence of an electron spin in a Si/SiGe quantum dot with micromagnet
• Characterizing errors on qubit operations via iterative randomized benchmarking
• Electrically controlling single spin qubits in a continuous microwave field
• Quantifying the quantum gate fidelity of single-atom spin qubits in silicon by randomized benchmarking
• Investigating the limits of randomized benchmarking protocols
• Contractivity of positive and trace preserving maps under $L_p$ norms
• Randomized Benchmarking of Multi-Qubit Gates
• What randomized benchmarking actually measures
• Randomized benchmarking of single and multi-qubit control in liquid-state NMR quantum information processing
• Characterizing Universal Gate Sets via Dihedral Benchmarking
• Randomized benchmarking with gate-dependent noise
• The effect of noise correlations on randomized benchmarking
• Non-exponential Fidelity Decay in Randomized Benchmarking with Low-Frequency Noise
• Experimentally scalable protocol for identification of correctable codes
• Randomized benchmarking of atomic qubits in an optical lattice
• Gate-error analysis in simulations of quantum computers with transmon qubits
• Practical experimental certification of computational quantum gates via twirling
• Accelerated Randomized Benchmarking
• Robust Characterization of Loss Rates
• Rolling quantum dice with a superconducting qubit
• From randomized benchmarking experiments to gateset circuit fidelity: how to interpret randomized benchmarking decay parameters
• Randomized benchmarking of quantum gates implemented by electron spin resonance

Cited by in corpus (6)

• Extensive characterization of a family of efficient three-qubit gates at the coherence limit
• Noisy Qudit vs Multiple Qubits : Conditions on Gate Efficiency for Enhancing Fidelity
• Randomized Benchmarking as Convolution: Fourier Analysis of Gate Dependent Errors
• Benchmarking universal quantum gates via channel spectrum
• Randomized benchmarking in the presence of time-correlated dephasing noise
• Reliable Characterization for Improving and Validating Accurate Quantum Operations